Great pizza...if you're looking for quality NY style pizza look no further! This is the closest we've found. Did not disappoint. The white pie was the best we've had in NC.
Darran Carter C.
You won't regret eating here. The food is fast and fresh and the employees are all so friendly! My favorite is their Philly Steak and Cheese!!
Jim C.
Fantastic slice of pizza! The meats are packed with flavor and the service was great. Making this my new go to spot for a quick slice. And also an affordable spot when downtown.
Kat K.
When Midnight hunger strikes, I've got just the spot for you! piping hot pizzas straight out of the oven, loaded with your favorite toppings and oozing with cheese. It's a haven for pizza enthusiasts and late-night snackers alike. Not only do they serve up the freshest pizzas in town, but they also have your favorite appetizers that will make your taste buds jump. From crispy garlic knots to mouthwatering Jalapeños poppers, their appetizers are the perfect prelude to the main event: the pizza extravaganza! they're open late. Did I mention that already? Lol.. ready to satisfy your midnight cravings whenever they strike. So whether you're craving a classic pepperoni pizza or a specialty white pizza, they got you covered, and for my ranch lovers, they got that good ranch lol. If I could change, just one thing is that they have orders y the slice at night, thats only available during the day now. Next time, hunger strikes after hours, though, skip the microwave meals, and head straight to this pizza place in DTWS. To me, their pizzas are great, delicious appetizers, and the best part the late-night availability - what more could you ask for? Your taste buds will thank you!
Jenni Vaughn
We ordered 2 pizzas and 3 slices of cheesecake for delivery from UberEats. 1 pizza was pepperoni and mushroom. The other was sausage, mushroom and black olives. The pizzas arrived earlier than expected. To my surprise when I opened the pizza boxes we saw that canned mushrooms were used on both pizzas. Not appealing at all. The crust was delicious as was the cheese but the mushrooms were not edible. The sauce was not seasoned particular, more of just a red sauce. The cheesecake was absolutely delicious and I would get that again.
Food: 2
Service: 3
Todd B
Small family pizza shop, operators are from NJ. Good pizza, pleasant staff. Expect longer waits late at night. This one of a very few places open until 3am in Winston Salem.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Tyree Thomas
Best pizza shop in Winston hands downDone by Guy from smoke
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brenda Canales
Sometimes, you don't have to get fancy in downtown. I will say, this is the closest you'll get to NY Pizza. The crust had the perfect crunch and didn't skimp out on the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 16 Cheese Pizza
Erik S.
I've definitely been missing what was my favorite pizza place in Winston-Salem, A Slice of Napoli, lately. But, I am so glad that Brother's Pizzeria exists because they are able to provide a pizza that is right up there with some of Daniel's greatest hits! Particularly the Sicilian style pizza for me... was something that SoN was amazing at, and is kind of rare to find in the Triad. Well at Brother's, you won't miss a bit if you love a good Sicilian, and they are open late. I also love that all prices include sales tax, and the totals always come up to nice round numbers. Not to mention, if you are looking for that true NY pizza vibe, you'll find it here. If you didn't know you were in the south, you'd swear you were in the Bronx. The key is an excellent pizza sauce recipe, and perfect texture on the crust. It's a little buttery and crispy, but pillowy underneath. My favorite toppings are pepperoni and mushroom, but on my most recent visit, I got half with pep and pineapple as well. I was afraid to do pineapple on a sicilian, but honestly the additional oven time just made the pineapple that much better. Leftovers galore, and for those who know, leftover Sicilian is THE best leftover pizza. I'll continue to come to Brother's when I need my Sicilian fix, and probably for any other pizza craving that hits.
The staff was very nice. It was a clean atmosphere and the pizza was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Taylor Fuller
Husband & I stopped by tonight . We had cheese and a bacon pizza . They both were phenomenal ! 10/10 would recommend . Definitely our new go to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
William Herrera
Located in downtown Winston and open till 3:00am, it’s the perfect place to grab a late night bite. The choices are like a true NY pizzeria, only difference is they do not have them on display. You order at the counter and they will call you up when ready. Staff & owners are very friendly. There is plenty of booth seating and there is always funky music play for a nice vibe. You feel like you’re back in a NY pizzeria. We ordered the 12” White Pizza, which has ricotta, tomatoes and garlic. I asked for extra garlic, which was a mistake. I should have asked if it was fresh garlic, it was not, they use garlic powder which killed my taste buds on my tongue. I have had regular pizza here among other items before and loved it all. I did not hate it this time but I wish they used fresh garlic…..makes a huge difference in my honest opinion. As far as the fresh ricotta and mozzarella it was on point, tomatoes may have been canned and also not fresh. Crust is thin and oven baked perfectly. Still love this place, just no extra Garlic!!! Won’t be getting any nucky tonight!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Patrick Goode
Good pizza, ok price, bonus points for not cheaping out on the quality of parm and pepper packets. That said, sometimes they burn it a little which sucks.
