Great takeout pizza spot. My family and I are huge fans of their ham pizza, they use some seriously tasty meat! The veggie is also a go to and the garlic cheesy bread is a favorite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Randy Pollock
Such great pizza! Don't forget that on Mondays, you get a FREE Cheese pizza with the purchase of a regular pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
April Fuller
Pizza could have used a little more sauce flavorable good seasoning very disappointed in the boneless wings They were nothing but an off brand frozen Buffalo chicken that you buy at the grocery store. some of the pieces looked like chicken nuggets with buffalo sauce thrown on them they taste like frozen chicken nuggets with buffalo sauce thrown on them and they were half cooked and had the freezer taste and when I say chicken nuggets I'm not even talking the good kind
Food: 2
John Edwards
Remember when Pizza was great the next day? Now you're lucky if it arrives edible! Fantastic Pizza! Great crust/dough. Perfect amount of toppers. Price is wonderful and is definitely a good buy for this quality. I ordered through Uber Eats, the driver really mishandled my pie. To his credit it was bought in a warmer though. I was able to fore the most part re-construct the Pie. I slapped the one slice left bare on one that wasn't. Delicious!!!!! Had the two leftover over slices two days late lightly warmed up in my microwave, Delicious!!! I'm looking forward to my next night in town, worth driving I-80 to have their Pizza!
Food: 5
Kathie Larson
Our pepperoni pizza didn’t have a single pepperoni. The extra veggies that we paid extra for were sparse. It was overcooked and dry. Not a great first experience.
Mikel Severe
Good pie.
Kasey Harrison
We order from here often. The food is AMAZING. However, today we ordered and our bill jumped from 57 to over 70 to have it delivered. Was suppose to be at our house at 450. At 515, I called to see where our order is. First, I was told that it had been ready for awhile and was scheduled for pickup. I said no it wasnt as I marked it for delivery and my total went up almost $20 for delivery. I was then told that it was marked for delivery and that no one has come to pick it up yet. I asked who do they use for delivery service and was then told it was just picked up. Then, when it was delivered, they left it on the front stoop without ringing the doorbell or follow up text of it being delivered. Our food not only sat in a warmer for over 30 min, but then outside for however long. Our wings have ranch dumped all over them, we ordered the sweet chili wings. Our pizza is dry and burnt due to sitting in the warmer. We spent over $70 on a meal that is poor quality and received poor customer service. As much as we enjoy the food, this makes us not want to return.
Preston Ehly
The Sunday crew never disappoints! Always a pleasure going in here! One of Omahas best spots!
M K
They use extra virgin olive oil, no added sugar, none of that other junk just good pizza! Love to see it! I will definitely be back!
Dave Reeder
It's really just a take out place, but Great pizza. Thin crust, which I love, fresh ingredients.
Ordered Meat Me and Brian's Song with gluten-free crust. It was very good with plenty of toppings. I'm Celiac and did not have a reaction. They took precautions including not cutting the pizza to avoid cross contamination.
Skyler Bauer (Realtor)
I had an amazing experience at Pizza Pie Guys! The pizza was loaded with toppings and cooked perfectly—just the way I like it. I ordered the Dan’s Special and the flavor was incredible, the sauce had a nice kick to it and you can tell they use quality ingredients. I crushed this whole pie in about 10 minutes. Highly recommend!
Sue Hull Walsh
We discovered The Pizza Pie Guys a couple of months ago. Really, really good pizza! They are now our regular take out go-to.
Sammie Ebbing
I ordered off of DoorDash, this is so good. I got the green chile enchilada pizza and my boyfriend did a build your own calzone. The dough is light and fluffy and the crust on the pizza is also light and fluffy, that’s how you know it’s a great pizza. The green chile flavor on the pizza is balanced so it’s not spicy at all. We will definitely order again and come in sometime!
Cory Tingle
This place is amazing.. I have ordered here over 20 times in the last 2 months since discovering this place.. was so sad when they announced they were closing and now that they are back I’ve never been more thrilled. My ABSOLUTE favorite pizza in Omaha. I’m trying the burger next week when it’s back.
