Order at counter, there were 7 of us.My order was not good, I didn't eat it. It was supposed to have been linguini with pesto .It was flavorless angel hair pasta with about a half inch of green tinted olive oil. Everyone else liked what they ordered.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
bswi007
Nice place for Lunch or Dinner at a reasonable price!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Lasagna
Chandler Carlson
Amazing food with insane consistency, awesome staff and atmosphere. You can tell they really care here.
Average at most. What is all this reviews? The pizza is average at best. And the appetizer also average at best. The pizza is identical to Hunt Bros Pizza at the gas station for $10. Seriously it’s identical
Pizza has 0 crisp to it, 0 undercarriage. Sloppy.
Sourdough doesn’t even beat Walmart $1 loaf. Cheese sticks undercooked.
Only thing good I can say is the sauce is great and the meatballs are great. Anchovies on side are standard. Pizza crust 3 star at most.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Rob Ruiz
Good italian food. Ive had better though. I would love more sauce and more meat in my dishes. The service is very lack luster. Also, its been the same for a while, would love to see some experimentation from time to time.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Creamy Chicken Alfredo
Kirsten A
After a recent poll about the cheesiest pizzas in Omaha I figured it would be a great family dinner on our way back to Lincoln.
Started with the Honey Wheat Rolls which were good but honestly we ended up taking them home and eating with preserves. My husband Loved the Mushroom soup special. He got the Spaghetti and meatballs with an Italian sausage on the side. Enjoyed it all but said nothing really stood out.
Five Cheese White Pizza, which was recommended over and over again was definitely Super Cheesy! The kids and I loved it. I'd have no problem eating this many more times in the future.
Service was great, lots of youngins, all keeping very busy. Incredibly friendly, lots of people in line, it was an ideal Family oriented restaurant!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Andy Gregory
We LOVE sgt. Peffers and their staff! we have always had great experiences with menu questions and the food itself is phenomenal! the california soup alone would make me come back every wednesday! i highly recommend stopping by to give it a try. you won’t be disappointed!
The soup was cold the bread roll tasted under cooked and the shrimp scampi was the worst thing I ever tasted the noodles were burnt all stuck together the shrimpa were over cooked tasted like eating rocks and it rest in a bowl of oil /butter sauce horrible!!!!!!!!!!!;
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Rosanne Marie
It had been several years.... it's gone downhill.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Heather Gray
They were super busy when I went in. Molly helped me and was absolutely lovely! The whole staff was so helpful to each other. Got my food back to work and it was cooked perfectly! Thanks for being awesome!!
Tried to give this place a try again tonight. Still very underwhelming. Last time I tried the chicken parm.... the chicken was not crusted, just sliced up chicken on pasta no cheese melted on top and red sauce very acidic tasting like it was tomato past thinned out with no seasoning. Tonight thought I'd try lasagna. Before ordering I asked the employee at the counter if you used full sheets of lasagna making the dish, she said yes. I thought ok, great. Got the dish, no meat in it as described on the menu, no cheese, purely just the sheets broken into pieces probably about 8-10 chunks drenched in the same acidic unseasoned sauce with no cheese in the dish to be found. Last time I checked lasagna is layered not tossed in with a 1/2 full bowl of sauce. No mozzarella on top as the employee stated there was.Another item to not was the roll that comes with the soup / or salad. Another employee who got that part of the order together asked if we wanted a warm roll, yes please! He grabbed a roll out of the warmer where they are typically warmed to perfection and squeezed the roll and it appeared hard. He then grabbed a different roll from a tub full of rolls on the bottom shelf of a stainless steel work table. Warmed it in the microwave and brought it to the table. Roll had a tough crust to it as you get from only warming breads in a microwave. I will not be back to try this another time. Perhaps you could get some recipe help from Romas in Bellevue, where the food is great. Chicken parm is the best.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Abby S
I used Sgt Peffers in Millard for my wedding and it was great! They were able to prepare for 400 people, deliver, and serve! It was great. BUT to top it off, I had a “pasta emergency” at work this week where my order with another pasta restaurant in Omaha fell through and Sgt Peffers accommodated us with a 50 person lunch with less than 24 hour notice. I was so thankful!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Alfredo, Mostaccioli and Meatballs, Roll
al Metz
Didn't dine in customer service was excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mostaccioli and Meatballs, Roll
Lawrence Jones
I don’t usually leave reviews but I felt I had to this time. I have had Chicken Alfredo from numerous places all over and have never had it as bland as here. I took 2 bites and had to toss it due to the lack of flavor. This is the drawback from getting food delivered. I can’t even get something different after this disappointment.
