Friendly staff and I was excited to try this but i found the chicken tough in the chicken pot, it was a bit bland.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
David Lippmeier
If you like comforting, rich, substantial pot pies, The Pot Pie Bar does a excellent job. The Chicken Pot Pie is incredibly satisfying, classic in its comfort, with good crust and filling. The Braised Short Rib Pie is even more indulgent, more of a treat, with tender meat and heft. The take‑and‑bake format is well executed: convenience is high, prep is minimal, and the result feels homemade without being a hassle.
If I were you and wanted something quick, delicious, and comforting, these pies are an excellent choice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Bergeron
We got a pot pie from them at a farmers market event a couple years ago and it was great! I was so excited when I found out they had opened a retail shop in Goffstown. Unfortunately they don’t keep many pies in stock, this was our second time trying to get a buffalo chicken pot pie and leaving empty handed. The first time we went they didn’t have any pot pies at all, they said they had only recently opened and were still figuring things out. The person I spoke with said they’d have stuff in stock in a couple weeks. I waited a few weeks (maybe a month?) and gave them another shot. Checked their website and nothing indicated they were out of what I wanted so I went across town only to be disappointed again. This isn’t really a retail location, more of a place to pick up pre ordered pies. Don’t waste your time stopping in, make sure to call ahead.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Andrea Houle
My family and I have ordered the bacon mac & cheese pot pie 2x and we just tried the Brat & cheddar pie. They have all been delicious! The crust is so flaky and all the ingredients are very flavorful. My only recommendations is to offer an XL version for larger families. We will be ordering again!
Janet Surak
The pot pie bar that has no pot pies!!! I am blown away at this. The place is literally called “THE POT PIE BAR”
I went in once last week and the only pot pies available were three pulled pork pot pies. Other than that, their freezer was completely empty except for pre-orders. I was told I could get a chicken pot pie at five but unfortunately could not return on that day.
I called today and asked for a small chicken pot pie which I told would be ready around five. I went in at five. They did not have any small chicken pot pies so I had to get a large chicken pot pie, which is ridiculous because I’m one person.
Again their freezer was completely empty, except for the same three frozen pulled pork pies from last week. When I questioned why there was absolutely no inventory for anyone to just walk in and buy a pot pie I was told I should call in advance to pre-order.
The fact that you call yourself “THE POT PIE BAR” but you cannot get a warm pot pie there. And there’s absolutely no inventory at that location to buy a pot pie. It is utterly ridiculous.
This better be the best damn pie I have ever had in my life. Trust me I will be getting back to this post.
*** UPDATE. the pot pie was tasty but most of the chicken was tough. My original Post stands and I will not be pre-ordering.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Gary Schulman
We recently had some neighbors over for dinner and decided to try 4 different pot pies – turkey, chicken, short ribs and beef stroganoff. All were outstanding, with plenty of meat and everyone was impressed. Beats carry out pizza or sushi by a wide margin. Keep the pot pies coming!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laura Kirby
Simply put, amazing!! We have purchased several of the varieties and each one was outstanding. What I love most is that they are handmade, from scratch, with fresh ingredients. We have recommended to numerous friends, who have also thoroughly enjoyed them. We actually keep several in the freezer for times when we need to prepare a quick meal at a moment's notice. Given the demand for the pies, which we have seen grow considerably, I'd suggest going earlier in the day before they run out of inventory. Better yet, you can order pies in advance through the website and the order will be ready when you arrive for pickup. That's the best way to guarantee you will have the pies when you need them. Well done Pot Pie Bar!!!!
Laura
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Melbourne
I’ve been following the Pot Pie Bar since they first opened in Bedford, and now to their new spot in Pinardville. The classic chicken is always solid, but what keeps me coming back is how creative they get with the flavors. The short rib pot pie is unreal... definitely a must-try.
The staff is super friendly every time I go in, and the new storefront is such an upgrade. You can tell they put a lot of thought into it.
Only thing to know: these pies go quick! I’d recommend calling in the morning to see what flavors they’ve got that day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pam Blevens
First time ordering and not what I was expecting for $12 No bottom crust, not much to it for what you pay. Husband said it was just okay
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Karen Eldridge
We have purchased 2 chicken pot pies and a short rib , I found the chicken pot pie VERY bland , not much flavor and I found the chicken in it really really tough, I have never had such tough and chewy chicken. Why is the chicken flavorless and so tough? I liked the raised short rib however did find it bland as well. This is positive feedback hoping they change things before it’s too late, because I would absolutely be a regular but not right now.
Tried the short rib pie..Crust was flaky and had a good amount of short ribs..Not enough vegetables and gravy too thick..Was not deep enough ..Still have the chicken pot pie..Will try that one.
