Service was great but sadly the food was terrible and bland. Very sad and disappointed with the steaks.
Opentable Diner
Feel devastating leaving my last review for this great restaurant. Thanks for all the great memories over the years.
BobA
The service and food was excellent. It was very impressive that such service could be provided with such a large gathering of customers.
EmmyS16
Will be so hard seeing Anthony's gone. Dined there when we moved to Omaha in '83. Menu is wonderful.
Joni
The food was fabulous and the service was exceptional. We had one of the best waitresses ever!!
Opentable Diner
Steaks were quite tough (bone in NY strip and filet mignon) even though cooked medium rare, was just not good quality meat. Also they did not appear to be seasoned, and were flavorless. Sides (au gratin potatoes and asparagus) were good however. Waitress did not seem to want to be there at all. Was recommended by a friend who lived in Omaha a few years ago, and we were really disappointed in the quality of a fairly expensive meal.
Steaks were quite tough (bone in NY strip and filet mignon) even though cooked medium rare, was just not good quality meat. Also they did not appear to be seasoned, and were flavorless. Sides (au gratin potatoes and asparagus) were good however. Waitress did not seem to want to be there at all. Was recommended by a friend who lived in Omaha a few years ago, and we were really disappointed in the quality of a fairly expensive meal.
Beefeater
It wasn't the quality of food or service that we expected (but our recent visit to Sullivan's may cloud that). But the steaks were average, the service from the hostess to the server was poor, our bill was wrong...since they're closing, skip it.
We had a great time with our friends, however it was bittersweet. We were one of many that had our wedding reception here (in 2017). We had compliments on the food and location for a very long time. We are glad that we were able to get in one last time.
CaptainElPato
Anthony's prices are much higher than most other steak houses in Omaha, and you would expect a quality of food to be representative. My steak was under seasoned, though it was properly cooked and the size that I ordered, I've had much better flavored steaks at many other places in the area. To the amount of money that I'm spending it, I would expected a better steak. Also, service was slow, although that is probably because of short staff. All that said, it's unfortunate that Anthony's is closing, because it was a great place to have dinner, special events, and go to see a band.
Anthony's prices are much higher than most other steak houses in Omaha, and you would expect a quality of food to be representative. My steak was under seasoned, though it was properly cooked and the size that I ordered, I've had much better flavored steaks at many other places in the area. To the amount of money that I'm spending it, I would expected a better steak. Also, service was slow, although that is probably because of short staff. All that said, it's unfortunate that Anthony's is closing, because it was a great place to have dinner, special events, and go to see a band.
Maria D
The place is not we expected ? The server was very abrupt - rude! Food was mediocre and very pricey! We’ll never go back! I heard the management decided to finally close their door is a very good idea!
Sammy
I ordered the Prime Rib it came out very fast, which I was surprised. It usually takes a little bit longer to come out but when I got my food, it was cold! I also noticed when I was cutting the meat, the meat was sticking to my knife. I have never had that happen in my life! My husband's steak was cooked medium but he had to keep chewing and chewing. The drinks were so over poured I couldn't drink mine! I am not sure why but we were sat on the bar side, no band was playing, not sure if its because they are closing but it was a Saturday night and it was dead. The wall we sat next to was dirty and had paint missing. I felt like I was at a hole in the wall bar but paid 5 times the price! We have never been here before but wanted to try it before they closed. I guess all I can say is at least we tried it...
Desi F
Such a shame that they are closing the door permanently at the end of February. My husband and I had our wedding reception here and the food was delicious. I've been back on birthdays and anniversaries since. Everything that I have had is positively delicious, and the service is fantastic. I
Jean Cappellano
Meal was good, service was Good but she asked way to many times if everything was ok it was like every 10 minutes , annoying, 2 appetizers 2 entries over $100 not including tip , no wonder they are closing we got 2 rolls with butter and a heel and 2 slices of bread in a basket with butter too……
Service was great but sadly the food was terrible and bland. Very sad and disappointed with the steaks.
Feel devastating leaving my last review for this great restaurant. Thanks for all the great memories over the years.
The service and food was excellent. It was very impressive that such service could be provided with such a large gathering of customers.
Will be so hard seeing Anthony's gone. Dined there when we moved to Omaha in '83. Menu is wonderful.
The food was fabulous and the service was exceptional. We had one of the best waitresses ever!!
Steaks were quite tough (bone in NY strip and filet mignon) even though cooked medium rare, was just not good quality meat. Also they did not appear to be seasoned, and were flavorless. Sides (au gratin potatoes and asparagus) were good however. Waitress did not seem to want to be there at all. Was recommended by a friend who lived in Omaha a few years ago, and we were really disappointed in the quality of a fairly expensive meal.
Steaks were quite tough (bone in NY strip and filet mignon) even though cooked medium rare, was just not good quality meat. Also they did not appear to be seasoned, and were flavorless. Sides (au gratin potatoes and asparagus) were good however. Waitress did not seem to want to be there at all. Was recommended by a friend who lived in Omaha a few years ago, and we were really disappointed in the quality of a fairly expensive meal.
It wasn't the quality of food or service that we expected (but our recent visit to Sullivan's may cloud that). But the steaks were average, the service from the hostess to the server was poor, our bill was wrong...since they're closing, skip it.
We had a great time with our friends, however it was bittersweet. We were one of many that had our wedding reception here (in 2017). We had compliments on the food and location for a very long time. We are glad that we were able to get in one last time.
Anthony's prices are much higher than most other steak houses in Omaha, and you would expect a quality of food to be representative. My steak was under seasoned, though it was properly cooked and the size that I ordered, I've had much better flavored steaks at many other places in the area. To the amount of money that I'm spending it, I would expected a better steak. Also, service was slow, although that is probably because of short staff. All that said, it's unfortunate that Anthony's is closing, because it was a great place to have dinner, special events, and go to see a band.
Restaurantji Recommends
Anthony's prices are much higher than most other steak houses in Omaha, and you would expect a quality of food to be representative. My steak was under seasoned, though it was properly cooked and the size that I ordered, I've had much better flavored steaks at many other places in the area. To the amount of money that I'm spending it, I would expected a better steak. Also, service was slow, although that is probably because of short staff. All that said, it's unfortunate that Anthony's is closing, because it was a great place to have dinner, special events, and go to see a band.
The place is not we expected ? The server was very abrupt - rude! Food was mediocre and very pricey! We’ll never go back! I heard the management decided to finally close their door is a very good idea!
I ordered the Prime Rib it came out very fast, which I was surprised. It usually takes a little bit longer to come out but when I got my food, it was cold! I also noticed when I was cutting the meat, the meat was sticking to my knife. I have never had that happen in my life! My husband's steak was cooked medium but he had to keep chewing and chewing. The drinks were so over poured I couldn't drink mine! I am not sure why but we were sat on the bar side, no band was playing, not sure if its because they are closing but it was a Saturday night and it was dead. The wall we sat next to was dirty and had paint missing. I felt like I was at a hole in the wall bar but paid 5 times the price! We have never been here before but wanted to try it before they closed. I guess all I can say is at least we tried it...
Such a shame that they are closing the door permanently at the end of February. My husband and I had our wedding reception here and the food was delicious. I've been back on birthdays and anniversaries since. Everything that I have had is positively delicious, and the service is fantastic. I
Meal was good, service was Good but she asked way to many times if everything was ok it was like every 10 minutes , annoying, 2 appetizers 2 entries over $100 not including tip , no wonder they are closing we got 2 rolls with butter and a heel and 2 slices of bread in a basket with butter too……
Loading...