Best pizza in South Jersey!! Great ingredients results in great product!! Grandé Mozzarella for the win!! Keep up the great work!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe Alfenito
Love their pizza and just had a great Italian hoagie. Soft seeded semolina bread with just the right amount of vinegar and oil and oregano. Well be back. Lunch special look great too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nick Leverock
Avalon has limited options in the off-season, and this place is often one of the few I can count on for a quick bite. The food is just okay and not worth the price for me. The pizza is greasy and bland, with small slices and portions that don’t feel like you’re getting good value. I’ve tried a bit of everything—cheese steak, buffalo tenders, salad—and it’s all fairly bland and not very memorable.
Service is usually friendly, and they’re open when other spots aren’t, which helps. But unless you’re starving and desperate, I’d look elsewhere for something more flavorful and filling. If you’re in Avalon and need a quick bite, you might end up here, but don’t expect a standout meal or great value for money.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
TODD HUCK
Pizza and cheesesteaks? Delicious, no doubt. But let’s be real—Avalon has a knack for turning everything into a luxury item. We decided to indulge in a large pizza and a cheesesteak, and all we wanted to wash it down was a simple glass of water. Imagine my surprise when the host informed us that bottled water was our only option. I inquired about regular water, only to be told that we’d need to purchase a cup for that privilege. “How much for the cup?” I asked, half-expecting a reasonable answer. “$2.85,” she replied. I had to pass. What kind of restaurant doesn’t offer complimentary water? It’s like charging for air! I guess I’ll be saving my pennies and my appetite for establishments that appreciate the value of hydration. Consider this my farewell to this overpriced joint!
Sounds like you don't trust your customers. The same customers who keep you in business. Why not provide pitchers of water to your dine-in paying customers like almost every restaurant does.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Kevin Lanahan
Food is good but christ whoever is driving the delivery van for yall needs to learn how to drive. Whoever was driving on saturday the 16th at 7pm blew a stop sign and had I not hit my brakes on my bike I would’ve been hit considering I was about 3 ft away before he sped off.
Justin Beegle
Food is decent but unbelievably slow service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Andy Sadowski
I wish Facebook would offer different options than recommend or not. I do like the pizza as it is tasty. I do think they are slightly overpriced, and have slipped into the we don't care much more about our customers. stopped in this evening for two pies and garlic bread. Order was over $55. When I asked for a cup for water I was told no. When I arrived home, garlic bread was burnt. Don't mind paying a premium for quality food, but when bread is obviously overcooked and it gets sent home, I have an issue. Not worth heading back for a new one being I'm not staying in Avalon. pretty sure other places are out there that are more customer oriented and will look for my new go to place. Spent many years eating Stone Harbor Pizza and traveled further north to Avalon. however this may be my last visit.
Jon Martin
Ray the pizza maker made my day!!!
Kaileigh Kimak
Pizza was soggy, greasy, and disgusting and then when we went back and they were rude and tried to blame the bad pizza on us. Do not eat here!!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Damek szustak
I called an order in and the person over the phone said my order was confirmed. When I can to pick it up they said the couldn’t see the order and didn’t have my food. I re ordered and just asked the manager Dustin if they could put a little priority on it because I was late to an event. Dustin not only got my food out to me within 5 minutes. But he also refunded my payment. Great manager and a great experience which could have otherwise ended up poorly.
Relaxed clean pizza place. Outside and inside seating. The food is good and fast. The workers fun. Try the specials! Thanks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Natalie Cook
I go to Circle every weekend when I visit Avalon. Typically, 6 -10 times during summer. Popped in this past Saturday. The was decorated for Halloween and looked festive! The pizza however, SUCKED! So GREAZY! I don't know if its a new owner, new pizza maker or they changed the recipe or ingredients but it literally got me and my boyfriend sick! For hours our stomachs weren't right! Never had this happen before. Never had a bad slice there! You had your chance Circle! When you screw up a plain cheese pie and it doesn't sit well with the tummy, there's no reason to come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 4
Maddie Hand
My FAVORITE PIZZA! New owners have brought some awesome new pizzas and they are an amazing, and good hearted family! They supplied pizzas to our wedding after party and Dustin and Alyse went out of their way to make sure everything was delicious, warm and on time. If I could give more than 5 stars I WOULD!!!!!!!!!
