Paper Moon Pastries

325 W 4th St, Cortland
(402) 405-4605

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Murtaza Nalwala

The owner greets all of her customers with smile and vibrant energy. Very passionate baker with reflection of her passion in her goods!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amanda Heyne

Had to go back 4 times in one trip down from South Dakota. Absolutely amazing.

rbuller

Hawai'i in a kolache! | Love Hawai'i's POG (Passion, Orange, and Guava juice) AND kolache? Guava kolache for the win! Yet another reason to love Paper Moon!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jonathan McAlister

Going to this bakery is a must!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Grace Pfeifer

We are over the moon about this place. If you want a treat and an experience of good old fashioned fun, take your family to paper moon. It’s like stepping back into the 1950s. The dingdongs are a favorite of ours, and the cinnamon rolls are unmatched.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Regina Blazek

Pillowy soft flavorful kolaches.

Mitchell Clark

LOVE Paper Moon. Of all the places that I promote via word-of-mouth, this one definitely "takes the cake" (pun intended.) The pastries are made to perfection with lots of gluten and dairy free options. I'm usually hesitant on GF/DF, but wow does Paper Moon pull it off! (Try the coffee cake. You'll have yourself thinking, "I can't believe it's not butter!") There are always creative, new flavors each week and of course some fan-favorite usuals. There's so much more to say about the pastries but you'll have to try it for yourself. 😇 Ok...I have to give the kolaches its own paragraph. As a Nebraska native, I've had me a lot of kolaches. But Paper Moon's kolaches are SPOT ON. Soft and moist dough. A hearty serving of filling. Not to mention, there are creative and unique flavors each week...even savory ones. YUM! Each bite of a Paper Moon kolache has me thinking, "this is how a kolache is supposed to be." You'll find yourself back in time as you walk through the doors into the 30's...so cool! Last but certainly not least, Lindsey (the owner) and the staff are always bright, cheery, and such a pleasure. They give Paper Moon that homey, inviting feel that brings us Nebraskans back to our small town roots. Full disclosure: get to know your neighbors in line. There's a reason there is a wait and space is limited...because it is a gem that attracts people from all around. But don't you worry, they're a well oiled machine. Paper Moon is well worth the wait! ☺️

Mitchell

LOVE Paper Moon. There are few places that get a "shut up and take my money", but this is definitely one of them!

The pastries are unique and made to perfection and the kolaches are SPOT ON (soft and moist dough with a hearty serving of filling - a rarity since most people can't seem to get this right). There's so much more to say about the pastries but not enough space here.

The environment has a cute little 30's vibe and such a gem that attracts people from all around. Last but certainly not least, Lindsey (the owner) and the staff are always bright and cheery and a pleasure to interact with.

Full disclosure: get to know your neighbors in line. There's a reason there is a wait and space is limited...because it is a gem well worth it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Monte Montgomery

We drove from nw kansas 4 the good pastries as always it is to die 4. Good work. We will be back .we come through about 4 times a year. 👌👍🏼

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Laura L.

Paper Moon is by far my favorite place to get a sweet treat. Their kolaches are the best around and worth the drive and the long line (if you don't catch them at the perfect time). Their staff is incredibly friendly despite being so busy. The only downfall is they're only open Saturdays (although my husband and wallet appreciate that.)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Miner

Kolaches...best I have ever eaten
Cinnamon rolls that are as soft and tender on the outside as the inside.....words do no justice to just how outstanding the food is here at this little bakery.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jack Traveler

The Banana Bread Brownies are awesome! I didn't even know they were dairy/gluten-free until I read it after the fact! I highly recommend Paper Moon!

Wizard Wizard

Best baker in the area. Kolaches are wonderful, Pecan roll was so tender that pieces came off in my fingers! Delightful mouth feel.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Baklava, Monster Cookies

Kelly Ann

The kolaches are amazing!!!! The dough is perfect and includes lots of filling!!!! So delicious!!!!! Yum!!!

Cori Cerveny

This is an AMAZING little small-town bakery with super friendly staff and AWESOME treats! They have SO MANY gluten free options, which I especially love since I have a family member who can't consume gluten. I cannot recommend this place enough! Totally worth the drive!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free AND Dairy Free options

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies, Cinnamon Coffee Cake, Monster Cookies, Cinnamon Rolls Moon Bars

Loading...