AC Island Pizza

1333 Pacific Avenue, Atlantic City
(609) 449-8554

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Seal Da Deal

Stopped here at the end of the night before retiring to our room. Let me just say the pizza was surprisingly delicious! Thin, great taste, good flavor, and I ordered wings 10 hot wings to accompany the pie. The wings were what you would want to pair with your slice, not too big at all good size, good flavor and cooked fried well. Would not hesitate to make this my go to pizza place when I am in AC!

Zachery Josefik

Probably the lowest rating I've ever given to somewhere. Open till the early morning hours, got there at like 930pm.Huge pizza slices, but pricey. Asked for mozzarella sticks, said they were out, asked for jalapeño poppers, after a few minutes the kid working the counter said they were out of those as well. Just ended up getting 5 slices (which is pretty much a whole pizza). We honestly think that they just didn't feel like frying anything. We were the only ones there though, and the slices came out fast! I'll give them that much. But every time we approached the kid working the counter it seemed like we were bothering him. Granted, he was just a young kid, but definitely could've been a bit more attentive and also could've just told us they didn't feel like frying anything and we would've been fine with it. Definitely a pizza you would want to eat after having one too many drinks lol. Big, floppy, and cheesy.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

About the Smiths

Seemed like the only late night early morning food open. Just for that they are already get 5 stars lol. But the pizza was good.

Food: 4

Earlena Bishop

Food so good
Customer Service awesome the young lady that takes orders awesome

Food: 4

Service: 5

Mendi FLEISCHER

Pizza was okay, but it's a very old store and not t good atmosphere

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 3

Adam Eladly

They give back to the homeless

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sara Friend

They delivered right to my hotel, faster than the app even said they would! I have to say that this was the best pizza I have had in years!!!! I wish I could take them home with me!!! My delivery driver was very nice and friendly!

Food: 5

Service: 5

destiny gaines

One of the best places to eat from in Atlantic City best customer service 10/10 I recommend 😝

Jasmine Williams

Great pizza that stays open late is always a good look...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cody

The chef Julio Is caring To all that come in I've seen him give food on occasion to the homeless.they have the cheapest most delicious pizza!! And when you come in for a slice. A whole pizza is cut into 4 slices so the size of the slice is pretty big!!... thank you Julio and the cashier girls that help him.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The Tech Guy

I went here late night around 12:30 a.m. it seemed like they let homeless people just chill in their. After ordering even the staff started chasing around a large bug and it was not kept very secretive. Did not make me feel good about eating their. And then after I did and I was leaving the homeless were showing off their drugs to each other in the booth freely and openly. I don't know who runs this place but I would never go here again and don't suggest anybody else does too.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Eric 01

Best pizza deal in town. The dough is made fresh. The crust was just right and the toppings were generous. The neighborhood is a little rough at times but it's still worth patronizing. The owner is really nice. Try it!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shaylee

The chef Julio really cares about his customers and definitely has skill in the kitchen. Open until 4 am weekdays and 5 am weekends. Best pizza in town so go check it out when visiting Atlantic City!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kia Yates

The pizza was delicious. The service was great.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jon Beasley

I wasn't able to even try the pizza as it was never delivered to me. I spent $38+ on a pizza ($8 tip) and then waited 20+ minutes in my hotel lobby. Nothing. No communication, either, after my order was placed. When I filed a complaint to Slice (3rd party), Slice came back and said that AC Island was denying my claim and that the pizza WAS actually delivered. Yeah, that's why I had to order a pizza from Tony's Baltimore Grill immediately after being ghosted by AC Island. And fortunately the Tony's was magnifico. But anyway, a more detailed rebuttal from me yielded the same result thru Slice. Either their delivery person is lying or, more unlikely, my pizza was just delivered to someone else. Either way, AC needs to get their delivery process fixed as it's obviously broken, and them not acknowledging it from a customer just puts them in a very bad light. Getting my money back only thru a credit card dispute.

Service: 1

Loading...