Barnegat Bay Ice Cream
Customers' Favorites
Peanut Butter Topside
Hard Ice Cream Sundae
Classic Banana Split
Chocolate Ice Cream
Soft Serve Sundae
Hard Ice Cream
Waffle Cone
Water Ice
Toppings
Pup Cup
Menu
Photos
+15 photos
+14 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Place was spotless inside and out. Ice cream is amazing and the girls working behind the counter were kind. My favorite was the cotton candy with rainbow sprinkles. It is a delightful little ice cream shop; I highly recommend.
I have got ice cream from Barneget Ice Cream with my family for years. The ice cream is amazing. Reasonably priced, portion sizes are large ( which is a good thing ), and a wide varietie of flavors. Each flavor is rich and filled with flavor. For example when you get birthday cake ice cream it’s not just vanilla ice cream with sprinkles it actually tastes like birthday cake. Highly Recommend!!
I love a good non-chain ice cream place. This one has such creative sundaes to pick from. Or if you want to keep it simple or on a cone, they have a ton of great flavors to choose from. Feel like an ice instead? They have that too. Plenty of choices and I haven't made a bad one yet.
You May Also Like
Lefty's Tavern - 547 N Main St
![]()
Bar, American, Seafood, New American
Danny’s Bayshore Bagels - 550 N Main St C
![]()
Bagels, Pet Friendly
Naples Pizza & Restaurant - 550 N Main St Ste d
![]()
Italian, Pizza, Seafood, Vegetarian