11 Best Pizza Restaurants near Peterborough

“The creations that come out of this establishment, are top-notch! Today I ordered the sugar shack pizza and would 100% order it again anytime. The flavor combination of bbq and maple syrup was like no other. Perfect undercarriage and crisp!!“

“Great food! I really appreciate that they have cheap slices. They make for a great, quick lunch if you don't have a big appetite for your own pizza or calzone. The sandwiches are also fantastic, but not for the faint of heart. If you have a smaller appetite, even the small versions might be too much!

The pizzas themselves have great texture: chewy, a hearty amount of toppings, crusts that are not too crunchy, and slices that fold perfectly (if that’s how you like to eat your pizza).
The calzones are something else - I had a dessert version once that was absolutely heavenly: ricotta and mango, wrapped up in a delicious crust. The savory versions are likewise excellent. I don't think I will ever be able to eat a calzone again after having had them at Pancho's Pizza - nothing else will quite compare to ones baked with such care and love! (Full disclosure - I also don’t know that I ever had a calzone before, so perhaps they are always that amazing.)

The dining rooms (there are two) are spacious and have plenty to offer. The reddish-brown room has the front order counter, a fair amount of tables, and a wonderful assortment of plants that make it a pleasant place to sit and eat.
The blue one features a pool table, several booths, barstool seating, and a kid-friendly play area in the back. In the multiple times that I have stopped in Pancho’s, the kid area was a popular spot for young families. It was nice to see parents relaxing waiting for a meal knowing that the kids have a safe area to play while the food is being prepared.

All in all, a great place to stop in for a slice or a meal. If you are in the area, it is not to be missed!“

“Delicious subs, especially the steak bomb! Amazing!“

“I'm not generally a fan of Greek style pizza but I love the cheese on their pizza. I crave it at times. Of the two Greek style places in town, I prefer Pizza Peddler by far. I don't find it too saucy like I do other places. That being said if you like a lot of sauce you might want to ask for extra. Not sure the exact size of the pizza but the largest aren't really that big. And there smalls are, well, small. No medium option. The inside is bright and nothing to write home about but I've never actually eaten there so I can't comment on that experience. Prices seem comparable to every other place in town. The subs are okay but I've only had the steak and cheese.“

“Great family owned business. The food is great. Very fresh ingredients and sometimes sourced locally. Tony & Shannon are wonderful hosts.“

“I’ve had the steak and cheese multiple times, very good. I’ve also ordered the haddock dinner plate and it was so delicious. I like fried haddock and I love steak and cheese and I’ve always felt welcomed and appreciated when I pick up my order or when I have dined in. Great people and great food. I love small businesses, they often serve much better food, more fresh, and a cleaner atmosphere, than any corporate/chain restaurant. Definitely worth checking out.“

“Great pizza, the bacon with ham was delicious. Also, the subs are good, but the pizzas are worth it. I drove 1 1/2 hours from Lawrence, so I have had my fair share of various pizza places.Good job Athens ?

Parking: Spacious parking lot“

“Good pizza that was cooked perfectly and they didn’t skimp me on pepperoni ???, fried mushrooms were crunchy and hot, the pesto garlic bread with cheese was delicious! The people behind the counter were friendly and answered any questions we had. With that being said the place was pretty busy, I could tell they were doing their best to keep up with orders. We will be returning!“

“Pizza was really good! Staff was very friendly

Kid-friendliness: Basement hangover things that are more important dishes and dinner helping us cleaned up and I need to get a shower and I wanna nap so I don’t think we’re gonna get to the trash with all that stuff today and Santa went to bed and do it early it’s only a day and a half p.m. five is what I mean is from now my know you can’t just do it OK then I’m

Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible ?“

“Food was excellent as well as their service“

“good stuff!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!“