Whitaker Square Pizza

I have to give this place one star as we have had 2 poor experiences with ordering. The first occurred a couple of months ago where our order got mixed up. I just chalked it up to a one-off; it happens. Yesterday, I tried order online. Their online ordering app took the order even though the restaurant was closed. I was a little distracted trying to keep an eye on kids. As soon as I hit the order button, I saw that the order was for the following day. The app randomly assigned a pick up time of 3:30 today. There was no way to undo the order. So instead of being a convenient dinner option on a busy workday, I had find another dinner option, then take time out of my workday today to pickup food that I didn't need or want. I tried to call earlier in the day, but of course WSP doesn't open until 3, and I was in a meeting at 3. I shared my feedback with one of the employees, and he said he knew about the app issue as he had received similar feedback from other customers. Then he said he was sorry. So am I. Next time I'll go to Burke Street; customer experience is much better there.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Simply place, good food.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Youre a Northerners looking for pizza you won’t be disappointed.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

1st Time Eating Here, Ive Had This Place On My Radar For Some Time Now And 2Day Was Tha Day!!!Had Dinner Here With My Moms This Isn't Your Ordinary Pizza Spot!! They Offer A Verity Of Specialty Pizzas With Different Topping And Different Signature Sauces..If You Want To Try A Non-Boring Pizza This Is Your Place!!2Night I Went With A Old School Favorite Half Cheese/ Half Pepperoni And Wasn't Disappointed In Tha Least!!!Ill Definitely Be Returning To Try The Variety Of Things They Have Im A Foodie And Excited To Try Everything Lol..Thank You For The Amazing Friendly Service And GOOD FOOD...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Pepperoni Pizza, Grandma Cheese Pizza

Great pizza, fair price… this is more of a takeout spot in my opinion which is fine. The only downside is no Apple Pay so make sure you bring cash or

Food: 5

Service: 5

When they first opened, we really enjoyed their pizza. We picked up a few times during Covid and noticed a change for the worse so we took a few years off. We retried it last night and were incredibly disappointed. We spent over $80 on garlic knots and three pizzas that were overcooked and chewy. The chicken Caesar pizza was a joke - barely finished one piece and had to throw rest away. It was gross and inedible. The buffalo chicken pizza tasted fine if we could get through the crust. The only saving grace were the garlic knots. Such a huge waste of money and left 7 people very unhappy. As my daughter said, we should have went with Pizza Greco. Lesson learned.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Pizza was cold and flavourless. The wings were way overcooked. Maybe just a bad night, but we won't be ordering again anytime soon.

Food: 3

Service: 5

1st and last time. Sicilian was cold, tough, and had barely any toppings.. 3 out of 10. Not worth it.

Food: 1

Ordered delivery, the chicken ceasar pizza, which was delicious.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great tasting pizza at a chilled and relaxed environment.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Steak Pizza, Cheese Pizza

Definitely not an eat in pizza place. Take out on their traditional round OK. The Sicilian square reminds me of school lunch pizza. Over priced with bad service. No specials or any that were listed. Things that made the evening dine in experience more amazing. No napkins, bottled water was out however we did get to see the establishment restock the water with a store brand (HT) that would then be sold for $1.25 each. The topper to the evening was being told I could hand over the pizza trays to a worker. My hands were full with leftover pizza that was crammed into a small box. All I could say was ok and walked out. I know it’s hard to walk around to clean up a table. Silly me.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Genuinely the best pizza in winston. staff is super sweet and they have a great menu other than pizza. This is my go to for fridays or nights I babysit.

Kid-friendliness: I suggest them to my babysitting clients all the time

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Ordered two slices, they were delicious. I will be back to try a whole pizza.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Consistent food and fast delivery

The steak and cheese Stromboli is delicious

Food: 5

Service: 5