I was disappointed with the ice cream here. I tried Oreo and Pistachio flavors, but the texture was not smooth at all — it didn’t feel like fresh, homemade, or organic ice cream. The brownie was okay, but overall the ice cream quality was not up to the mark. I’ve had much better ice cream at other places, so I wouldn’t recommend this shop if you’re looking for a good, creamy ice cream experience.
Stephanie Kung
Friendly staff and great ice cream. I had been wanting to try this shop for about 15 years, passing by on my way home from hockey at the local hockey rink. Today was the day and Magic Fountain did not disappoint!
Felix Oly Ortiz
Best ice cream ever
Lisy Rodriguez
Plenty of flavors to choose.
Tim
Best ice cream in Bayonne, amazing service!!!
Nicole Sadiee
I really HATE to leave bad reviews, especially since I’ve worked in customer service my whole life. The girl who took my order with the blonde hair was so rude to me. She took my order for a malt and asked all her coworkers who wants to make the malt because she doesn’t want to make it. IN FRONT OF MY FACE WITH THE WINDOW OPEN. I recently retired because of my 6 congnitive/mental disabilities and it’s important for me to find places that treat people with disabilities with respect. I honestly don’t think I’ll be coming back here… I used to love this place..
Jessica Ruge
The owners really need to start having managers on shift at all times. The attitudes of the young girls who work in there are out of control. If I'm paying $6 dollars for an ice cream cone, it shouldn't be leaning like the Tower of Pisa before it's even handed to me. I asked her to remake it and she rolled her eyes, intentionally put less ice cream on the cone, and snatched my card out of my hand when I went to pay. I gave her the cone back and just left. I'm not giving my money to a business who allows their employees to be so rude for no reason. I don't know if I'll be returning this season.
Ned Ryun
Come cream your pants at magic fountain. The ice cream is so good it will make you explode!! 🤯. The service was so good I wanted to keep coming back for seconds. I can never get enough of this nice big magic fountain location, endless supply of creams and smiles :)
Kinga Omiljan
A delicious Bayonne staple!
carlos diaz
Great homemade ice cream. Nice local spot in Bayonne.
The crew is friendly and the ice cream 🍦 is delicious 👌
Esther Rodriguez
Our favorite ice cream shop!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Split
Tamekia Bolden
I've been to this location a few times. I've always got the ice cream and last night decided to get a milkshake. I must say the milkshake was terrible ---- it tastes like an icy rather than a thick strawberry milkshake or vanilla milkshake. I was so disappointed $12 bucks just wasted. Please teach the young kids working there how to make a milkshake --- you do not use ice.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Thomas J. Lee
BEST VALUE. Stopped by here to get some ice cream after tennis practice. This is a window pickup or Drive thru Only. Ordered 2 x 2 scoops with all different flavors. Great quality. And very friendly young staffs. The total came out to be $9.50+/-. For 4 scoops, $9+ ??? What an amazing value! In Jersey City, it's $7 a scoop at some places. Instantly, Magic Fountain became my daughter's and my go-to Ice cream place!! Keep up the great business!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Onisti Payton
5 all around, but I wish that there were sugar/ dairy free options. But great all the way!!
I was disappointed with the ice cream here. I tried Oreo and Pistachio flavors, but the texture was not smooth at all — it didn’t feel like fresh, homemade, or organic ice cream. The brownie was okay, but overall the ice cream quality was not up to the mark. I’ve had much better ice cream at other places, so I wouldn’t recommend this shop if you’re looking for a good, creamy ice cream experience.
Friendly staff and great ice cream. I had been wanting to try this shop for about 15 years, passing by on my way home from hockey at the local hockey rink. Today was the day and Magic Fountain did not disappoint!
Best ice cream ever
Plenty of flavors to choose.
Best ice cream in Bayonne, amazing service!!!
I really HATE to leave bad reviews, especially since I’ve worked in customer service my whole life. The girl who took my order with the blonde hair was so rude to me. She took my order for a malt and asked all her coworkers who wants to make the malt because she doesn’t want to make it. IN FRONT OF MY FACE WITH THE WINDOW OPEN. I recently retired because of my 6 congnitive/mental disabilities and it’s important for me to find places that treat people with disabilities with respect. I honestly don’t think I’ll be coming back here… I used to love this place..
The owners really need to start having managers on shift at all times. The attitudes of the young girls who work in there are out of control. If I'm paying $6 dollars for an ice cream cone, it shouldn't be leaning like the Tower of Pisa before it's even handed to me. I asked her to remake it and she rolled her eyes, intentionally put less ice cream on the cone, and snatched my card out of my hand when I went to pay. I gave her the cone back and just left. I'm not giving my money to a business who allows their employees to be so rude for no reason. I don't know if I'll be returning this season.
Come cream your pants at magic fountain. The ice cream is so good it will make you explode!! 🤯. The service was so good I wanted to keep coming back for seconds. I can never get enough of this nice big magic fountain location, endless supply of creams and smiles :)
A delicious Bayonne staple!
Great homemade ice cream.
Nice local spot in Bayonne.
Restaurantji Recommends
The crew is friendly and the ice cream 🍦 is delicious 👌
Our favorite ice cream shop!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Split
I've been to this location a few times. I've always got the ice cream and last night decided to get a milkshake. I must say the milkshake was terrible ---- it tastes like an icy rather than a thick strawberry milkshake or vanilla milkshake. I was so disappointed $12 bucks just wasted. Please teach the young kids working there how to make a milkshake --- you do not use ice.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
BEST VALUE. Stopped by here to get some ice cream after tennis practice. This is a window pickup or Drive thru Only. Ordered 2 x 2 scoops with all different flavors. Great quality. And very friendly young staffs. The total came out to be $9.50+/-. For 4 scoops, $9+ ??? What an amazing value! In Jersey City, it's $7 a scoop at some places. Instantly, Magic Fountain became my daughter's and my go-to Ice cream place!! Keep up the great business!
Food: 5
Service: 5
5 all around, but I wish that there were sugar/ dairy free options. But great all the way!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...