The thin crust was excellent, crispy and yet chewy. The sauce was just right. Even the pepperoni was just right, not too spicy which seems to be the trend these days. For just two people we got the 15 in and at first thought it would be too much but we polished it off with no trouble. Lots of seating inside. The light fixtures are a really cool design. We are from out of town but this was an excellent experience. Yeah I'm going to give it
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robin Strader
This was the best Mario's experience we've had in the triad area in a long time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julie W
Good new york style here in Forsythe county. Clean restaurant, speedy service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Terry Cribb
Best pizza place in Winston-Salem North Carolina absolutely a hole in the wall place that you need to visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone, Pizza by the Slice
Becky Bunnz
1 star on customer service! We ordered a beef pepperoni pizza, wings and a cheesecake! We’re no stranger to this place love the fact they offer non pork options, however when my husband picked the food up it was pork pepperoni, ok mistakes happen they offered to remake the pizza. So here is where poor customer service comes to play they took the wings and put them on top of the heater I suppose to keep them warm unbeknownst to us we believe they remade the order because now the fresh hot wings we ordered are now cold and soggy. When we got home literally 2 minutes from the restaurant we called and asked about it the response was there was nothing wrong with the wing order when we placed it so they would not be remaking them nor refunding them dispite us having to wait for them to remake a pizza they messed up in the first place, the tone of the conversation was how dare we ask them to fix some cold soggy wings that’s was drowned in buffalo sauce. I just told my husband end the conversation we are not gonna beg anyone to do what should have been done originally. It’s crazy because this restaurant is in my neighborhood and they expect customers to just accept anything more so a disrespectful disposition. But what’s more crazy is that there are other places in Winston to take our business nobody is obligated to spend their money to keep these restaurants open. Although my household orders may not mean anything to them I can assure you there are other places that value their customers, value the integrity of their food that is going out the door and value their reputation in our communities. Whoever the staff and management was that day are the reason why you all have one less customer.
William Herrera
Located in a strip mall next to LA Fitness, it’s hard to see from the main road. This is a chain pizzeria but the pizza is definitely not chain material. It definitely holds up….literally….and compares to NY pizza. Good ratio of sauce and cheese. Both tastes of good quality and not local store bought. They are made fresh and served hot. A taste of NY in every bite. They have daily specials, this was the two slice, one topping and a drink. I got pepperoni on one and unlike other pizzerias, it was not runny with oil, it only dripped a bit. The drinks are self serve. Employees are friendly. You order at the counter and then pick up your order when called. The place is very spacious and kept clean and orderly. Plenty of indoor seating as well as a few other tables with umbrellas for shade. Very warm artsy environment. I’m picky about my pizza and this places past the test IMHO!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Aaron Sams
This pizza parlor has some of the best pizza and other offerings in the triad,you can't stop eating it even after your full
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Billy Coleman
My family and I do NOT eat pork, and just happened on this restaurant in our travels one day. We were pleasantly Suprised when we were told they have beef pepperoni. Then, not just that, but the pizza was phenomenal. Being born in NY, you kinda get skeptical of pizza places. This is a place to try. Would definitely recommend.
Richard Hammond
Pizza was extremely greasy and you could tell it came from them using too much cheese on the pizza. Sauce consistency was watery and under seasoned. I folded the slice of pizza in half to bite it and it fell apart and the cheese and pepperoni slid off of the pizza. For $5 a slice, I would rather buy a gas station pizza and microwave it. Service was great and atmosphere is comfortable but the pizza needs some work if they are going to call themselves a pizzeria.
Being from NY we are always looking for good ny style pizza and this definitely fit the bill. We got a regular pepperoni and a gluten free pepperoni and they were both excellent even after getting it to go. Will definitely be back again and will probably eat in because it was a good looking place
Wendy M
Ordered on Doordash. Two orders of baked ziti one with an added side of sausage. Garlic knots and salad come with the ziti. One cheese Slice. One cheese calzone. Not one edible meal. There was no seasoning in the sauce. Everything was bland. The sausage was dry. The garlic knots were hard. If the food had been good, it would have been a good price for the portions. Really disappointed but will find another place for Italian.
Michael Boughman
A great place to get a NY slice for lunch.
Matthew Boles
We come here almost every Wednesday. Our two families meet and have 4 large pizzas. The staff are awesome, always clean, food is great!, and the seating is always 👌! Appreciate you all! Keep up the great work.
