Benanti's Italian Delicatessen

16 W 22nd St, Bayonne
(201) 437-5525

Recent Reviews

heartlisk

What a WONDERFUL place! Recommended by my grandma (a Bayonne native), we now go every time we visit New Jersey! You cannot beat the quality of their meats and cheeses, along with personable service, and cost for a FANTASTIC, must-have Italian sub. (:

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian Sub

Simone Lamela

There is no one better for authentic Italian food in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Argante Colageo

Friendly service, good food, not pricey.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dan Thomas

I drove by this place recently and wanted to check it out after reading all the reviews here. The pros: Sandwich came as good as advertised. I mean it even left a good taste in my mouth for hours afterward. I got a turkey sub with mozzarella and veggies.The cons: While there's a certain amount of old school/old world appeal here that I enjoyed the lack of stable pricing for sandwiches I wasn't a fan of. I'm not going to accuse these guys of ripping me off but comparing what I ordered to what some people did here though does make me wonder a little.At any rate this place is one of a kind!

Ronald Mejia

Very good imported food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian Sandwich

Tony Borea

Old school deli that's worth the trip just to talk to the owner! I was going to the Giants game and went a little bit out of my way (by about 45 minutes or so) to stop by and get some sandwiches for the tailgate. I know, I normally grill but I wasn't in the mood. They were delicious with meat piled to the sky! Would definitely stop by again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian Sub

Katherine B.

Absolutely perfect! Hidden gem. The service and sandwiches were outstanding, will definitely be back!

maria paz munizaga alvear

I loved this place, they serve very well and the food is exquisite!!! To take away, they have cheeses that they cut right there to deliver grated if you prefer, the spinach ravioli are very good and also the natural tomato sauce with meatballs is very

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

María Paz M.

I loved this place, they serve very well and the food is exquisite!!! To take away, they have cheeses that they cut right there to deliver grated if you prefer, the spinach ravioli are very good and also the natural tomato sauce with meatballs is very delicious.

Alinson Martinez

The first time I went there I paid $20 for a sandwich and two and a water. Second time I spent two sandwiches $30. How do they make sense and the test the money and the sandwich are the same time will be going there never again and sanitary, not clean at all the touch the money and the sandwiches is disgusting ? ???

Jason Reed

Best LOADED Italian samitch I've ever had. Great Italian guys and awesome atmosphere! I'm definitely going back!

Joe McCusker

Pick out your bread on the way in (boxes fresh every day).Always good sandwiches and great ingredients what more can I say!

Ryed J.

Charged 50$ for two Italian sandwiches. And it was cash only. I don't think he charges those prices to everyone either, never coming back.

pavel butrim

Moved out from bayonne 7 years ago but every time I stop in Bayonne have to go there and get that sandwichLove that place

Russell H.

A friend of mine grew up in Bayonne and when I mentioned loving Italian Subs, he said, "I got you" and within a week I had a rather large Italian sub delivered to my house by said friend. It was fresh and delicious. I will be back and I will get another variation of their italian meats and cheeses inside freshly baked bread.

Load More

Benanti's Italian Delicatessen

16 W 22nd St, Bayonne, NJ 07002
(201) 437-5525