The 5'4 coat check guy with the bad haircut has a Napoleon complex (don't lose your ticket and respectfully ask for help otherwise he just might cry and try to fight you) but this place is still the best around.
Connie Rose
Disappointed, Disrespected, and Put at Risk After Years of Loyalty
I’ve been coming to this bar for over 6 years—my husband (10+) and I own a beach property in West Allenhurst and visit throughout the year. We’ve always supported this establishment, often purchasing bottles and choosing to sit down and enjoy the atmosphere. But tonight, after attending a wedding and arriving dressed accordingly, we were treated with shocking disrespect.
A group of patrons claimed we couldn’t sit in a section they hadn’t even paid for, and immediately targeted my husband with ageist remarks, saying they didn’t want “someone old” near them. When we didn’t move, one individual threatened to physically pick me up and remove me from my seat. I told security that my safety was being threatened, and they refused to address the person who made that threat. Instead, they chose to remove us—longtime, respectful patrons—while allowing a group of visibly intoxicated younger and trashy looking individuals to stay. That decision was not only insulting, it was dangerous.
I spoke with the head of security, who acknowledged that we’ve never caused issues and are known to staff. Yet we were still forced to leave because he “didn’t know the full story.” It was clear that credibility and loyalty meant nothing in that moment.
This experience was deeply upsetting. The lack of professionalism, the tolerance of discriminatory and threatening behavior, and the failure to protect regular patrons is unacceptable. No matter how much money you spend or how long you’ve supported this place, it seems respect, safety, and fairness are no longer part of the culture.
Jeanne Savarese
I had my daughter's wedding there, and it was amazing! We had approximately 100 guests with plenty of dancing room. The food was delicious, with a beautiful bar, an ocean view, and an expansive outside deck. Check it out; you won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason S
Beautiful view of the Ocean, and Stone Pony. Fantastic atmosphere. Lots of seating. Very Clean place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kendall Ambrose
Attended a wedding here over the weekend. I have a really severe gluten allergy so emailed in advance to ensure it could be accommodated - chef Mo took INCREDIBLE care of me. Walked me through all safe food items on the phone & then day of event - Mo checked in before & after every course to make sure I was loving the food/letting me know what out of the options was safe for me. Prevented all cross contact fully and even offered to make me gluten free pasta if I was still hungry! Not only was it super safe everything was delicious. 10/10 recommend - all around incredible time. THANK YOU CHEF MO!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wade Walters
Seems like a chill spot. Nice atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Jack Fusco
Best place to have any kind of party, especially in nice weather.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Angela Campbell
I don't recommend this place staff are rude and management don't care. You will be better off going to someplace else do not come to this place
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dave Lewis
This place is so cool! We love to sit on the upstairs patio bar and watch the sea and the people on the boardwalk. Love this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aaron Huse
The cocktails and melon spritz my friends and I had were terrible. However, we appreciated the view, atmosphere, and quality service. I recommend getting 2 drinks and enjoying the view.
Went to Watermark for the first time with close friends this past week before a concert at the Stone Pony. The drinks were perfectly balanced. Service was great. The food was executed so beautifully. The outdoor rooftop space is casual/comfortable and the inside offers high end lounge vibes. You can spend hours here enjoying every minute of time with loved ones and friends. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
stefy ganduglia
I just left this place celebrating a friend's birthday. They kick out other 2 friends for being tired! Absurd and more! Im not sure why this happened it was so confusing and crazy. Im definitely not coming back. Nothing special about this place. First time and last. You should get a better policy for your place. You cant kick 2 ppl out for not doing anything. BS!!
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Yun Yun Tsai
There is never a sign that I can’t laying down and I just lay down for one minute the security tell me to leave
C. P.
Great view, good little bites, the drinks are hit or miss
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Jessica Carroll
Last night I had roughly 30 friends meet me at Watermark for my birthday. Many living local were there for the first time. Everyone was blown away by the space. Kristy & Michelle took care of everyone and that couldn’t have been easy. Everyone was raving about the food! We had a great night so grateful for the experience.
We did have a situation with the manager on duty, he spoke to one senior woman in the party completely unprofessional. Granted we did make an error and she did apologize, heck we all did. He had No couth whatsoever. Many of the attendees were floored. Some that witnessed the situation decided to leave even a party next to us of 4 women from NY. Decided not to give Watermark any more of the $.
