Amazing and unique food with perfect service. We were delighted to find this gem. The whitefish pâté was a wonderful appetizer, served on a crisp block of hash browned potatoes. House made Parker House rolls were definitely worth the carbs! The pollack and monkfish entrees were amazing. We highly recommend this elevated dining experience!!
Amy
Sat is a small room to ourselves with a large picture window with a view of the ocean. Enjoyed some local oysters, black bass crudo, their black truffle pasta special and ny strip steak. Everything was delicious and plates were cleaned by the end of each course. The pacing of the food was perfect. We cap the meal off with a slice of carrot cake with a cream cheese mousse frosting and swapped the ginger ice cream with mascarpone ice cream. Service was delightful. 10/10 can't wait to go back!
Paul
Went to Carriage House Saturday night with friends. Everything was great, except my friend's Hangar Steak and the rest of the food on the plate came out cold. It took longer than usual to get our food, so it means it had to be sitting. They redid the dish as quickly as possible, but of course it disturbed our dinner. Mistakes happen, but I was disappointed they didn't offer him a free dessert.
Victor
We've been going to The Carriage House for years, and we still love it just as much as the first day! The people are always warm and welcoming, the food is consistently excellent, and the cozy atmosphere makes it the perfect spot to enjoy time with friends and family. A true local gem!
Susan
The service and food were excellent. We asked to sit upstairs and were able to do so. We were met at the door and made to feel welcome from the very beginning. Our server was attentive to the timing of ordering and the food delicious. We will definitely visit again soon!!
Maria
Every single dish we had was delicious. You can tell the quality of the local seasonal ingredients because their flavors aren't masked by a of bunch of chef wizardry. Deeply flavored seasonal dishes that really hit the mark!
Jennifer
Beautiful and wonderful experience. Service was slow. Our fish was super salty. But would highly recommend nonetheless .
Betty Dehart
Great service great food
Eric Tholomé
They went out of their way to accommodate our request for a view, everyone was super friendly in an authentic way, the food was really good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joan Pettengill
We celebrated a wonderful birthday dinner here. Reservations are recommended. We got here just before they opened and sat at the bar. Picturesque view of the ocean. Bartender was attentive and talented. We shared the swordfish and tuna dishes which were prepared with detail and very delicious. The desserts are unique and wonderful. We shall return.
Excellent ! Our server RJ was so cheerful and knowledgeable and made our dining experience very pleasurable . Had the tuna steak this visit it was cooked to perfection as was the Wife's fish entree . We've never had anything below a 5 star experience at the Carriage House, highly recommended ! You won't be disappointed ! Gary & Carol Barrell from Albany NY
Kevin Scannell
The Lobster Gnocchi is absolutely amazing. I mean its been a while since i put gnocchi in my mouth and said “hot damn, this is some flipping good gnocchi “. And that happened. Mind the market price, because at 72 dollars it may make you think “should i?” But the answer is still a yes you should, this one time.
I do have to knock a star off because of the server. They were very charming and on top of our table. However they forgot our apps, so they came after the mains and only after i reminded the server. Not really a big deal, except im paying the equivalent of a monthly car payment for a meal for two people so i expect that not to happen.
The atmosphere is intimate but and dark. I did not notice anything overly charming and was very aware of the other people as they did their job. Nothing bad but nothing special.
Parking: The free lot has 6 spots and will surely be filled unless your deity happens to be guiding your travels. Across the street is a paid lot which depending on the time of year will also be filled because its for a beach. So sacrifice a goat before you depart for Carriage House and pray on the way.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Lobster Gnocchi
Dan L
Place is amazing! Great food, a must try!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: East Coast Oysters, Lobster Gnocchi, Hanger Steak
jackie
Truly every aspect of our dining experiences there have been the best. I live nearby and bring friends from out of town there! All have been very impressed with the food experience the service and ambiance are always great as well!
Jennifer
Outstanding experience at The Carriage House! The food was exquisite, and there were so many unique offerings we cannot wait to return to try all the options. Our server was excellent, and all of the staff went above and beyond. Also, the view is priceless!
