Sgt. Peffer's Cafe Italian

13760 Millard Ave, Omaha
(402) 932-6211

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Slightly Average

Very good real Italian

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pamela Elizabeth Brodkey

I Highly Recommend Going This Restaurant & Save Some Room & Stamina For Homey Inn For Champagne đŸ„‚ đŸŸOn Tap At The Homey Inn Bar When You & You’re Entourage Have Completed Your Dinner!

Rick Johnson

This is a great place for Italian food. It is not a fancy place but the food quality is really good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

ronald kwick

Pizza was excellent. Called ahead for a combo. Called at the last second before closing, they were happy to take the order. I was happy to wait 5 mins. Very courteous help. Will return when I have enough time to eat in. Very clean with pleasant decor. Price was very reasonable.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kenneth Manahl

Rolls were better than the one on Leavenworth but Leavenworth's chili tastes better. My Son loved the pepperoni pizza he ordered. Service was awesome 👍😎. I wish both places had better chairs that don't feel like they are going to buckle and break when a big guy such as myself sits on them.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Sandy G.

Two days ago, we ordered food to be delivered to our house for my dad’s birthday party. The delivery was on time, and very reasonable. The seafood lasagna, beef lasagna, grilled chicken salad, and rolls were outstanding
perfectly made!!! The portions are also very generous. Can’t wait to eat at their restaurant again or have them cater another special event!!! Definitely one of the best Italian restaurants around!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ciarra Wagner

I want to share my experience with catering. I hosted a 100 person event. A Friend recommended this place. I'm sure glad they did! I ordered five deep dish pans. Chicken alfredo, a shrimp option, a red sauce with beef ravioli, and a mostaccioli pasta. I asked in my order for extra sauce and they were kind enough to bring me some extra sauce on the side too. The food was a hit. People were all asking where the food was from. The owners delivered the food. It was nice and hot. The left overs have also gone over well. I will definitely be catering from this location again! The price felt right to. Thank you, thank you! Good food and good people. 😊

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stacey M.

Worst pasta I've ever eaten. Looked/tasted like they just dumped a can of unseasoned tomato paste on noodles. They also forgot to put our cheesy bread in our to-go order, so we never got to taste that. If you want cheap pasta, please save yourself and just go to Fazoli's!

Nebbaseball2

If you’re gonna charge $22 for a pizza at least cook it thoroughly. Got my food and the dough was doughy and undercooked. The service itself was fine, just gotta learn to cook that food longer to ensure it’s cooked properly.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Robert Strunk

I want to first state, that I am a huge fan of their Pizza. However, I wanted to explore of the Menu, so being a lover of Lasagna, I tried theirs.
To my disappointment, it was an absolute joke.
It could have qualified for the third Soup on the Menu. It was a wallet sized stack of noodles, with perhaps a Tablespoon each of meat bits, and Alfredo Sauce, along with maybe an ounce of Mozzarella Cheese, just swimming in a Pasta Boat full of bland Marinara Sauce-- Not even Bolognese!
In my 20 years in the Italian Restaurant Business, I would have been ashamed to have my name associated with that dish.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Ida Causevic

Canned chicken in everything, Alfredo tasted like nothing, pizza was made on frozen crust. Cut too many corners and you get Italian fast food that tastes underwhelming. So disappointing because when I walked in it smelled so good.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

Michael Nawojski

The pizza and pasta is a classic flavor I have enjoyed since I was 5 years old! It's rare at this age to have something trigger long lost memories like this place does. I thank you for that

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rodney Rahl

Get the chicken salad. Omg. So great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Belise Draper

Ordered food to be picked up, service over the phone was great. The food is less expensive if you call in your order, the food was absolutely delicious, love their white fresh-baked rolls.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Maxwell Braaten

Got the 5 sauce red, it was fantastic. The 9 inch was perfect for 2. Service was great and the Beatles theme was cool.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Loading...