Best pizza in Wilmington! Closest to NY style pizza around. The 5 stars for atmosphere are that it feels like a Brooklyn neighborhood pizzeria, no pretension. Nothing fancy just sit down and eat your slice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bryan
Great food
D P
My wife and I had dinner there while visiting Wilmington. After shopping, we wanted pizza and took to Google to look close by. It was very obvious that Brooklyn is geared more toward takeout and delivery than the dine in experience. You order at the counter and they bring the food out to your table. Everything thing else is self serve. We were too late for pizza by the slice, so we elected to split wings and a stromboli. I felt like the wings were frozen precooked, heated in the oven, and sauced. The buffalo sauce a traditional buffalo and delicious in my opinion. The stromboli, while delicious, was only a partial and missing my favorite part, the ends. I love the doughy ends of the stromboli. The marinara was simple, but delicious in my opinion. The drink choices were only can drinks. The staff was pleasant and courteous. Overall it was a good experience. It would definitely be a regular place for takeout, if I lived in the area.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
travelbug08502
One of the best pizza’s I’ve had in Wilmington. The place is small but worth dining in because having the pizza right out of the oven was incredible. We shared among 4 people a slice of the Grandma’s pie, which was like a Sicilian with roasted tomatoes on top. The dough was light and airy with a nice firm, crisp bottom. We also shared a cheese calzone which was delicious. The dough was thin and crispy with a generous portion of ricotta and mozzarella inside. The side sauce was very good. Finally we tried the large sausage pizza. The sausage was sliced and a generous amount was given. We boxed up our leftovers to enjoy another day. If you are in the area, you must try this place.
Janice Cavuto
This pizza is the closest we found to NJ pizza! The large is HUGE!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Vincoli
This is my granddaughter’s favorite pizza. We brought one home and loved it. Give it a try you will enjoy the staff as well as the pizza. They work hard and friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Swaave Too_Smooth
Those are all my guys. Everytime I go in pizza is always on point. Older Mexican dude puts love into that dough. By far favorite pizza in Wilmington.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
lainie joy
Just moved down here from Brooklyn Me and my son went for lunch today and both agreed it made us feel like home Will def be back
Rhonda Jordan
Phone service wasn't great. Very dismissive. But in person was better. Pizza wasn't good. The Oleander location is great. I will probably go there moving forward.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Susan M
Ordered a pizza yesterday. Price was 16.50. I paid with a card and gave a cash tip. Got home to see my credit card was charged 18.50. Can’t believe they added a tip on my card without my authorization. Pizza was good but that is horrible customer service. Very disappointed and I won’t go back.
Really a pizza at a really great price. My friend and I went with our kids and when they brought our pizza to the table they even offered to kids cut their pieces. Super helpful when you're juggling toddlers!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert Swartwout
Connecticut native guy here. Living in Sneads Ferry now. This is a very good pizza joint. Give it a try.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
Megan Lopez
Decided to give this place a try after reading a good amount of the reviews. I want to start by saying, the customer service and wait time was great but I felt disappointed with the Sicilian pie. A solid 3/5 stars. I’m a New Haven native so I’m used to good quality pizza and never expect to have the same BUT I was quite disappointed with this pie.
Let me begin by saying the dough was amazing. It was crunchy, held structure and had good flavor. But the canned mushrooms, extreme lack of flavor from the sauce and absurd amount of cheese really threw me off… I also got a free order of garlic knots that were packed with flavor which was great but the pizza was a huge let down. If I’m being honest, the sauce just tasted like canned crushed tomatoes rather than a good quality pizza sauce. I’ve included a photo of what my Sicilian pie from a local Italian pizza shop near me typically looks like vs the one from here.
I also felt a bit disappointed that they were not able to deliver 13 minutes away from their location. Again 3/5 stars from my experience. I appreciate the kind service but there’s definitely room for growth in multiple areas for their pies. I’d be willing to try Brooklyn Pizza Co Market st location again in a few weeks to see if things improve. If not, unfortunately this just isn’t the place for me.
