Jay's Incredible Pizza

Best pizza we’ve had on our trips to Wilmington.. my daughter and son in law live here.. thanks for the consistency of a good Pizza!

Best pizza in Wilmington as far as I'm concerned. Any and every pizza packed full of taste and toppings.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

With my foot at first glance, it does not appear to be the fanciest of pizza places however it does have a small non-franchised charm to it. Some other pizza place is like the mask bad pizza with fancy surroundings. That’s however, is the opposite. it’s just a hard-core pizza kitchen. They sell pizza by the slice or whole pies. The food is incredible. The marinara sauce is nice and smooth, not overstated, but kind of like a wonderful warm bath on your tongue. Very soothing and reassuring. So the thing that really sold it for me was the Great attitude of all of the staff and the way they engaged with us. My child included. They were willing to converse didn’t have any negative or bad attitudes and were overall very helpful. Very kind and that made the great food all the better. I highly recommend Jay’s incredible pizza for anybody on a pizza mission and the value cannot be beat $20 to feed myself my wife and my child. Phenomenal!

Kid-friendliness: There’s no play place, but they definitely are accommodating to the little ones

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Ordered from their catering menu. Chicken Parmesan, barbecue chicken and salad. It was glorious food. Very well done. I highly recommend Jay’s Pizza. Their pizza and the rest are also wonderful. Great prices too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: BBQ Wings, Lasagna, Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza

Best pizza ever, highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I’ve been away and a couple of years later, so glad to see Jay’s Incredible is still making yummy pizza. Ordered the white pizza with extra garlic, extra cheese and artichokes and everything was delish! I even think it’s better than I remembered. Extra cheesy, just the way I like it. The pizza tastes fresh out of the oven and not greasy

Vegetarian options: There’s plenty of veggie options to add to your pizza

Parking: it can get a little busy during rush hour but you can find parking in the adjacent larger Food Lion lot esp if you don’t like parking in tight strip mall spaces

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Another great experience with Jay's. Pizza and salad were perfection. Thank you, Jay's!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jays incredible Thanksgiving pizza!!! So much cheese and flavor and top notch service from the staff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We have ordered pizza from Jay’s since he opened 3 years ago. It never disappoints. This go-round we order a cheese, pepperoni and a meatball parmesan. They were all delicious but wow was the meatball parm amazing! We will definitely order that one again. Great pizza and Jay is a great local guy I will always support.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Decided to try the Thanksgiving pizza from Jays. Arrived at Jays Incredible Pizza to find out they never made our pizza. So, instead of an apology, the 2 options were, a refund or wait to finally make the pies. So I waited, watch them literally throw the ingredients on the pie. Needless to say after arriving home, the thanksgiving pie was less than what was described and missing the cheese. Ive eaten at Jays before and this was by far the worst customer service and the pie was near inedible. After calling back to the shop and asking for management, only to be told "there is no management here" We were told they would refund our charge. Do better Jay!!

Food: 1

Service: 1

The pizza was delivered very quickly- however, it was almost inedible. The “crust” was soggy and watery to the point of holding no form. We had to scrape the toppings off to just have something to eat.

Food: 1

Definitely get the conolli rolls!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

DO NOT GET THERE PIZZA BY THE SLICE!

Their pizza by the slice was a huge disappointment. I believe they should either have a fresh selection to choose from or stop selling their pizza by the slice. You cant put more topping on an already cooked cheese pizza and bake it again and expect it to turn out good. From a culinary perspective this should be common sense. My wife and I got the 2 slice meal deal and I got a slice with extra pepperoni and she got a slice with pepperoni and bell peppers. It turned out terrible. The pepperoni had a bad texture and the bell peppers were mushy and wet.

*PS I rated them 4 stars cause I like small locally owned businesses and didn’t want to lower their score. Plus I have high hopes for this place I will be back to try their deep dish at some point in the future. But again you cant put more toppings on an already cooked cheese pizza and bake it again and expect it to turn out good. Which is why I don’t want to actually judge how good their pizza is because I knew after they explain how they did pizza by the slice it was gonna be terrible.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Highly recommend this place. Delicious pizza served hot and fresh, with ample toppings and generous sizes available. Service was reliable and the shop was clean. The staff were honest and easy to order from.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Italian, Marinara, Large, Pizza

I just wish they accepted ebt..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza