Atlantic Bagel Co.

74 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands
(732) 872-7727

Recent Reviews

Ken Weston

Good bagels and service

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagel

Johnny Rivera

Great local spot!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagel

Steve Trezza

The food is fine, but this place messes up my order almost EVERY TIME I order. I always ask for SPK on my breakfast sandwiches and they never add it. Often times they'll forget to add cheese to my bacon/pork roll egg and cheese. I get that mistakes happen every now and then but this is every order.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Bobby Emmons

If you don't go there shame on you.

Sherri P

Small, stale bagels on a Saturday morning……Really?

Kirsten Diebold

Made in-house bagels and most of the pasties. Great staff. Quick.Delicious local spot.

Anthony Dinnocenzo

Great place niceeeeee people and good food

Hania Strus

I’ve ordered from this place many time and every time I go in the service is incredibly slow and there’s always something wrong. Today I placed an order at 11:55, for an order to be picked up at 12:32. I arrived at 12:37, waited in line for my order, just to be told they hadn’t made it. My breaks are only 30 minutes and had I waited for them to make it I wouldn’t have had time to eat it. This isn’t the first time this has happened either. Service is slow, there’s no counter for just pick ups which makes the lines longer, and there’s always 2-3 people waiting ahead of you to get your bagel. We were given a refund thankfully but absolutely unacceptable for a franchise like this

Stacey romanello

Amazing, friendly! Great way to start the day!

Melissa Beyeler

DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE!!!! They are VERY RUDE!!! My fiancé just tried to order from here and asked for a whole sub and they rudely said NOPE. Then he said he will give them a call back. Then they THOUGHT THEY HUNG UP BUT DIDNT…… he heard the woman making fun of him to another co worker saying this isn’t subway. Well guess what. We will NEVER BE BACK. Next time make sure you ACTUALLY HANG UP THE PHONE BEFORE MAKING FUN OF YOUR CUSTOMERS!!!!!!This happened May 6th at 1:30.

Ramesh Dharan

An area staple. Great service, fresh and tasty bagels.

Sara Beveridge

Good food but the service is not that great. Everytime I call in an order I'm put on hold for over ten sometimes fifteen minutes and can hear everything they're saying in the background. One time a lady had me on hold, another woman said "you know u have a customer on hold right" she said I know they can wait. And laughed. Very unprofessional and rude in my opinion. I've hung up amd have gone somewhere else more then I've ordered from there.

christian rogich

Food is great but I wish the person behind the counter recognised that when the line is out the door, it’s not the time to have lengthy convos with customers and chat about their kids etc.

Neekaah Singer-Songwriter

Staff is so nice .. great coffee n bagels

Joe DeLisi

Excellent! Bagels, muffins and turnovers all made on site. Wonderfully friendly staff. Highly recommended.

Load More