Great American Lobster Roll Co

Delicious lobster rolls and sides. We tried the CT version and it did not disappoint, definitely coming back here.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Connecticut

We had the Maine Lobster Roll, the CT Lobster Roll and the Lobster Bisque. The lobster rolls were delicious and packed with lobster meat but the lobster bisque had def gone bad. Not sure if they left it sitting over night (since we ordered right when they opened) but It’s tasted very sour. The women working there were very apologetic and refunded my money. We, unfortunately, won’t be back next time we visit LBI due to the bisque incident. Makes you question the rest of their food and preparation protocol. Really sucks because their lobster rolls were delicious, came with a generous side of tater tots, cole slaw and a corn salad for $21. This is def more of a pick up place. The only seating available are some chairs and tables outside.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

The lobster roll is good here. Far better than Mystic Market at this point. The lobster was fresh and tasty. And it came with a small corn dish, small Cole slaw and tater tots. All for only a dollar more than what Mystic Market charges! The quality seems better than Mystic Market as well!!!! I would recommend this place.My only complaint is there is no indoor seating and the inside, on a hot day waiting for your lobster roll is not very comfortable. Besides that, the staff and the product was very good!!!!!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 4

Lobster roll comes with street corn and coleslaw…..street corn is canned corn in a tiny container and the coleslaw is definitely out of a tub from the vendor. Very disappointing!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

ordered chicken tenders yesterday from this restaurant and i got it delivered on the beach. today i have REALLY bad food poisoning which is absolutely disgusting. all i had were the chicken tenders n tots. shocking bc this place has good reviews too. do NOT order from here. if i could give 0 stars i would.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

My family and I placed a takeout order yesterday, and to say we were disappointed is an understatement. They were out of lemonade and water, which was fine because they were able to substitute it for soda (which they then shorted us one). We ordered over $100 worth of food which we weren’t given any utensils to eat with, we were missing two sides, and the sauce we requested on the side was not in the bag. Definitely would not recommend if you are doing a takeout order because we tried calling back and the phone just rang with no answer. Quality of food was also subpar- I’ve had better. A shame because their reviews were great!! We won’t be ordering from here again.

Service: 1

Excellent lobster roll! Best on LBI Across from the Chegg...a must try spot. We will be back!

We ordered the Maine and Connecticut rolls. They were rich, delicious, and we enjoyed them.Would definitely order again! A little disappointed in the coleslaw, did not taste homemade and the small condiment container size.We would Oder again ?

Best lobster roll I’ve had in years and comes with really good sides. Very friendly staff also.

Wow!!! We’re locals and can’t stop raving about this place.Family run business with generous portions. Owner is on premises to make sure everything is top notch. The lobster mac & cheese was to die for. I had the Jersey lobster roll which was delicious too.

Food was fantastic, quick prep time on a busy Sunday night, great flavor variety without overpowering the lobster! Highly recommend! They also handed a large order very well.

Really great experience from the start. The owner was fantastic - he was so amazing with our 3-year old son and offered him some lobster meat to try in addition to the mac & cheese he ordered (which was delicious). The food was really tasty and some interesting options for the rolls. The rolls had a generous amount of lobster for the price. Overall we were super happy with our lunch.

Not the best Lobster Roll I've ever had, but a solid choice for sure.

One of the best lobster rolls I’ve ever had. Dave did not disappoint, and was so nice and fun to talk to. Had no complaints about the lobster roll, all around amazing in every way. Drove over an hour for lobster rolls and will definitely be back!

Delicious and full of lobster. Meal comes with corn, cole slaw and tater tots. We ordered the Connecticut lobster roll which was tossed in hot butter. Each lobster roll had large chunks of lobster. So delicios