Best pizza in Wilmington! Closest to NY style pizza around. The 5 stars for atmosphere are that it feels like a Brooklyn neighborhood pizzeria, no pretension. Nothing fancy just sit down and eat your slice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food
My wife and I had dinner there while visiting Wilmington. After shopping, we wanted pizza and took to Google to look close by. It was very obvious that Brooklyn is geared more toward takeout and delivery than the dine in experience. You order at the counter and they bring the food out to your table. Everything thing else is self serve. We were too late for pizza by the slice, so we elected to split wings and a stromboli. I felt like the wings were frozen precooked, heated in the oven, and sauced. The buffalo sauce a traditional buffalo and delicious in my opinion. The stromboli, while delicious, was only a partial and missing my favorite part, the ends. I love the doughy ends of the stromboli. The marinara was simple, but delicious in my opinion. The drink choices were only can drinks. The staff was pleasant and courteous. Overall it was a good experience. It would definitely be a regular place for takeout, if I lived in the area.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
One of the best pizza’s I’ve had in Wilmington. The place is small but worth dining in because having the pizza right out of the oven was incredible. We shared among 4 people a slice of the Grandma’s pie, which was like a Sicilian with roasted tomatoes on top. The dough was light and airy with a nice firm, crisp bottom. We also shared a cheese calzone which was delicious. The dough was thin and crispy with a generous portion of ricotta and mozzarella inside. The side sauce was very good. Finally we tried the large sausage pizza. The sausage was sliced and a generous amount was given. We boxed up our leftovers to enjoy another day. If you are in the area, you must try this place.
This pizza is the closest we found to NJ pizza! The large is HUGE!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is my granddaughter’s favorite pizza. We brought one home and loved it. Give it a try you will enjoy the staff as well as the pizza. They work hard and friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Those are all my guys. Everytime I go in pizza is always on point. Older Mexican dude puts love into that dough. By far favorite pizza in Wilmington.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just moved down here from Brooklyn
Me and my son went for lunch today and both agreed it made us feel like home
Will def be back
Phone service wasn't great. Very dismissive. But in person was better. Pizza wasn't good. The Oleander location is great. I will probably go there moving forward.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Ordered a pizza yesterday. Price was 16.50. I paid with a card and gave a cash tip. Got home to see my credit card was charged 18.50. Can’t believe they added a tip on my card without my authorization. Pizza was good but that is horrible customer service. Very disappointed and I won’t go back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
They have THE BEST pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really a pizza at a really great price. My friend and I went with our kids and when they brought our pizza to the table they even offered to kids cut their pieces. Super helpful when you're juggling toddlers!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Connecticut native guy here. Living in Sneads Ferry now. This is a very good pizza joint. Give it a try.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
Decided to give this place a try after reading a good amount of the reviews. I want to start by saying, the customer service and wait time was great but I felt disappointed with the Sicilian pie. A solid 3/5 stars. I’m a New Haven native so I’m used to good quality pizza and never expect to have the same BUT I was quite disappointed with this pie.
Let me begin by saying the dough was amazing. It was crunchy, held structure and had good flavor. But the canned mushrooms, extreme lack of flavor from the sauce and absurd amount of cheese really threw me off… I also got a free order of garlic knots that were packed with flavor which was great but the pizza was a huge let down. If I’m being honest, the sauce just tasted like canned crushed tomatoes rather than a good quality pizza sauce. I’ve included a photo of what my Sicilian pie from a local Italian pizza shop near me typically looks like vs the one from here.
I also felt a bit disappointed that they were not able to deliver 13 minutes away from their location. Again 3/5 stars from my experience. I appreciate the kind service but there’s definitely room for growth in multiple areas for their pies. I’d be willing to try Brooklyn Pizza Co Market st location again in a few weeks to see if things improve. If not, unfortunately this just isn’t the place for me.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Good pizza, great value.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...