Benny's Big Time Pizzeria

206 Greenfield St, Wilmington
(910) 550-2525

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Thursday Cheeseburger Special with Fried Mozzarella Slice
Kevin McCallister Pizza with Hot Honey Sauce
Gluten Free Detroit Style Pizza
Chopped Salad Red Weapon Ranch
Southern Fried Chicken Parm
Meeting of the Minds Pizza
Charred Brussel Sprouts
Talk'in Shiitake Pizza
Olive Oil Cake Zeppole
Fungus Among Us Pizza

Menu

Featured items
MARGHERITA
red sauce, basil, fior di latte (fancy mozz)
TONY PEPPERONI
red sauce, pepperoni, mozzarella, oregano
LUNCH FOR 2
Margherita Pizza, Lg House Salad + 2 cans of soda
CONSTRUCTION ZONE
Build your own pie. Keep it simple, if you get greedy your pizza will suffer.
KEVIN MCCALISTER
grayson taleggio, mozzarella, hot honey
MEATING OF THE MINDS
Red sauce, mozz, 'nduja, pepperoni, sausage, pancetta, red onion, basil, Parm
PIZZA ALLA CARBONARA
white sauce, mozz, pecorino, garlic, red onion, chicken, pancetta, parsley, yolk
PINEAPPLE EXPRESS
pineapple jam, mozz, Calabrian & serrano chilies, speck & mint
LITTLE GREENIE
red sauce, garlic, pickled red onion, brussels sprouts, mixed greens, guindilla peppers, nutritional yeast, Calabrian chili

BENNY'S BIG TIMERS
LUNCH FOR 2
Margherita Pizza, Lg House Salad + 2 cans of soda
PIZZA PACKS - 3 KEVIN McCALLISTER'S
Our wildly popular cheese pizza for adults - not adults only. The combination of the funky taleggio cheese and Benny's Hot Honey is now a little cheaper to hoard. Go for it.
PIZZA PACKS - 3 TONY PEPPERONI'S
Why not have another slice? Or, keep a little Toni Pepp in the fridge in case of emergency. Either way, we got you covered.
BENNY'S HOT HONEY BEARS 6OZ
Feeling like the little cup of Benny's Hot Honey is just never enough? Stock up with the Honey Bear!

SALADS
BENNY'S CAESAR
fried & raw brussels sprouts, romaine, pecorino, lemon, house-made crouton
HOUSE SALAD
green leaf lettuces, red onion, pickled peppers, smoky croutons, pecorino, house Italian vinaigrette

PIZZA (12-14 INCH WOOD FIRED)
CONSTRUCTION ZONE
Build your own pie. Keep it simple, if you get greedy your pizza will suffer.
KEVIN MCCALISTER
grayson taleggio, mozzarella, hot honey
TONY PEPPERONI
red sauce, pepperoni, mozzarella, oregano
MARGHERITA
red sauce, basil, fior di latte (fancy mozz)
MEATING OF THE MINDS
Red sauce, mozz, 'nduja, pepperoni, sausage, pancetta, red onion, basil, Parm
TALK'IN SHITAKE
Ricotta white sauce, sausage, shitake & cremini mushroom, fennel, mozz, parm, garlic, olive
PINEAPPLE EXPRESS
pineapple jam, mozz, Calabrian & serrano chilies, speck & mint
LITTLE GREENIE
red sauce, garlic, pickled red onion, brussels sprouts, mixed greens, guindilla peppers, nutritional yeast, Calabrian chili
PIZZA ALLA CARBONARA
white sauce, mozz, pecorino, garlic, red onion, chicken, pancetta, parsley, yolk
PLAIN CHEESE PIZZA

Featured items
MARGHERITA
red sauce, basil, fior di latte (fancy mozz)
TONY PEPPERONI
red sauce, pepperoni, mozzarella, oregano
KEVIN MCCALISTER
Ricotta white sauce, taleggio, mozzarella, hot honey
MEATING OF THE MINDS
Red sauce, mozz, 'nduja, pepperoni, sausage, guanciale, red onion, basil, Parm
THE CONSTRUCTION ZONE
Build your own pie. Keep it simple, if you get greedy your pizza will suffer.
TALK'IN SHIITAKE
ricotta white sauce,sausage, shiitake & cremini mushroom, fennel, mozz, parm, garlic, olive
GLUTEN FREE DETROIT STYLE PIZZA
Our gluten free DETROIT style pizza crust is amazing! Our standard comes with cheese and sauce but you can build your own pizza, just as you like it or ask for a GF version of one of our specialty pies.
PIZZA ALLA CARBONARA
white sauce, mozz, pecorino, garlic, red onion, pancetta, parsley, raw egg yolk
PINEAPPLE EXPRESS
pineapple jam, mozz, Calabrian & serrano chilies, speck & mint
LITTLE GREENIE
red sauce, garlic, pickled red onion, brussels sprouts, mixed greens, guindilla peppers, nutritional yeast, Calabrian chili