Order at counter, there were 7 of us.My order was not good, I didn't eat it.
It was supposed to have been linguini with pesto .It was flavorless angel hair pasta with about a half inch of green tinted olive oil.
Everyone else liked what they ordered.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Nice place for Lunch or Dinner at a reasonable price!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Lasagna
Amazing food with insane consistency, awesome staff and atmosphere. You can tell they really care here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Honey Wheat Rolls, Seafood Lasagna, Alfredo
Average at most. What is all this reviews? The pizza is average at best. And the appetizer also average at best. The pizza is identical to Hunt Bros Pizza at the gas station for $10. Seriously it’s identical
Pizza has 0 crisp to it, 0 undercarriage. Sloppy.
Sourdough doesn’t even beat Walmart $1 loaf. Cheese sticks undercooked.
Only thing good I can say is the sauce is great and the meatballs are great. Anchovies on side are standard. Pizza crust 3 star at most.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Good italian food. Ive had better though. I would love more sauce and more meat in my dishes. The service is very lack luster. Also, its been the same for a while, would love to see some experimentation from time to time.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Creamy Chicken Alfredo
After a recent poll about the cheesiest pizzas in Omaha I figured it would be a great family dinner on our way back to Lincoln.
Started with the Honey Wheat Rolls which were good but honestly we ended up taking them home and eating with preserves. My husband Loved the Mushroom soup special. He got the Spaghetti and meatballs with an Italian sausage on the side. Enjoyed it all but said nothing really stood out.
Five Cheese White Pizza, which was recommended over and over again was definitely Super Cheesy! The kids and I loved it. I'd have no problem eating this many more times in the future.
Service was great, lots of youngins, all keeping very busy. Incredibly friendly, lots of people in line, it was an ideal Family oriented restaurant!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
We LOVE sgt. Peffers and their staff! we have always had great experiences with menu questions and the food itself is phenomenal! the california soup alone would make me come back every wednesday! i highly recommend stopping by to give it a try. you won’t be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fettuccine Alfredo, Chicken Alfredo, Roll, Garlic Bread, Soup Salad and Rolls
The soup was cold the bread roll tasted under cooked and the shrimp scampi was the worst thing I ever tasted the noodles were burnt all stuck together the shrimpa were over cooked tasted like eating rocks and it rest in a bowl of oil /butter sauce horrible!!!!!!!!!!!;
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
It had been several years.... it's gone downhill.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
They were super busy when I went in. Molly helped me and was absolutely lovely! The whole staff was so helpful to each other. Got my food back to work and it was cooked perfectly! Thanks for being awesome!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Tried to give this place a try again tonight. Still very underwhelming. Last time I tried the chicken parm.... the chicken was not crusted, just sliced up chicken on pasta no cheese melted on top and red sauce very acidic tasting like it was tomato past thinned out with no seasoning. Tonight thought I'd try lasagna. Before ordering I asked the employee at the counter if you used full sheets of lasagna making the dish, she said yes. I thought ok, great. Got the dish, no meat in it as described on the menu, no cheese, purely just the sheets broken into pieces probably about 8-10 chunks drenched in the same acidic unseasoned sauce with no cheese in the dish to be found. Last time I checked lasagna is layered not tossed in with a 1/2 full bowl of sauce. No mozzarella on top as the employee stated there was.Another item to not was the roll that comes with the soup / or salad. Another employee who got that part of the order together asked if we wanted a warm roll, yes please! He grabbed a roll out of the warmer where they are typically warmed to perfection and squeezed the roll and it appeared hard. He then grabbed a different roll from a tub full of rolls on the bottom shelf of a stainless steel work table. Warmed it in the microwave and brought it to the table. Roll had a tough crust to it as you get from only warming breads in a microwave. I will not be back to try this another time. Perhaps you could get some recipe help from Romas in Bellevue, where the food is great. Chicken parm is the best.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
I used Sgt Peffers in Millard for my wedding and it was great! They were able to prepare for 400 people, deliver, and serve! It was great. BUT to top it off, I had a “pasta emergency” at work this week where my order with another pasta restaurant in Omaha fell through and Sgt Peffers accommodated us with a 50 person lunch with less than 24 hour notice. I was so thankful!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Alfredo, Mostaccioli and Meatballs, Roll
Didn't dine in customer service was excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mostaccioli and Meatballs, Roll
I don’t usually leave reviews but I felt I had to this time. I have had Chicken Alfredo from numerous places all over and have never had it as bland as here. I took 2 bites and had to toss it due to the lack of flavor. This is the drawback from getting food delivered. I can’t even get something different after this disappointment.
Food: 3
Love the food ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...