Atlantic Grill

5 Pioneer Rd, Rye
(603) 433-3000

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Marc

Service was really terrible - slow and for some reason the waitress had a low level hostility towards the table - unknown why. I'm not sure what the beef tenderloin was glued together from but it was an odd texture and color - drinks didn't arrive and side choices were all wrong - but not worth risking the ire of the waitress by mentioning anything.

Nicholas

We celebrated a 50th birthday party for 8 attendees and the food was excellent. The service was amazing, and our waitress Melissa went above and beyond to make sure we had a memorable experience. Highly recommend for small gatherings or personal dining.

Ramona

Had an early dinner reservation ((4:30) . Our booth was next to the bar which was a very noisy spot. Husband ask for coffee..it was cold. He had short ribs which were very good..said he would order again. I had haddock piccata. Fish cooked perfectly but the broccolini served with is was practically raw. You couldn't cut this with a steak knife. This was not the pleasant experience we hoped.

Pam

We had a delicious dinner. All seven of us loved our meal. We had the haddock piccata the butter poached lobster the salmon a wedge salad Seafood chowder and strawberry shortcake. Everything was outstanding.

Robert

Great place to go for a meal or a drink. Everytime we stop in the food is great, drinks are the best, and the place feels comfy. Our server, Christie, did a great job. She was attentive and communative. Had a great meal, good time. Would recommend.

Brodie Cusack

outstanding ambience, food and tremendous service. the prices are very fair as well.

Kim

Excellent service, comfortable dining room and good variety of menu options. The service is always on point. The food is very well prepared, and the kitchen will make reasonable accommodations (no tomatoes, extra dressing for the salad...). Full bar with creative cocktail, and they offer outdoor seating with a heated patio.

RobertB

Went Saturday for our 56th anniversary and couldn't have been happier. Everyone was pleasant, efficient and the food was great. We also got a free dessert! Our waitress was Alyssa and she was wonderful.

Paul

Always a great dining experience at Atlantic Grille. Rene was awesome!! Food was fresh, hot, and delicious!! Love the coastal feel of the decor! Relaxing and comfortable.

Deb

So wonderful to know that most of the menu can be made gluten free. Excellent service, delightful garden seating and delicious food. This place is a favorite for us!

Gail

I took my son here back in 2018 when he graduated college and we had one of the best meals ever. Don't know why it took me so long to come back but came back this past Friday night, had the fillet and crab, and it was out of this world. The restaurant is beautiful, clean and the service was fantastic!

Jeremiah

Solid spot with a lot of competition around it. Parking is convenient, food and service always on point.

Amy

Choice of seating options (outdoor, indoor, & bar). Good variety of items on the menu. My seafood dish was fresh. Friendly attentive staff. Overall, great visit. Will return.

Lou

Have always enjoyed our visits to the Atlantic Grill. Consistently good food, fine beverage selection. Can be loud at peak times, so outside dining is our preference.

Shirley

I had the halibut which was delicious. Lots of good seafood choices. The drinks are very good. Everyone in our party had seafood including lobster, haddock, salmon and swordfish. It was all very good.

Loading...