Godfather's Pizza

17935 Welch Plaza, Omaha
(402) 896-1177

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Laurie Gibbs

Ordered my game day pizzas at 2:30 for 5:30 pick up. Arrived at 5:35 and everything was ready. Pick up was smooth using the drive through. Great pizza and customer service!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Soren Grandall

5/5. Manager was friendly beyond belief. Offered to put my order in early when I showed up before my pickup time. Offered a drink as I sat there and waited. Would absolutely recommend stopping in to grab a pizza or sit and hangout with family for a while. Incredible service, kind people. What more do you want.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dave Montray

THE BEST!!! My wife and I absolutely loved their pizza until all of them closed in the Minneapolis area. Ugh 😩. Come back!!!

Alexander Hamilton

Ghost town at noon on Saturday.
Even the workers weren't present. Food wasn't out either. Maybe next time.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Bob E

Very clean. Service was friendly and fast. Taco pizza is awesome.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mike Foley

Ordered pizza from here large two topping and small taco. Large pizza was not good. The crust definitely was not fresh, tasted like frozen. Matter of fact I can and have had better frozen pizza before. At $60 plus or minus a little I’ll be hard pressed to order from here again. Sad considering corporate office is practically right across the street from this location.

Brent Moser

I’m Roy the pizza daddy and I loved their pizza!! Their golden crust pan pizza was so good and the cheese was very high quality and thick!!

Carrie ā€œBadMommaJoeā€ Edmunds

Food is always delicious and fresh! Our family has pizza take out dinner from here all the time!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lex

Why does this location refuse to bake the pepperoni UNDERNEATH the cheese? Is it really that hard? I genuinely would like to know since it's not a problem at other locations. Godfather's is more on the pricey side when it comes to chain pizza places but I'm willing to pay the extra for decent pizza which I feel that it is when you're not in the mood for a mom and pop and are just wanting something quick. However, I think Godfather's pepperoni is truly the best when they cook it underneath the cheese. The Lavista location does this without asking and it's amazing every time. It's the only location that remains consistent and tasty. Very curious as to why this location specifically does not want to take the time to do something so simple but worth it. I do request this in the special instructions as well.

Jonah Galardi

It isn’t often you find an atmosphere like this. Walking into this location you are engulfed in the life of ā€œThe Godfatherā€. Clean, organized, and staffed by some of the most lovely people you can find. During the entirety of my visit to this location you could hear the good spirits of the staff, see the clean store and experience what true pizza is supposed to taste liked. The Taco pizza was to die for, and the Cinnamon Crazy Bread is the best thing since the invention of the wheel. This was the first time for me at this location, and I can garuntee you it won’t be the last time I visit the Godfather!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

R Heanue

The manager of this location is extremely rude. They quoted 45 minutes, but took about an hour, which was not an issue. I completely understand being busy on Friday night. The issue started when they forgot our 2 two liters of pop. I called to let them know that they forgot them and got nothing but attitude from the manager. In the process of me asking if she knew where to deliver said missing pop, I got hung up on. I called back to make sure she had my address and was answered by ā€œdo you have something else you need?ā€ Talk about rude and unprofessional!! I will not be back.

Andrew Holt

Long lines and disgruntled employees. =(

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Chad Frodyma

Avoid this location, if at all possible. Ordered two pizzas online for carry-out. Said it would be ready in 25 minutes. Got there 30 minutes after ordering, and they hadn't even started my order.

Left and came back 30 minutes later, the girl at the window said they "ran out of larges" and tried to give me a medium specialty instead of the large that i paid for online. I asked for the difference between large and medium to be put back on my credit card. She looked at me like I asked her a science question and made the manager help me instead. I explained to her what had just happened. The manager said, with a confused tone, "we aren't out of larges." The manager then said they could have my large pizza done in 15 minutes. So, I left (again) and returned 20 minutes later. This time, I walked in to the store. The young girl who "helped" me before, grabbed my pizza, put it on the counter, and walked away without saying a word. As I left, I couldn't help but notice two different people in their cars just sitting there, as if they were waiting for their own pizzas they ordered some time ago.

This place is too busy. They don't need my (or your) money.

Service: 1

Jonathan London

First time eating Godfathers since moving to Omaha, and I can’t recommend them enough! The pizza was fantastic, I ordered ahead and the food was ready exactly when they said it would be. We definitely found our regular pizza restaurant!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kathy Pahan

We have been to this location for pickup only. We called in our order and have always been treated very cordially through the process. The atmosphere is quiet as it appears to be mostly take outs that we've seen. Always greeted with a friendly smile & excellent timing on pickup! The pizza ? ? is always exceptional, and we've never been disappointed with our meal. We always return when visiting our son & grandbabies in Nebraska!

Parking: Godfathers is located in a mini mall, so you chose your own parking area.

Kid-friendliness: They have coloring pages for kids and a big open area.

Wheelchair accessibility: Easy to acess

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread with Cheese, Green Olives, Pizze

Loading...