The Vintage Cake

171 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands
(732) 807-5961

Recent Reviews

Kate Stoddard

We’ve worked with The Vintage Cake on three different occasions for our children’s special events, and the cakes have all been beautiful and delicious. Highly recommend.

Cara Heusel

The Vintage Cake did an amazing job with my son’s first birthday cake! Will definitely be a returning customer for future events!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marianna Atiya

Can't say enough good things about the Vintage Cake! I've used them for a couple of events now and the food has always been jaw-droppingly delicious! Their desserts are truly a work of art - so beautiful and soooo delicious! You really feel it's top quality ingredients. I will only ever order from The Vintage Cake for any event! Highly highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gulzifa M

It's been a week since our wedding, and today I finally found time to thank The Vintage Cake for absolutely phenomenal, gorgeous and delicious cake they have created for us! Not only it looked like a piece of art, it also tasted really good! We went with coconut sponge and passion fruit buttercream, and it came out so yummy - we received many compliments from out guests! The whole process of ordering was very easy, working with The Vintage Cake was a pleasure. Thank you so much for creating such a delicious beauty for our special day!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

Gulzifa G

It's been a week since our wedding, and today I finally found time to thank The Vintage Cake for absolutely phenomenal, gorgeous and delicious cake they have created for us! Not only it looked like a piece of art, it also tasted really good! We went with coconut sponge and passion fruit buttercream, and it came out so yummy - we received many compliments from out guests! The whole process of ordering was very easy, working with The Vintage Cake was a pleasure. Thank you so much for creating such a delicious beauty for our special day!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

Dina Polidori

Thank you so much! The cake not only looked phenomenal but also tasted delicious. My husband can’t stop talking about it and everyone asked who made it. Communication with Gina and the ordering process was great as well.

Jackie DeBernardis

Ordered cupcakes for my daughter’s baby shower solely on a recommendation from a loyal customer of Vintage Cakes. I am so glad I did. Everyone at the shower was raving about how delicious they were. Thank you for making the shower extra special.

Julie Clarke

Perfect! Beautiful! Delicious! I can’t think of three better words to describe a cake from Vintage. I trusted them with my thoughts and the cake for my daughters Golden 30th Birthday was amazing!

Jessica Grisanzio

10/10 recommend The Vintage Cake! Very easy to communicate with and they are willing to work with you and let you know how to stay within your budget. They brought my son’s Olaf birthday cake to life! It was a showstopper and not only did it look amazing on the outside but it was delicious on the inside !! They will not disappoint!!!

Michelle Behre

DELICIOUS, DECADENT DESIGNS! All I can say is WOW! Our experience with The Vintage Cake was incredible. Gina and Nancy’s booking process was seamless. From their communication, to the decadent custom design that they created for our very special wedding, Gina and Nancy designed a picture-perfect, delicious wedding cake for our Hamilton Farm Golf Club wedding. We were between a few flavors. Gina recommend a tasting to finalize our details and we were absolutely blown away. Everything was so delicious and from there we knew exactly what we needed to order. Following our tasting and finalizing our guest count, all details were set and Gina and Nancy created a picture-perfect, delicious vanilla sponge, vanilla custard and fresh strawberry wedding cake for our day. Thank you so much, Gina and Nancy for everything!

Emily Schlotterbeck

My husband and I used the vintage cake for our wedding cake. We enjoyed the tasting box and felt it came with plenty of cake samples and fillings. We went with a confetti cake with cookies and cream filling- 2 of our favorite things!. The vintage cake was easy to work with and flexible when our guest count wasn’t as high as we originally expected as we needed to change our order. They created a beautiful cake which fit our wedding theme perfectly. Unfortunately after the wedding, in talking with friends and family, multiple people said the cake was dry and lacked flavor. I only ate a small bite during the cake cutting and I did think the cake was a bit bland. It didn’t change our day at all but I, as well as some very close family members, are huge cake lovers so it was disappointing to hear.

Rachel Jaros

We had a great experience with the Vintage Cake for my baby shower! They made a beautiful and delicious vanilla sponge cake with raspberry buttercream and macaron party favors, which everyone loved. The planning process was seamless and response times quick. I would definitely work with them again!

maria fois

This was amazing, no just the cake but all the desserts I ordered. Plus they delivered perfect timely. Also they make it so easy to the orders online. Great place I highly recomienden

CHAN LAM PENNY

The champagne is popping to celebrate a milestone birthday!Thank you @thevintagecake…cake was super delicious.Cannot wait to order again,; a pleasure to work with Nancy & Gina!

Stacey Sampson

Can’t thank you enough for the absolutely amazing cake you did for my brother’s birthday. It was the highlight of the party so much so I have never seen him smile so big. Everyone got up to take pictures and everyone even asked if it really was all cake. The details on everything on the cake was on point. The clasp on the box, the writing of Jameson on the barrel and even the Cohiba labels on the cigars were just amazing. Beside the amazing look of the cake it was also absolutely delicious. The cake was moist and buttercream was smooth and not to sweet, the cake was perfect. I can’t thank you enough for the beautiful cake. As a fellow CIA grad I can say you have made them proud and are amazing at what you do. Thank you again for the show stopper of a cake.

Load More