Brooklyn Pizza Co.

The food was fresh and very good. Staff were helpful and there were solid seating options both inside and outside. The “typical cheese” pizza isn’t on the menu, but if you ask for a “small cheese,” it’s just right for younger kids. My 7 and 6-year-olds loved it. I ordered wings, a small cheese, and two large slices of pepperoni all for $40 including a 20% tip. We’ll be back soon.

I have always loved this place, the food is absolutely delicious, but today I wasn’t feeling well so I ordered delivery instead of picking it up. I made a joke about it in my delivery notes, and they wrote a sweet note saying “Feel Better” attached to a container of 2 cannolis! 🥹 So thoughtful, what great customer service!

(Whoever is working lunch on 5/22 - thank you!!)

When you accidentally burn someone's order, simply apologize and make another one. Don't expect them to rave about your food and service. Accept responsibility and fix it. Do that, and you will have a customer for life. Don't, and potential customers will go to another restaurant. Treat people the way you want them to treat you.

Great food. Huge portion sizes! Nice to see a true NY pizza spot in the South.

Went on Saturday afternoon 4,19,25 Pizza was fantastic, staff and service was to relaxed. We sat outside to eat our pizza and nobody once came out to check on us . If I would of known that I would not of tipped the guy while ordering. Back to Antonio's and Marcos we go.

I had a girls weekend down in SC and worked with Otto to plan some half trays of their delicious entrees to bring along. He went above and beyond to be sure everything was perfect! We had delicious meals every night and didn’t have to cook a thing - just reheat! I cannot recommend Brooklyn Pizza enough - not only for their delicious food but for their outstanding customer service! Thanks, again, Otto!

Pizza was quite good but so expensive-almost $30.00 for a large one item is way too much. Might have bumped it up to a four but the dark haired young lady who took our order had zero personality-acted like we were bothering her and never made eye contact. For that price a little customer service should be in order. Won’t be back.

Great food fast service

I love the pizza, but it's hit or miss. I don't know if they scrape their ovens regularly during the day or if they are leaving my pizza in too long, but half the time I end up with burnt pizza, so disappointing!

Grandma Pizza Slice is my favorite!!

Had a large pizza and the slices were huge ans good. Also had wings. They were good too..so watch how you order cause we definitely ate pizza the next day..lol

Something has changed, our pizza did not meet our expectations. We ordered extra cheese; it was not added; anchovies- they were out of, no garlic butter. In short the pizza was mediocre at best.

I am a self-described pizza snob from Brooklyn. The pizza is authentic to New York. The Sicilian slice is exceptional! It’s hard to find a Sicilian slice and when you do, it’s hard to find one that’s done right this place nailed it.
Their regular slices are good as well nice and crispy. The sausage is real sausage not those sausage crumbles you get at other places.
Their chicken marsala is amazing! You can actually cut the chicken with a fork. Very flavorful good sized portion.
If you’re looking for authentic New York style pizza in Wilmington, this is your place!

Love this place! Always a fantastic meal. Friendly staff and a clean restaurant. I always make a point to stop when I am visiting Willmington.

Haven't left the parking lot yet and wanted to take a look and bite of my fresh large cheese.

Easy 7.5/10 za; any chain pizza doesn't hold a candle to this. Great crunch, beautiful undercarriage, good cheese. Nothing sliding off the top and not so oily you could save some and toast bread with. The folks working were kind enough and easy to talk to. Must-go pizza place. Definitely returning.

If you want to know if it's good the next day cold, respond to this or send a direct message because I'm not coming back to this post to update it