Mystic Sugar Bakery
$ • Bakery, Custom Cakes, CupcakesAbout Mystic Sugar Bakery
Customers' Favorites
Assorted Bakery Cookies and Muffins
Lemon-Blueberry Cupcake
Cookie Butter Cupcake
Blueberry Muffin
Cinnamon Rolls
Birthday Cake
Chocolate Cake
Wedding Cake
Dark Magic
Croissant
Mystic Sugar Bakery Reviews
227 ratings
Share your opinion about Mystic Sugar Bakery
Pure Magic. visiting from Florida and was dragged into this little gem. decor is very cool. a "Wizard of Oz" theme and cupcakes that would make the wicked witch chuckle in delight... bought 2, then bought two more the next day and had to bring a few home with me... the Turkey Club was MASSIVE... hint for families.. its sharable.
Stopped here for a quick breakfast. The apple Carmel and peach muffins were on point! The pumpkin scone was amazing as well - will definitely be going back on our next trip!
My family and I made our first trip to Mystic Sugar Bakery today. We loved the creative Harry Potter themed names and the cupcakes are delicious! Perfectly moist cake with just the right amount of flavor and filling, topped with light and fluffy frosting.
The woman at the counter was very nice and even offered to hold our cupcakes while we had lunch so they wouldn’t melt in the car.
We will be back!
The woman at the counter was very nice and even offered to hold our cupcakes while we had lunch so they wouldn’t melt in the car.
We will be back!
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 9AM - 4PM |
| Thursday | 9AM - 4PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 4PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 4PM |
| Sunday | 9AM - 3PM |
Mystic Sugar Bakery is a charming and whimsical establishment that offers an array of delightful homemade treats. The magical decor creates a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for enjoying the bakery's impressive menu. Customers praise the exceptional quality of the bakery's offerings, from moist and flavorful muffins and scones to the best chocolate chip cookies they've ever had.
The bakery's cupcakes are particularly noteworthy, with their distinct flavors that are not overly sweet. Customers describe the overall experience as a "very beautiful cute little mysterious themed cafe" and a "must visit" for those in the area. The bakery also hosts a popular English Tea Time on every second Sunday, adding to the whimsical and charming experience.
In addition to the bakery's signature items, customers have also enjoyed the chewy molasses cookies, the biscuit breakfast sandwiches, and the grilled cheese sandwich, which was described as the best they've ever tried. The bakery's friendly staff and commitment to accommodating customer requests further contribute to the positive dining experience.