Tara Johnson
Mario's pizza on Strafford Road is by far the best pizza in Winston Salem. The sauce, pepperoni,crust, and taste is wonderful.
big pizza like nyc style
The thin crust was excellent, crispy and yet chewy. The sauce was just right. Even the pepperoni was just right, not too spicy which seems to be the trend these days. For just two people we got the 15 in and at first thought it would be too much but we polished it off with no trouble. Lots of seating inside. The light fixtures are a really cool design. We are from out of town but this was an excellent experience. Yeah I'm going to give it
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was the best Mario's experience we've had in the triad area in a long time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good new york style here in Forsythe county. Clean restaurant, speedy service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Best pizza place in Winston-Salem North Carolina absolutely a hole in the wall place that you need to visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone, Pizza by the Slice
1 star on customer service! We ordered a beef pepperoni pizza, wings and a cheesecake! We’re no stranger to this place love the fact they offer non pork options, however when my husband picked the food up it was pork pepperoni, ok mistakes happen they offered to remake the pizza. So here is where poor customer service comes to play they took the wings and put them on top of the heater I suppose to keep them warm unbeknownst to us we believe they remade the order because now the fresh hot wings we ordered are now cold and soggy. When we got home literally 2 minutes from the restaurant we called and asked about it the response was there was nothing wrong with the wing order when we placed it so they would not be remaking them nor refunding them dispite us having to wait for them to remake a pizza they messed up in the first place, the tone of the conversation was how dare we ask them to fix some cold soggy wings that’s was drowned in buffalo sauce. I just told my husband end the conversation we are not gonna beg anyone to do what should have been done originally. It’s crazy because this restaurant is in my neighborhood and they expect customers to just accept anything more so a disrespectful disposition. But what’s more crazy is that there are other places in Winston to take our business nobody is obligated to spend their money to keep these restaurants open. Although my household orders may not mean anything to them I can assure you there are other places that value their customers, value the integrity of their food that is going out the door and value their reputation in our communities. Whoever the staff and management was that day are the reason why you all have one less customer.
Located in a strip mall next to LA Fitness, it’s hard to see from the main road. This is a chain pizzeria but the pizza is definitely not chain material. It definitely holds up….literally….and compares to NY pizza. Good ratio of sauce and cheese. Both tastes of good quality and not local store bought. They are made fresh and served hot. A taste of NY in every bite. They have daily specials, this was the two slice, one topping and a drink. I got pepperoni on one and unlike other pizzerias, it was not runny with oil, it only dripped a bit. The drinks are self serve. Employees are friendly. You order at the counter and then pick up your order when called. The place is very spacious and kept clean and orderly. Plenty of indoor seating as well as a few other tables with umbrellas for shade. Very warm artsy environment. I’m picky about my pizza and this places past the test IMHO!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
This pizza parlor has some of the best pizza and other offerings in the triad,you can't stop eating it even after your full
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My family and I do NOT eat pork, and just happened on this restaurant in our travels one day. We were pleasantly Suprised when we were told they have beef pepperoni. Then, not just that, but the pizza was phenomenal. Being born in NY, you kinda get skeptical of pizza places. This is a place to try. Would definitely recommend.
Pizza was extremely greasy and you could tell it came from them using too much cheese on the pizza. Sauce consistency was watery and under seasoned. I folded the slice of pizza in half to bite it and it fell apart and the cheese and pepperoni slid off of the pizza. For $5 a slice, I would rather buy a gas station pizza and microwave it. Service was great and atmosphere is comfortable but the pizza needs some work if they are going to call themselves a pizzeria.
Restaurantji Recommends
Being from NY we are always looking for good ny style pizza and this definitely fit the bill. We got a regular pepperoni and a gluten free pepperoni and they were both excellent even after getting it to go. Will definitely be back again and will probably eat in because it was a good looking place
Ordered on Doordash. Two orders of baked ziti one with an added side of sausage. Garlic knots and salad come with the ziti. One cheese Slice. One cheese calzone. Not one edible meal. There was no seasoning in the sauce. Everything was bland. The sausage was dry. The garlic knots were hard. If the food had been good, it would have been a good price for the portions. Really disappointed but will find another place for Italian.
A great place to get a NY slice for lunch.
We come here almost every Wednesday. Our two families meet and have 4 large pizzas. The staff are awesome, always clean, food is great!, and the seating is always 👌! Appreciate you all! Keep up the great work.
Mario's pizza on Strafford Road is by far the best pizza in Winston Salem. The sauce, pepperoni,crust, and taste is wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...