Kelly Fought Royall
The best pizza. My fav is the white pizza. Their ranch is so good. All their sandwhiches are awesome too.
1st visiting great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza...if you're looking for quality NY style pizza look no further! This is the closest we've found. Did not disappoint. The white pie was the best we've had in NC.
You won't regret eating here. The food is fast and fresh and the employees are all so friendly! My favorite is their Philly Steak and Cheese!!
Fantastic slice of pizza! The meats are packed with flavor and the service was great. Making this my new go to spot for a quick slice. And also an affordable spot when downtown.
When Midnight hunger strikes, I've got just the spot for you! piping hot pizzas straight out of the oven, loaded with your favorite toppings and oozing with cheese. It's a haven for pizza enthusiasts and late-night snackers alike. Not only do they serve up the freshest pizzas in town, but they also have your favorite appetizers that will make your taste buds jump. From crispy garlic knots to mouthwatering Jalapeños poppers, their appetizers are the perfect prelude to the main event: the pizza extravaganza! they're open late. Did I mention that already? Lol.. ready to satisfy your midnight cravings whenever they strike. So whether you're craving a classic pepperoni pizza or a specialty white pizza, they got you covered, and for my ranch lovers, they got that good ranch lol. If I could change, just one thing is that they have orders y the slice at night, thats only available during the day now. Next time, hunger strikes after hours, though, skip the microwave meals, and head straight to this pizza place in DTWS. To me, their pizzas are great, delicious appetizers, and the best part the late-night availability - what more could you ask for? Your taste buds will thank you!
We ordered 2 pizzas and 3 slices of cheesecake for delivery from UberEats. 1 pizza was pepperoni and mushroom. The other was sausage, mushroom and black olives. The pizzas arrived earlier than expected. To my surprise when I opened the pizza boxes we saw that canned mushrooms were used on both pizzas. Not appealing at all. The crust was delicious as was the cheese but the mushrooms were not edible. The sauce was not seasoned particular, more of just a red sauce. The cheesecake was absolutely delicious and I would get that again.
Food: 2
Service: 3
Small family pizza shop, operators are from NJ. Good pizza, pleasant staff. Expect longer waits late at night. This one of a very few places open until 3am in Winston Salem.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Best pizza shop in Winston hands downDone by Guy from smoke
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sometimes, you don't have to get fancy in downtown. I will say, this is the closest you'll get to NY Pizza. The crust had the perfect crunch and didn't skimp out on the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 16 Cheese Pizza
I've definitely been missing what was my favorite pizza place in Winston-Salem, A Slice of Napoli, lately. But, I am so glad that Brother's Pizzeria exists because they are able to provide a pizza that is right up there with some of Daniel's greatest hits! Particularly the Sicilian style pizza for me... was something that SoN was amazing at, and is kind of rare to find in the Triad. Well at Brother's, you won't miss a bit if you love a good Sicilian, and they are open late. I also love that all prices include sales tax, and the totals always come up to nice round numbers. Not to mention, if you are looking for that true NY pizza vibe, you'll find it here. If you didn't know you were in the south, you'd swear you were in the Bronx. The key is an excellent pizza sauce recipe, and perfect texture on the crust. It's a little buttery and crispy, but pillowy underneath. My favorite toppings are pepperoni and mushroom, but on my most recent visit, I got half with pep and pineapple as well. I was afraid to do pineapple on a sicilian, but honestly the additional oven time just made the pineapple that much better. Leftovers galore, and for those who know, leftover Sicilian is THE best leftover pizza. I'll continue to come to Brother's when I need my Sicilian fix, and probably for any other pizza craving that hits.
Restaurantji Recommends
The staff was very nice. It was a clean atmosphere and the pizza was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Husband & I stopped by tonight . We had cheese and a bacon pizza . They both were phenomenal ! 10/10 would recommend . Definitely our new go to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Located in downtown Winston and open till 3:00am, it’s the perfect place to grab a late night bite. The choices are like a true NY pizzeria, only difference is they do not have them on display. You order at the counter and they will call you up when ready. Staff & owners are very friendly. There is plenty of booth seating and there is always funky music play for a nice vibe. You feel like you’re back in a NY pizzeria. We ordered the 12” White Pizza, which has ricotta, tomatoes and garlic. I asked for extra garlic, which was a mistake. I should have asked if it was fresh garlic, it was not, they use garlic powder which killed my taste buds on my tongue. I have had regular pizza here among other items before and loved it all. I did not hate it this time but I wish they used fresh garlic…..makes a huge difference in my honest opinion. As far as the fresh ricotta and mozzarella it was on point, tomatoes may have been canned and also not fresh. Crust is thin and oven baked perfectly. Still love this place, just no extra Garlic!!! Won’t be getting any nucky tonight!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Good pizza, ok price, bonus points for not cheaping out on the quality of parm and pepper packets. That said, sometimes they burn it a little which sucks.
The best pizza. My fav is the white pizza. Their ranch is so good. All their sandwhiches are awesome too.