BIG TIMERS
BENNY'S HOT HONEY BEARS 6oz
Feeling like the little cup of Benny's Hot Honey is just never enough? Stock up with the Honey Bear!
PIZZA PACKS - 3 KEVIN McCALLISTER'S
Our wildly popular cheese pizza for adults - not adults only. The combination of the funky taleggio cheese and Benny's Hot Honey is now a little cheaper to hoard. Go for it.
PIZZA PACKS - 3 TONY PEPPERONI'S
Why not have another slice? Or, keep a little Toni Pepp in the fridge in case of emergency. Either way, we got you covered.

BENNY'S SALADS, ANTIPASTI & FRIED STUFF
FRIED MOZZ
fried mozz fritters, w/ Marinara
BENNY'S CAESAR
fried & raw brussels sprouts, romaine, pecorino, lemon, Little Green Dress, house-made crouton
HOUSE SALAD
head lettuces, red onion, pickled peppers, smoky croutons, pecorino, house Italian vinaigrette
BENNY'S CHICKEN PARM
stracciatella, hot honey, pickled peppers, sage
CHARRED BRUSSEL SPROUTS
charred radicchio, dried cranberry, golden balsamic vinaigrette, pecorino

BENNY'S PIZZA (12-14 INCH WOOD FIRED)
MARGHERITA
red sauce, basil, fior di latte (fancy mozz)
THE CONSTRUCTION ZONE
Build your own pie. Keep it simple, if you get greedy your pizza will suffer.
TONY PEPPERONI
red sauce, pepperoni, mozzarella, oregano
KEVIN MCCALISTER
Ricotta white sauce, taleggio, mozzarella, hot honey
MEATING OF THE MINDS
Red sauce, mozz, 'nduja, pepperoni, sausage, guanciale, red onion, basil, Parm
GLUTEN FREE DETROIT STYLE PIZZA
Our gluten free DETROIT style pizza crust is amazing! Our standard comes with cheese and sauce but you can build your own pizza, just as you like it or ask for a GF version of one of our specialty pies.
LITTLE GREENIE
red sauce, garlic, pickled red onion, brussels sprouts, mixed greens, guindilla peppers, nutritional yeast, Calabrian chili
PIZZA ALLA CARBONARA
white sauce, mozz, pecorino, garlic, red onion, pancetta, parsley, raw egg yolk
TALK'IN SHIITAKE
ricotta white sauce,sausage, shiitake & cremini mushroom, fennel, mozz, parm, garlic, olive
PINEAPPLE EXPRESS
pineapple jam, mozz, Calabrian & serrano chilies, speck & mint
PLAIN CHEESE PIZZA
red sauce, fresh mozzarella

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+55 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+54 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I booked a reservation at Benny’s Big Time before even booking my flight to town—yes, it’s that good. This is the kind of place where we already knew our order before glancing at the menu: the Benny’s Caesar to start (a must), followed by the iconic vodka pasta and the Pineapple Express pizza—both consistently crave-worthy.

A surprise highlight was the Friday night Lambrusco special, which paired perfectly with the meal and set a fun, laid-back tone....
July 2025
The service here was truly excellent—everyone was incredibly friendly and welcoming, and I really appreciated how attentive the staff was. That said, I was disappointed with the pizza. It just didn’t hit the mark for me. The crust was too floppy, and it tasted like it was missing cheese or something to bring it all together. For the price, I expected a lot more flavor and quality. I really wanted to love it, especially with how great the service was, but unfortunately, the...
July 2025
Food is always amazing. Pizza and Friday night fish and chips are our go to dishes. We also tried the burnt ends and we will be getting those each time we go now too. We’ve been several time and had Angus the last few, he’s always very friendly and helpful! We will be back again soon!
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Satellite Bar and Lounge - 120 Greenfield St #6123
Bar, Lounges, Music Venues, Pet Friendly
Block Taco - 120 Greenfield St #B
Tacos, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian
Ellipsis | Unique Culinary Experiences & Events - 1502 S 3rd St
Seafood, Vegan

Benny's Big Time Pizzeria

206 Greenfield St, Wilmington, NC 28401
(910) 550-2525