Love the blueberry fritters. Will go yearly just for those. Just wish the line went quicker since it gets so busy! Hard to see all products because everyone crowds in.
Beth K
My daughter was thrilled with her Key Lime Pie! They all loved it. I was so happy with their GF options. The Crumb Cake Muffin was delicious!
Vickie Wilson
Best crumb cakes and the blueberry tart was fantastic.
Sean ODonnell
What can you say? Best crumb cake in New Jersey. Can get very crowded during the summer on the weekends, but worth the wait, so get there early.
Anthony Averso
I wanna thank the organization for making my father's 100th birthday cake. Thanks for delivery it to the shrimp box. The people who absolutely loved the cake were in the food business and the cake was outstanding.
Hannah Corbin
Mueller’s is an amazing family owned bakery. Known for their crumb cake they have an amazing array of baked goods and breads. Not to be missed!
Darek Krzak
Cakes, cookies are great , You need to try the Canoli cake . Always busy and don't forget to get a ticket or order ahead
Mike Pappas
All the food was awesome from the donuts and the bagels, but don't get me started on the crumb cake! Every bite was to die for! But besides the food they provided absolutely amazing service! There was a beautiful young lady in front helped me right away and kept the over crowding place moving. The atmosphere is okay, the place is cute but the only issue is the amount of people crowding this place on the week of 4th of July. Another reason why I give the atmosphere a 3/5 is due to some of the old bats that were in front of me being rude to the the younger employees, I've lived in the bayhead area for a while and know some of the locals are very privileged and can be rude and I give all workers propositions for working that area! Keep up the amazing work!😊
Elly VZ
What a step back in time when there were bakeries like this that served homemade breads, rolls, specialty cakes, donuts, variety if ethnic pastries, vegan bakery and gluten free bakery , hot beverages. Also variety of take home and premade gift-able bags. Now Muellers is the only TRUE BAKERY IN A 30 mile radius. And it so worth the trip. When you see the long line of customers each spending a large amout of money and two full bags of items, you know the food is AWESOME. Lovely counter help that know how yo be polite , friendly and efficient. I drive 30-35 minutes to shop there and spend triple digits. But it is OH SO WORTH IT! Thank you for providing this service to the beach community and WAY beyond. Please do not ever close!!! Fan since the ‘80’s
Vegetarian options: Vegan cookies and soft bakery
Dietary restrictions: Vegan Gluten free
Kid-friendliness: Small pieces of bakery items. Character cookies and cupcakes
Love the blueberry fritters. Will go yearly just for those. Just wish the line went quicker since it gets so busy! Hard to see all products because everyone crowds in.
My daughter was thrilled with her Key Lime Pie! They all loved it. I was so happy with their GF options. The Crumb Cake Muffin was delicious!
Best crumb cakes and the blueberry tart was fantastic.
What can you say? Best crumb cake in New Jersey. Can get very crowded during the summer on the weekends, but worth the wait, so get there early.
I wanna thank the organization for making my father's 100th birthday cake. Thanks for delivery it to the shrimp box. The people who absolutely loved the cake were in the food business and the cake was outstanding.
Mueller’s is an amazing family owned bakery. Known for their crumb cake they have an amazing array of baked goods and breads. Not to be missed!
Cakes, cookies are great ,
You need to try the Canoli cake . Always busy and don't forget to get a ticket or order ahead
All the food was awesome from the donuts and the bagels, but don't get me started on the crumb cake! Every bite was to die for! But besides the food they provided absolutely amazing service! There was a beautiful young lady in front helped me right away and kept the over crowding place moving. The atmosphere is okay, the place is cute but the only issue is the amount of people crowding this place on the week of 4th of July. Another reason why I give the atmosphere a 3/5 is due to some of the old bats that were in front of me being rude to the the younger employees, I've lived in the bayhead area for a while and know some of the locals are very privileged and can be rude and I give all workers propositions for working that area! Keep up the amazing work!😊
What a step back in time when there were bakeries like this that served homemade breads, rolls, specialty cakes, donuts, variety if ethnic pastries, vegan bakery and gluten free bakery , hot beverages. Also variety of take home and premade gift-able bags. Now Muellers is the only TRUE BAKERY IN A 30 mile radius. And it so worth the trip. When you see the long line of customers each spending a large amout of money and two full bags of items, you know the food is AWESOME. Lovely counter help that know how yo be polite , friendly and efficient. I drive 30-35 minutes to shop there and spend triple digits. But it is OH SO WORTH IT! Thank you for providing this service to the beach community and WAY beyond. Please do not ever close!!! Fan since the ‘80’s
Vegetarian options: Vegan cookies and soft bakery
Dietary restrictions: Vegan Gluten free
Kid-friendliness: Small pieces of bakery items. Character cookies and cupcakes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything
Pricey but worth it
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious baked goods. One of the best bakeries around.
Parking: Municipal lot directly across the street
Recommended dishes: Everything
Bought a crumb cake for Christmas for my family and it was stale and rock hard. For $20 for a cake I would never go back here.
We drive about a hour south to pick up bread, rolls and cakes. That should say it all !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best bakery around!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great bakery, a must go to
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...