George Briggs
Everything is very good! Love the wings!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Caesar Salad, Fries, Cheesesteak, Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Caesar Salad, Burger, Chicken Caesar, Pizza, Onion Rings
Best pizza in South Jersey!! Great ingredients results in great product!! Grandé Mozzarella for the win!! Keep up the great work!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love their pizza and just had a great Italian hoagie. Soft seeded semolina bread with just the right amount of vinegar and oil and oregano. Well be back. Lunch special look great too.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Avalon has limited options in the off-season, and this place is often one of the few I can count on for a quick bite. The food is just okay and not worth the price for me. The pizza is greasy and bland, with small slices and portions that don’t feel like you’re getting good value. I’ve tried a bit of everything—cheese steak, buffalo tenders, salad—and it’s all fairly bland and not very memorable.
Service is usually friendly, and they’re open when other spots aren’t, which helps. But unless you’re starving and desperate, I’d look elsewhere for something more flavorful and filling. If you’re in Avalon and need a quick bite, you might end up here, but don’t expect a standout meal or great value for money.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Pizza and cheesesteaks? Delicious, no doubt. But let’s be real—Avalon has a knack for turning everything into a luxury item. We decided to indulge in a large pizza and a cheesesteak, and all we wanted to wash it down was a simple glass of water. Imagine my surprise when the host informed us that bottled water was our only option. I inquired about regular water, only to be told that we’d need to purchase a cup for that privilege. “How much for the cup?” I asked, half-expecting a reasonable answer. “$2.85,” she replied. I had to pass. What kind of restaurant doesn’t offer complimentary water? It’s like charging for air! I guess I’ll be saving my pennies and my appetite for establishments that appreciate the value of hydration. Consider this my farewell to this overpriced joint!
Sounds like you don't trust your customers. The same customers who keep you in business. Why not provide pitchers of water to your dine-in paying customers like almost every restaurant does.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Food is good but christ whoever is driving the delivery van for yall needs to learn how to drive. Whoever was driving on saturday the 16th at 7pm blew a stop sign and had I not hit my brakes on my bike I would’ve been hit considering I was about 3 ft away before he sped off.
Food is decent but unbelievably slow service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
I wish Facebook would offer different options than recommend or not. I do like the pizza as it is tasty. I do think they are slightly overpriced, and have slipped into the we don't care much more about our customers. stopped in this evening for two pies and garlic bread. Order was over $55. When I asked for a cup for water I was told no. When I arrived home, garlic bread was burnt. Don't mind paying a premium for quality food, but when bread is obviously overcooked and it gets sent home, I have an issue. Not worth heading back for a new one being I'm not staying in Avalon. pretty sure other places are out there that are more customer oriented and will look for my new go to place. Spent many years eating Stone Harbor Pizza and traveled further north to Avalon. however this may be my last visit.
Ray the pizza maker made my day!!!
Pizza was soggy, greasy, and disgusting and then when we went back and they were rude and tried to blame the bad pizza on us. Do not eat here!!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I called an order in and the person over the phone said my order was confirmed. When I can to pick it up they said the couldn’t see the order and didn’t have my food. I re ordered and just asked the manager Dustin if they could put a little priority on it because I was late to an event. Dustin not only got my food out to me within 5 minutes. But he also refunded my payment. Great manager and a great experience which could have otherwise ended up poorly.
Restaurantji Recommends
Relaxed clean pizza place. Outside and inside seating. The food is good and fast. The workers fun. Try the specials! Thanks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I go to Circle every weekend when I visit Avalon. Typically, 6 -10 times during summer.
Popped in this past Saturday. The was decorated for Halloween and looked festive! The pizza however, SUCKED! So GREAZY! I don't know if its a new owner, new pizza maker or they changed the recipe or ingredients but it literally got me and my boyfriend sick! For hours our stomachs weren't right!
Never had this happen before. Never had a bad slice there! You had your chance Circle! When you screw up a plain cheese pie and it doesn't sit well with the tummy, there's no reason to come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 4
My FAVORITE PIZZA! New owners have brought some awesome new pizzas and they are an amazing, and good hearted family! They supplied pizzas to our wedding after party and Dustin and Alyse went out of their way to make sure everything was delicious, warm and on time. If I could give more than 5 stars I WOULD!!!!!!!!!
Everything is very good! Love the wings!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Caesar Salad, Fries, Cheesesteak, Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Caesar Salad, Burger, Chicken Caesar, Pizza, Onion Rings
Don't see why everyone is crazy about this place
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Burger, Pizza
Loading...