Vic & Anthony's Steakhouse

We ordered two different steaks, a side, a salad, a sauce and dessert. The ice cream was the only item that met or exceeded expectations. Caesar salad was tart/vinegary, little to no cheese and two small croutons. Both steaks (ribeye,porterhouse) were not of high quality. I doubt they were graded prime as advertised. Neither was cooked to correct temp. Porterhouse was ordered Medium rare but came out medium well. Ribeye was ordered medium but came out rare-med rare. At least this one was an easy fix which was handled well by our server and quickly returned with the steak after finishing in the kitchen. The sauce options were not to my liking but tried the port peppercorn anyway. It didn't pair well with either steak. Once again, the server quickly removed the $10 from our bill without us asking. Baked potato was served plain with no offer for butter, sour cream etc.. but there was enough butter on the steak plates to accommodate. Liked the heated plate which makes a big difference in keeping meal warm throughout. Service overall was very good and well timed.

Everything was great from the very nice hostess Sophia to the server Yanni to the food runners and support staff! All super nice and was a great way to celebrate our 23rd anniversary!

Excellent steaks and great service. After over ten years of patronage, Vic and Anthony's is still one of my favorite restaurants

This is our favorite steakhouse. Party of 7 to celebrate a Birthday, all of us extremely happy with our meal and service. Food was outstanding and top notch service from Tori. A bit pricey but well worth it!

apps and service were great - first time we've ever been disappointed in the steak. Mgr did have another another steak made but it wasn't better. everyone has an off night so we'll def go back but if it happens again that'll be the end of that.

Everything was good. Pear and saga salad is my favorite. We also enjoyed the steak special and the Bronzino was delicious.

I had alot of steak in my life , and I must say Vic & Anthony’s in Atlantic City New Jersey delivers a great tasty, perfectly cooked Steak. Top notch food ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mashed Potatoes, Seafood

We had a mixed experience at Vic & Anthony's. The service was excellent, and the romantic, upscale ambiance was perfect. Unfortunately, my husband's $70 steak was tough and inedible. Everything else was great, but the food quality fell short.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

That $70 “prime” ribeye, is not prime. Got it medium rare and it was dry and chewy. It was covered in loads of sauce and that did not help with how dry the stake was. Prime suppose to have fat marbling that gives that stake its tenderness. But it felt like a choice steak from Walmart.
Service was great as well as the ambience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Service is excellent food was excellent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It was a good dinner, until I asked for change for a $100 bill prior to paying my bill. She said what kind of change? I said I don’t know, two $50 bills is fine. She comes back with just $50 in the book and says did you say to keep $50? I mean I didn’t, and didn’t even pay my bill yet, I asked for change not for you to take $50 but I guess you can tip yourself lol. Weird experience, the food was good but that rubbed me the wrong way. What type of waitress does that? Golden Nugget will be closed soon and Vic and Anthony’s will follow, so I’m guessing they are trying to scrounge up as much money as possible.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 3

Always enjoy eating here. Food is always very good. Yes it is more on the expensive side but you get great service and amazing food. The Ribye is fantastic! Worth coming here every time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Creme Brulee, Mashed Potatoes

My husband and I went after we got a recommendation. The food was very good BUT the music and noise level and the stacking of guests so close to each ruined our experience. We went to celebrate our anniversary and were seated between a loud family and a group of college kids. There were a ton of empty seats yet we we were packed in like sardines. Food was delicious but if you'd like to have an intimate meal don't go there. Way too expensive for sports bar noise level and atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fresh Oysters Rockefelle, Crab Cakes, Grilled Asparagus, Mashed Potatoes

Always an amazing dining experience. The steak is always the best in AC. We love the seasoning and the char. They added a special soup “cheesesteak soup”. Omg, that's a keeper.... Spicy, smooth, and meaty... absolutely delicious! It's a meal in itself.... Thank you Ashley for always delivering exceptional customer service! Stephan you've got a great staff here!

A very disappointing experience last night. Filet Mingon ordered med-well came out well and a bone-in Filet ordered medium came out well. Then we waited 4-5 minutes to get steak knives. When we cut into the steaks even our waiter was surprised how badly they were cooked. He took them back to get refired. The bone-in came back med-rare (okay.....I can live with that) but the Filet mignon came back twice as over cooked. Worse than the first one. Again our waiter apologized. At that point the meal was over. We got a complimentary creme brulee and the filet mignon, uneaten and returned, was removed from the check.