Great takeout pizza spot. My family and I are huge fans of their ham pizza, they use some seriously tasty meat! The veggie is also a go to and the garlic cheesy bread is a favorite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such great pizza! Don't forget that on Mondays, you get a FREE Cheese pizza with the purchase of a regular pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza could have used a little more sauce flavorable good seasoning very disappointed in the boneless wings They were nothing but an off brand frozen Buffalo chicken that you buy at the grocery store. some of the pieces looked like chicken nuggets with buffalo sauce thrown on them they taste like frozen chicken nuggets with buffalo sauce thrown on them and they were half cooked and had the freezer taste and when I say chicken nuggets I'm not even talking the good kind
Food: 2
Remember when Pizza was great the next day? Now you're lucky if it arrives edible!
Fantastic Pizza! Great crust/dough. Perfect amount of toppers. Price is wonderful and is definitely a good buy for this quality.
I ordered through Uber Eats, the driver really mishandled my pie. To his credit it was bought in a warmer though. I was able to fore the most part re-construct the Pie. I slapped the one slice left bare on one that wasn't. Delicious!!!!!
Had the two leftover over slices two days late lightly warmed up in my microwave, Delicious!!!
I'm looking forward to my next night in town, worth driving I-80 to have their Pizza!
Food: 5
Our pepperoni pizza didn’t have a single pepperoni. The extra veggies that we paid extra for were sparse. It was overcooked and dry. Not a great first experience.
Good pie.
We order from here often. The food is AMAZING. However, today we ordered and our bill jumped from 57 to over 70 to have it delivered. Was suppose to be at our house at 450. At 515, I called to see where our order is. First, I was told that it had been ready for awhile and was scheduled for pickup. I said no it wasnt as I marked it for delivery and my total went up almost $20 for delivery. I was then told that it was marked for delivery and that no one has come to pick it up yet. I asked who do they use for delivery service and was then told it was just picked up. Then, when it was delivered, they left it on the front stoop without ringing the doorbell or follow up text of it being delivered. Our food not only sat in a warmer for over 30 min, but then outside for however long. Our wings have ranch dumped all over them, we ordered the sweet chili wings. Our pizza is dry and burnt due to sitting in the warmer. We spent over $70 on a meal that is poor quality and received poor customer service. As much as we enjoy the food, this makes us not want to return.
The Sunday crew never disappoints! Always a pleasure going in here! One of Omahas best spots!
They use extra virgin olive oil, no added sugar, none of that other junk just good pizza! Love to see it! I will definitely be back!
It's really just a take out place, but Great pizza. Thin crust, which I love, fresh ingredients.
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered Meat Me and Brian's Song with gluten-free crust. It was very good with plenty of toppings. I'm Celiac and did not have a reaction. They took precautions including not cutting the pizza to avoid cross contamination.
I had an amazing experience at Pizza Pie Guys! The pizza was loaded with toppings and cooked perfectly—just the way I like it. I ordered the Dan’s Special and the flavor was incredible, the sauce had a nice kick to it and you can tell they use quality ingredients. I crushed this whole pie in about 10 minutes. Highly recommend!
We discovered The Pizza Pie Guys a couple of months ago. Really, really good pizza! They are now our regular take out go-to.
I ordered off of DoorDash, this is so good. I got the green chile enchilada pizza and my boyfriend did a build your own calzone. The dough is light and fluffy and the crust on the pizza is also light and fluffy, that’s how you know it’s a great pizza. The green chile flavor on the pizza is balanced so it’s not spicy at all. We will definitely order again and come in sometime!
This place is amazing.. I have ordered here over 20 times in the last 2 months since discovering this place.. was so sad when they announced they were closing and now that they are back I’ve never been more thrilled. My ABSOLUTE favorite pizza in Omaha. I’m trying the burger next week when it’s back.
Loading...