Now granted I have been many time to this establishment and never had a problem. I’m grateful for all that they provide and I will return.
The 5'4 coat check guy with the bad haircut has a Napoleon complex (don't lose your ticket and respectfully ask for help otherwise he just might cry and try to fight you) but this place is still the best around.
Disappointed, Disrespected, and Put at Risk After Years of Loyalty
I’ve been coming to this bar for over 6 years—my husband (10+) and I own a beach property in West Allenhurst and visit throughout the year. We’ve always supported this establishment, often purchasing bottles and choosing to sit down and enjoy the atmosphere. But tonight, after attending a wedding and arriving dressed accordingly, we were treated with shocking disrespect.
A group of patrons claimed we couldn’t sit in a section they hadn’t even paid for, and immediately targeted my husband with ageist remarks, saying they didn’t want “someone old” near them. When we didn’t move, one individual threatened to physically pick me up and remove me from my seat. I told security that my safety was being threatened, and they refused to address the person who made that threat. Instead, they chose to remove us—longtime, respectful patrons—while allowing a group of visibly intoxicated younger and trashy looking individuals to stay. That decision was not only insulting, it was dangerous.
I spoke with the head of security, who acknowledged that we’ve never caused issues and are known to staff. Yet we were still forced to leave because he “didn’t know the full story.” It was clear that credibility and loyalty meant nothing in that moment.
This experience was deeply upsetting. The lack of professionalism, the tolerance of discriminatory and threatening behavior, and the failure to protect regular patrons is unacceptable. No matter how much money you spend or how long you’ve supported this place, it seems respect, safety, and fairness are no longer part of the culture.
I had my daughter's wedding there, and it was amazing! We had approximately 100 guests with plenty of dancing room. The food was delicious, with a beautiful bar, an ocean view, and an expansive outside deck. Check it out; you won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beautiful view of the Ocean, and Stone Pony. Fantastic atmosphere. Lots of seating. Very Clean place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Attended a wedding here over the weekend. I have a really severe gluten allergy so emailed in advance to ensure it could be accommodated - chef Mo took INCREDIBLE care of me. Walked me through all safe food items on the phone & then day of event - Mo checked in before & after every course to make sure I was loving the food/letting me know what out of the options was safe for me. Prevented all cross contact fully and even offered to make me gluten free pasta if I was still hungry! Not only was it super safe everything was delicious. 10/10 recommend - all around incredible time. THANK YOU CHEF MO!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Seems like a chill spot. Nice atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Best place to have any kind of party, especially in nice weather.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I don't recommend this place staff are rude and management don't care. You will be better off going to someplace else do not come to this place
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This place is so cool! We love to sit on the upstairs patio bar and watch the sea and the people on the boardwalk. Love this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cocktails and melon spritz my friends and I had were terrible. However, we appreciated the view, atmosphere, and quality service. I recommend getting 2 drinks and enjoying the view.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Went to Watermark for the first time with close friends this past week before a concert at the Stone Pony. The drinks were perfectly balanced. Service was great. The food was executed so beautifully. The outdoor rooftop space is casual/comfortable and the inside offers high end lounge vibes. You can spend hours here enjoying every minute of time with loved ones and friends. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I just left this place celebrating a friend's birthday. They kick out other 2 friends for being tired! Absurd and more! Im not sure why this happened it was so confusing and crazy. Im definitely not coming back.
Nothing special about this place. First time and last.
You should get a better policy for your place. You cant kick 2 ppl out for not doing anything. BS!!
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
There is never a sign that I can’t laying down and I just lay down for one minute the security tell me to leave
Great view, good little bites, the drinks are hit or miss
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 3
Last night I had roughly 30 friends meet me at Watermark for my birthday. Many living local were there for the first time. Everyone was blown away by the space. Kristy & Michelle took care of everyone and that couldn’t have been easy. Everyone was raving about the food! We had a great night so grateful for the experience.
We did have a situation with the manager on duty, he spoke to one senior woman in the party completely unprofessional. Granted we did make an error and she did apologize, heck we all did. He had No couth whatsoever. Many of the attendees were floored. Some that witnessed the situation decided to leave even a party next to us of 4 women from NY. Decided not to give Watermark any more of the $.
Now granted I have been many time to this establishment and never had a problem. I’m grateful for all that they provide and I will return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...