Theresa's South

530 Main Ave, Bay Head
(732) 892-1555

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kristi Conner

I loved the pistachio crusted salmon. The service was amazing too! The atmosphere was simple but still enjoyable for a nice dinner. We liked our family dinner there.

Melinda Lamprecht

Overall, I was quite disappointed in my experience at Theresa’s South. I decided to take a trip to the restaurant after seeing positive reviews on Instagram, but unfortunately, I wish I would have stayed home. To start, I noticed that there were lipstick stains in my wine glass. When I sent it back, I got another glass with the same stain and it really grossed me out. After a receiving the appetizers, I took my fork and noticed that had food on it too! Maybe I would have rated it higher but this is unacceptable for the money I paid

S S

We came here for dinner for the first time last night and everything was outstanding. They're BYOB, the food was fresh and delicious, the atmosphere was peaceful, and our waitress, Abby, was a delight. She went over menu items with us and recommended her favorite dishes. She really added to the whole experience.

Peter Muller

The food and service were outstanding! The rooms were a bit crowded as it was Mother's Day, but the staff were very accommodating. I will definitely consider the restaurant for special events in the future!

Michele DeDea

Had the seared tuna and it was delicious. Also had fried calamari and the dipping sauce so good. Pistachio crusted salmon also very good. Service was great. Can't say anything negative.

Shannon Kelly

Enjoyed a baby shower there. I'd love to go back and dine soon though. Thanks for a great brunch.

Dean Sparaino

Hard to beat these Eats Beautiful restaurant

Chris Kunzman

We had a great night. Food and service were very good. We never felt rushed and had a great night! BYOB as well.

Eileen Rajczyk

Our original dinner plans on Saturday evening did not pan out! Actually grateful, because we were lucky enough to get a last-minute reservation at Therea's. We sat outside, was a beautiful evening. The food was amazing, service stellar and a BYOB what else could you ask for! If you haven't been to Therea's South, you are in for a treat!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JoeyD

Went there with a Table of 5 Ola males were excellent we did arrive 15 minutes later than our reservation and felt the kind of rush but I could understand

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Gorgonzola Crusted Filet of Beef, Crispy Calamari

Klee Lightner

The overall experience was great. Great food, good service, and a pleasurable atmosphere I would visit again if in the area.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Seafood Trio

Opentable Diner

We throughly enjoyed our entire dinner. Our favorite was the Eggplant appetizer. Very unique and the garlic creams sauce was amazing. We drove 45 minutes both ways to try this restaurant out and were very impressed!! I would highly recommend!

We throughly enjoyed our entire dinner. Our favorite was the Eggplant appetizer. Very unique and the garlic creams sauce was amazing. We drove 45 minutes both ways to try this restaurant out and were very impressed!! I would highly recommend!

Beth

Tables inside are on top of each other. Food was good service was good. It was loud and you were less then 6 inches from table next to you . Waiter reached over my shoulder to put food down on table next to me.

Barbara

We go to Theresa's South at least once a month and we go for the Tuna - sushi rare. It is fabulous. This week we started with sharing the stuffed pepper appetizer which was delicious, and the sauce was amazing. The banana bread pudd was delicious, plenty if you are sharing, and the cinnamon gelato was just the topper to a delicious meal!

Loading...