Paulanto Bakery

387 Broadway, Bayonne
(201) 339-9001

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sandi Abdelsayed

Absolutely the best bakery!!! Delicious cookies and cake!! Went above and beyond to accommodate our requests. We will definitely come back for all our party desserts!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Abigail Kadir

We always order our birthday cakes from here and the quality is top notch every time. This year we wanted a groovy cake for a 1 year old birthday party and the cake came out beautifully! We also love their cupcakes and little desserts as well. Highly recommend Pulanto’s!!

Sam Micek

I’ve used Paulanto’s several times now, and every experience has been fantastic. I’ve ordered custom cakes on multiple occasions, and each one has been absolutely beautiful—so detailed, delicious, and exactly what I envisioned. I’ve also tried a variety of their other desserts, including chocolate mousse hearts, sprinkle cookies, and more, and everything has been consistently fresh and flavorful.

One thing I really appreciate is how thorough Saad is when taking cake orders. He genuinely listens and takes the time to fully understand what you’re looking for—and he’s also the one who makes the cakes! You can really see the care and skill he puts into every detail. I had tried a few other bakeries before a friend recommended Paulanto’s, and I’m so glad I made the switch. I’m already looking forward to working with them again for my niece’s first birthday cake in a couple of weeks. Highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cupcakes, Wedding Cake, Chocolate Cake, Rainbow Cookies, Strawberry Shortcake with Vanilla Custard, Personalized Cake, My Son's First Birthday Cake, Customs Cake with Chocolate and Vanilla, Personalized Customized Cake

Martha Micek

We’ve ordered from Paulanto several times now — both custom cakes and regular bakery items — and everything is always amazing! Most recently, we had a custom Bluey cake made for my grandson's 3rd birthday, and it turned out perfect.

When we first showed the owner some photos of a more intricate design, he was incredibly transparent and explained that while he could do exactly that design, it would cost quite a bit more. He showed us a simpler version that would look great but be much more affordable. We really appreciated his honesty and advice — we went with the simpler version, and we absolutely loved it (see photos attached!).

The cake looked beautiful and tasted delicious. We’ve tried at least four different cake flavors so far, and every single one has been fantastic. We also regularly pick up their bakery items for parties and to enjoy at home — the chocolate hearts are a must-try and will be gone within the day.

We’ll definitely continue to be repeat customers and can’t recommend Paulanto Bakery enough — both for their custom cakes and their everyday treats.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mahmoud A Shalaby

Honestly, this is hands down one of the best cakes I’ve ever had! 😍 I ordered a custom design just for me, and they absolutely nailed it — even better than the photo I showed them! 🎂✨
The details were perfect, the colors matched beautifully, and the flavor was out of this world — super soft, fresh, and delicious. Everyone at the party kept asking where I got it from! 😋
The team was so kind, professional, and made sure every little detail was just right. They really went above and beyond to make it special for me ❤️
Definitely a 10/10 experience — highly recommend to anyone who wants a unique and unforgettable cake! 👌

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

kevin garcia

Bad customer service

Service: 1

Andrew Mavros

Ordered 5 sfogiatelle this morning and they were very stale threw out one and returned 4, you could throw them at a wall and they’d bounce. Baker tried claiming they were made yesterday but very hard to believe that’s true. Very disappointed and will not be coming here again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

carlos santiago

Ordered a cake for my sister, and it was amazing. They did a awesome job down to every detail! Will definitely be ordering more cake here

Craig Bart

Small round cheese cakes are good mom didn't like carrot cake or mocha cake

Anty Auta

Decided to try something new purchase a cake from the area, based on the reviews I decided to give this place a try. Took forever to be helped, they do not have a menu, and to top it all off the cake I purchased was as flakey as can be. The cake crumbled the minute a slice was cut and we all had to eat it as if it were a bowl of soup. Definitely not wasting my money here at all, this business needs to do a lot better, ALOT.

huvaida ali

I got the Space theme cake for my 1year old boy from this bakery and the baker outdone . It was the most beautiful cake ever. The cake was delicious and we all enjoyed. The cake was actually picture perfect. Thankyou Pulanto Bakery

Deepali

I must say their cheese cake is wow one must try it . Red velvet cake was also delicious I loved it.

My son's cake was so yummy everyone liked it so much thank you 😍

Maged G

Paulanto bakery is one of the best places to order quality cakes for any occasion. They can customize any cake of any shape you like. It's not just how great the cake looks, but it's how amazing it tastes. High quality ingredients, special attention to details & great prices. Owner and staff are very professional and friendly. They are willing to accomodate all your requests. I highly recommend this bakery for and will definitely be back to order more.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ray Nash

Great place, nice service and amazing cakes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ⲓⲣⲉⲛⲉ Ⲡⲁⲥⲓ

The cake turned out so nice they had great service and the cake was ready just in time!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cake, Cupcakes, Cookies and Cream Cake, Personalized Cake, Custom Cake, Personalized Customized Cake, Birthday Cake

Loading...