William Waddington
For a place that just opened they have no product.They will neverale it
Debbie Padden
This is my first tiime here, had the chicken cordon bleu, hot and ready single serving. It was great! The staff was pleasant too, Ill definitely be back! Great price too for a one person meal!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott
Didn’t taste very good and there was no bottom crust. You can tell they just roll of an assembly line. Not what I would have expected from a place specializing in one type of food. I had a gift card and never went back and used it after tasting the first one
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Matt
Wow the turkey pie is so good. I’m glad I got 2 of them. Can’t wait to try the short ribs. 😊
Friendly staff and I was excited to try this but i found the chicken tough in the chicken pot, it was a bit bland.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
If you like comforting, rich, substantial pot pies, The Pot Pie Bar does a excellent job. The Chicken Pot Pie is incredibly satisfying, classic in its comfort, with good crust and filling. The Braised Short Rib Pie is even more indulgent, more of a treat, with tender meat and heft. The take‑and‑bake format is well executed: convenience is high, prep is minimal, and the result feels homemade without being a hassle.
If I were you and wanted something quick, delicious, and comforting, these pies are an excellent choice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We got a pot pie from them at a farmers market event a couple years ago and it was great! I was so excited when I found out they had opened a retail shop in Goffstown. Unfortunately they don’t keep many pies in stock, this was our second time trying to get a buffalo chicken pot pie and leaving empty handed. The first time we went they didn’t have any pot pies at all, they said they had only recently opened and were still figuring things out. The person I spoke with said they’d have stuff in stock in a couple weeks.
I waited a few weeks (maybe a month?) and gave them another shot. Checked their website and nothing indicated they were out of what I wanted so I went across town only to be disappointed again. This isn’t really a retail location, more of a place to pick up pre ordered pies. Don’t waste your time stopping in, make sure to call ahead.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
My family and I have ordered the bacon mac & cheese pot pie 2x and we just tried the Brat & cheddar pie. They have all been delicious! The crust is so flaky and all the ingredients are very flavorful. My only recommendations is to offer an XL version for larger families. We will be ordering again!
The pot pie bar that has no pot pies!!! I am blown away at this. The place is literally called “THE POT PIE BAR”
I went in once last week and the only pot pies available were three pulled pork pot pies. Other than that, their freezer was completely empty except for pre-orders. I was told I could get a chicken pot pie at five but unfortunately could not return on that day.
I called today and asked for a small chicken pot pie which I told would be ready around five. I went in at five. They did not have any small chicken pot pies so I had to get a large chicken pot pie, which is ridiculous because I’m one person.
Again their freezer was completely empty, except for the same three frozen pulled pork pies from last week. When I questioned why there was absolutely no inventory for anyone to just walk in and buy a pot pie I was told I should call in advance to pre-order.
The fact that you call yourself “THE POT PIE BAR” but you cannot get a warm pot pie there. And there’s absolutely no inventory at that location to buy a pot pie. It is utterly ridiculous.
This better be the best damn pie I have ever had in my life. Trust me I will be getting back to this post.
*** UPDATE. the pot pie was tasty but most of the chicken was tough. My original Post stands and I will not be pre-ordering.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
We recently had some neighbors over for dinner and decided to try 4 different pot pies – turkey, chicken, short ribs and beef stroganoff. All were outstanding, with plenty of meat and everyone was impressed. Beats carry out pizza or sushi by a wide margin. Keep the pot pies coming!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Simply put, amazing!! We have purchased several of the varieties and each one was outstanding. What I love most is that they are handmade, from scratch, with fresh ingredients. We have recommended to numerous friends, who have also thoroughly enjoyed them. We actually keep several in the freezer for times when we need to prepare a quick meal at a moment's notice. Given the demand for the pies, which we have seen grow considerably, I'd suggest going earlier in the day before they run out of inventory. Better yet, you can order pies in advance through the website and the order will be ready when you arrive for pickup. That's the best way to guarantee you will have the pies when you need them. Well done Pot Pie Bar!!!!
Laura
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve been following the Pot Pie Bar since they first opened in Bedford, and now to their new spot in Pinardville. The classic chicken is always solid, but what keeps me coming back is how creative they get with the flavors. The short rib pot pie is unreal... definitely a must-try.
The staff is super friendly every time I go in, and the new storefront is such an upgrade. You can tell they put a lot of thought into it.
Only thing to know: these pies go quick! I’d recommend calling in the morning to see what flavors they’ve got that day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time ordering and not what I was expecting for $12 No bottom crust, not much to it for what you pay. Husband said it was just okay
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
We have purchased 2 chicken pot pies and a short rib , I found the chicken pot pie VERY bland , not much flavor and I found the chicken in it really really tough, I have never had such tough and chewy chicken. Why is the chicken flavorless and so tough? I liked the raised short rib however did find it bland as well. This is positive feedback hoping they change things before it’s too late, because I would absolutely be a regular but not right now.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
Tried the short rib pie..Crust was flaky and had a good amount of short ribs..Not enough vegetables and gravy too thick..Was not deep enough ..Still have the chicken pot pie..Will try that one.
For a place that just opened they have no product.They will neverale it
This is my first tiime here, had the chicken cordon bleu, hot and ready single serving. It was great! The staff was pleasant too, Ill definitely be back! Great price too for a one person meal!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Didn’t taste very good and there was no bottom crust. You can tell they just roll of an assembly line. Not what I would have expected from a place specializing in one type of food. I had a gift card and never went back and used it after tasting the first one
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Wow the turkey pie is so good. I’m glad I got 2 of them. Can’t wait to try the short ribs. 😊
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Turkey Pot Pie
Loading...