Best pizza on the island hands down one pie is huge fantastic Love this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephen Connors
Really good NY style pizza. Take out. Outdoor seating area with roof.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
MANNY ADORNO
The size of the pizza you really get your money worth
Christopher Guarin
Stopped by Bay Village for some shopping and craved some pizza. Decided to go with the White Pizza w/ Ricotta (only served as whole pie, not by the slice) after a little wait, we ate at the adhacent pavillion seating area and it was scrumptious and fresh. The crust had a thin crunch. Flavor witb the ricotta was great and felt light and not heav, dense, or oily.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Christina Martucci
HUGE thin crust slice. Really great NY slice while down the shore, a pleasant surprise. The fries are also delicious. Pizza and fries are all they do here and they do both well.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza, Seasoned Fries
Mindy Olive
I ordered the mushroom pizza, and it was delicious! Loved it! The staff was friendly, and the food was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kellyann Fontana
Bay Village Pizza is one of those must-visit spots when you’re in Beach Haven. The thin-crust, New York–style slices are everything you hope for—crispy edges, melty cheese, and a sauce that hits the sweet-savory balance just right. The slices are huge, so one or two can easily hold you over after a day of shopping in Bay Village or relaxing by the water.
Service is quick, even when they’re busy, which makes it great for a fast lunch or grab-and-go dinner. I also appreciate that they keep things simple—no overly complicated menu, just solid pizza and a few extras like fries or specialty pies if you’re in the mood.
The location can’t be beat, the atmosphere is casual, and the smell of fresh pizza alone will pull you in. Prices are a bit higher than your corner pizza shop back home, but you’re paying for quality and the convenience of a prime shore location.
The only downside is that I’ve read about a few rare mishaps with food safety that I hope are fully addressed—thankfully, my own experience was nothing but positive.
If you love thin-crust pizza and want a satisfying, no-frills slice while exploring LBI, Bay Village Pizza is a solid choice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Logue
Hours were not accurate. Spent 30 minutes calling from midnight to 12:30 with no answer.
Dolores Larusso
Was told they had great pizza, not so, requested cooked onions and peppers on pie , got raw items . Pizza was cold when handed to me. It cost $34 and was not worth it. Go somewhere else!!
Doug Fischer
3.5 star slice but I'll round to 4 for the quick window service, which I love. Its your classic boardwalk style, large slice that's thinner than a normal pie with a decent taste to both the cheese and sauce (although nothing incredible). Worth stopping by if you want to grab a slice on the run, although not sure it would be my first pick in the area to order a whole pie.
The pizza was delicious. The size was more than generous. The people were very kind and friendly, especially working in the back kitchen where it is hot as hell.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beata Markowicz
Great pizza at reasonable prices
John Blahut
Great food but google says they close at 1am. Went at 12:15 and they said they were closed? Maybe want to fix that.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
MEB
Truthfully, the BEST pizza on the island, best bang for your buck and organized service. $25 for large plain cheese.. order ahead on weekends! Outdoor covered seating area available :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza, Seasoned Fries
Marielle Fedorko
Get a slice with extra sauce on top and this place gets 5 stars. Without the extra sauce it would get 4, maybe. Fairly thin and crispy style pies, big slices. It’s a takeout window at the beach so atmosphere is good for what it is, sit and eat in the covered gazebo-like area. Friendly workers and servers. Overall good spot for pizza (with extra sauce) on LBI. Recently gave this place a try after about 10 years or so, pizza used to be barely mid, they have significantly stepped it up. Thanks for the great slice (with extra sauce)!
Best pizza on the island hands down one pie is huge fantastic Love this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really good NY style pizza. Take out. Outdoor seating area with roof.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
The size of the pizza you really get your money worth
Stopped by Bay Village for some shopping and craved some pizza. Decided to go with the White Pizza w/ Ricotta (only served as whole pie, not by the slice) after a little wait, we ate at the adhacent pavillion seating area and it was scrumptious and fresh. The crust had a thin crunch. Flavor witb the ricotta was great and felt light and not heav, dense, or oily.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
HUGE thin crust slice. Really great NY slice while down the shore, a pleasant surprise. The fries are also delicious. Pizza and fries are all they do here and they do both well.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza, Seasoned Fries
I ordered the mushroom pizza, and it was delicious! Loved it! The staff was friendly, and the food was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bay Village Pizza is one of those must-visit spots when you’re in Beach Haven. The thin-crust, New York–style slices are everything you hope for—crispy edges, melty cheese, and a sauce that hits the sweet-savory balance just right. The slices are huge, so one or two can easily hold you over after a day of shopping in Bay Village or relaxing by the water.
Service is quick, even when they’re busy, which makes it great for a fast lunch or grab-and-go dinner. I also appreciate that they keep things simple—no overly complicated menu, just solid pizza and a few extras like fries or specialty pies if you’re in the mood.
The location can’t be beat, the atmosphere is casual, and the smell of fresh pizza alone will pull you in. Prices are a bit higher than your corner pizza shop back home, but you’re paying for quality and the convenience of a prime shore location.
The only downside is that I’ve read about a few rare mishaps with food safety that I hope are fully addressed—thankfully, my own experience was nothing but positive.
If you love thin-crust pizza and want a satisfying, no-frills slice while exploring LBI, Bay Village Pizza is a solid choice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hours were not accurate. Spent 30 minutes calling from midnight to 12:30 with no answer.
Was told they had great pizza, not so, requested cooked onions and peppers on pie , got raw items . Pizza was cold when handed to me. It cost $34 and was not worth it. Go somewhere else!!
3.5 star slice but I'll round to 4 for the quick window service, which I love. Its your classic boardwalk style, large slice that's thinner than a normal pie with a decent taste to both the cheese and sauce (although nothing incredible). Worth stopping by if you want to grab a slice on the run, although not sure it would be my first pick in the area to order a whole pie.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
The pizza was delicious. The size was more than generous. The people were very kind and friendly, especially working in the back kitchen where it is hot as hell.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza at reasonable prices
Great food but google says they close at 1am. Went at 12:15 and they said they were closed? Maybe want to fix that.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Truthfully, the BEST pizza on the island, best bang for your buck and organized service. $25 for large plain cheese.. order ahead on weekends! Outdoor covered seating area available :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza, Seasoned Fries
Get a slice with extra sauce on top and this place gets 5 stars. Without the extra sauce it would get 4, maybe. Fairly thin and crispy style pies, big slices. It’s a takeout window at the beach so atmosphere is good for what it is, sit and eat in the covered gazebo-like area. Friendly workers and servers. Overall good spot for pizza (with extra sauce) on LBI. Recently gave this place a try after about 10 years or so, pizza used to be barely mid, they have significantly stepped it up. Thanks for the great slice (with extra sauce)!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...