Mystic Lobster Rolls Beach Haven

In response to your response to my original review…. This is not a fake review! Second blame autocorrect for never winning a spelling bee! Third and most importantly if you are going to open your doors and turn on your griddle.. and attempt at making something tasty then learn how to cook first! Or just specialize in pre-made beef franks!Lastly and most importantly for you… listen to your customers and take a lil advise before bashing them… because the truth will always prevail.We went to this restaurant to get 2 lobster rolls Mac n cheese fries and a crab cake sandwich… almost $80.00…. insane!!!The lobster roll had no flavor with such a small portion of meat and the crab cake was the same! I don’t mind spending money but not for a meal like this!!! Discrase!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Overpriced and bland. Look for something else.

Tiny portion, no flavor, doesn't even come with what it's supposed to. At least the girls at the counter are nice.

best lobster roll i have ever had, definitely the best on the island. so many options and great service. never go anywhere else.

Very disappointed. Maine roll had no mayo I could taste and no pickle and no slaw on the side as advertised.Just chopped up claws on a roll. There was a side of pasta salad for some reason.

Apparently Beach Haven has a bunch of lobster roll restaurants. We tried three of them this week that are close to Bay Village, and I can say that Mystic is the best tasting. The place across the street is better if you want to eat in the restaurant, but Mystic is the best tasting roll. Mystic was the most expensive roll of the three places, but it was also the largest, so I’m perfectly fine with that. Will definitely go back again, and would highly recommend.

Best lobster roll I have ever had!

I have never had a lobster roll since a couple of days ago and I feel this place has the best on the island! Will definitely be coming back for more lobster rolls.

The service, bright smiles and delicious food. also the price is right!

awesome family and amazing food

Most amazing Lobster Roll I’ve ever had. Highly recommended.