Amazing and unique food with perfect service. We were delighted to find this gem. The whitefish pâté was a wonderful appetizer, served on a crisp block of hash browned potatoes. House made Parker House rolls were definitely worth the carbs! The pollack and monkfish entrees were amazing. We highly recommend this elevated dining experience!!
Sat is a small room to ourselves with a large picture window with a view of the ocean. Enjoyed some local oysters, black bass crudo, their black truffle pasta special and ny strip steak. Everything was delicious and plates were cleaned by the end of each course. The pacing of the food was perfect. We cap the meal off with a slice of carrot cake with a cream cheese mousse frosting and swapped the ginger ice cream with mascarpone ice cream. Service was delightful. 10/10 can't wait to go back!
Went to Carriage House Saturday night with friends. Everything was great, except my friend's Hangar Steak and the rest of the food on the plate came out cold. It took longer than usual to get our food, so it means it had to be sitting. They redid the dish as quickly as possible, but of course it disturbed our dinner. Mistakes happen, but I was disappointed they didn't offer him a free dessert.
We've been going to The Carriage House for years, and we still love it just as much as the first day! The people are always warm and welcoming, the food is consistently excellent, and the cozy atmosphere makes it the perfect spot to enjoy time with friends and family. A true local gem!
The service and food were excellent. We asked to sit upstairs and were able to do so. We were met at the door and made to feel welcome from the very beginning. Our server was attentive to the timing of ordering and the food delicious. We will definitely visit again soon!!
Every single dish we had was delicious. You can tell the quality of the local seasonal ingredients because their flavors aren't masked by a of bunch of chef wizardry. Deeply flavored seasonal dishes that really hit the mark!
Beautiful and wonderful experience. Service was slow. Our fish was super salty. But would highly recommend nonetheless .
Great service great food
They went out of their way to accommodate our request for a view, everyone was super friendly in an authentic way, the food was really good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We celebrated a wonderful birthday dinner here. Reservations are recommended. We got here just before they opened and sat at the bar. Picturesque view of the ocean. Bartender was attentive and talented. We shared the swordfish and tuna dishes which were prepared with detail and very delicious. The desserts are unique and wonderful. We shall return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent ! Our server RJ was so cheerful and knowledgeable and made our dining experience very pleasurable . Had the tuna steak this visit it was cooked to perfection as was the Wife's fish entree . We've never had anything below a 5 star experience at the Carriage House, highly recommended ! You won't be disappointed ! Gary & Carol Barrell from Albany NY
The Lobster Gnocchi is absolutely amazing. I mean its been a while since i put gnocchi in my mouth and said “hot damn, this is some flipping good gnocchi “. And that happened. Mind the market price, because at 72 dollars it may make you think “should i?” But the answer is still a yes you should, this one time.
I do have to knock a star off because of the server. They were very charming and on top of our table. However they forgot our apps, so they came after the mains and only after i reminded the server. Not really a big deal, except im paying the equivalent of a monthly car payment for a meal for two people so i expect that not to happen.
The atmosphere is intimate but and dark. I did not notice anything overly charming and was very aware of the other people as they did their job. Nothing bad but nothing special.
Parking: The free lot has 6 spots and will surely be filled unless your deity happens to be guiding your travels. Across the street is a paid lot which depending on the time of year will also be filled because its for a beach. So sacrifice a goat before you depart for Carriage House and pray on the way.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Lobster Gnocchi
Place is amazing! Great food, a must try!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: East Coast Oysters, Lobster Gnocchi, Hanger Steak
Truly every aspect of our dining experiences there have been the best. I live nearby and bring friends from out of town there! All have been very impressed with the food experience the service and ambiance are always great as well!
Outstanding experience at The Carriage House! The food was exquisite, and there were so many unique offerings we cannot wait to return to try all the options. Our server was excellent, and all of the staff went above and beyond. Also, the view is priceless!
Loading...