4 Best Diners near Barnegat Light

“If you close your eyes and picture a classic Jersey diner, Mustache Bill’s is probably exactly what you’re imagining. But on LBI, it’s more than a diner. It’s a way of life.

This isn’t just a place for tourists. It’s packed with locals, which tells you everything you need to know. The staff is always friendly, welcoming, and helpful, and there’s a reason people have been coming back for generations.

One of our favorite things is the fun-shaped pancakes for the kids. They even turn the butter into part of the artwork, which is a small touch that always brings a smile to the table.

For breakfast, I highly recommend the Eggs Louie, their take on crab cake eggs Benedict. It’s outstanding. That said, I’ve worked my way through a good portion of the menu over the years, and you really can’t go wrong with anything.

The prices are fair, especially for being on the island, and the portions never disappoint.

One tip for first-time visitors: bring cash. Mustache Bill’s is cash only, and there isn’t an ATM on site. If you forget, there’s one just down the street.

Whether you’re a longtime local, a summer regular, or visiting LBI for the first time, Mustache Bill’s is one of those places that should be part of your island tradition.“

“The friendliest place I have ever visited!! The owner Michele is the nicest and kindest host(also the owner). She goes out of her way to talks and shares with the customers.. and the food is over the top!! Do yourself a favor and get a taste of this place!“

“I go to the Forked River Diner often. The food is incredible. Every menu item I have ordered is excellent! The staff is very friendly and the prices are very reasonable. I highly recommend it!“

“The food is great but you must save room for desert. The lemon coconut cake is scrumptious! The waitress mentioned a chocolate cake to try but I couldn't be swayed from the lemony goodness.“