The best ice cream you’ll find just about anywhere. The staff is super friendly. They constantly update the flavors and everything is made in house.
We also had a party for our daughter here. They got to learn how ice cream is made and then got make their very own flavors to take home. Such a great experience!!
Miss them in the off season.
Pierce Alexander Lilholt
Locals know it as The Ice Cream Sammich Shack.
Tatiana Hoover
Delicious homemade cream with interesting unique flavors. We were there on a weekend afternoon, short line, very nice server. Generous servings of tasty, creamy ice cream. Small parking lot, inside and outside tables.
Juliet Lebda
A friend and I ordered chocolate milkshakes. They were decent I suppose but not even halfway through the shake I had extreme stomach pain as did my friend. Ruined my whole night.
William Wurtz
WooHoo has an electronic ice cream flavor menu that you would think is easy to update. After I ordered and waited a minute or two, I was told “we are out of that flavor”, I ordered a second flavor choice, also listed on the electronic menu. After again waiting, I was told “we are out of that flavor” . My third selection was available, and I watched as the server had quite a difficult time adding the second scoop to my two scoop cone order. The second scoop kept falling off. After a few more attempts, the server was able to balance the second scoop, but as she lifted up the cone from the ice cream tub area, the second scoop fell off and I was served, with a shrug, that I interpreted as “that was the best I could do”. I was charged for two scoops and served a cone with ultimately less ice cream than what was on my wife’s single scoop cone. It’s not about the price, it is all about service. After tasting the ice cream, my assumption is that due to a very “icy” texture on what should have been a creamy ice cream texture, it was quite challenging to get the two scoops to stick together. So who was at fault….the person who made the batch of ice cream? The server? Both. As a member of a family who has lived on LBI for 5 generations, I understand the difficulty getting Summer help, and never set the bar high in anticipation of great Summer LBI service, but I think WooHoo should try a little harder.
Brooke
Lots of flavors. Very creamy. No line like the other places nearby!
Carolyn Culley
Lines are so slow, service isn’t good!! Took 30 min to get ice cream
CD 1980
Great ice cream, love the old school vibe! One suggestion would be an outside menu for while you are waiting in the line. Other than that, woo hoo!!!
Maverick Davis
My spouse is severely allergic to eggs and we double checked with the manager to make sure she could have the vegan ice cream and allergy safe brownie. She ended up getting a severe allergic reaction.Not an allergy friendly location!
Sophia Latriano
Incredible creamy ice cream, lots of fun flavors. Tried the strawberry pretzel and cinnamon crunch - loved both. One scoop actually is more like three!
If anyone gives this place less than 5 stars they have no idea what delicious homemade ice cream tastes like. Hands down the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Quality ingredients made to perfection!
Gordon Robertson
Great prices and quality ice cream, owners are super friendly and you can tell they put a lot of time and effort into making great flavors!
Mari Vida
Frankie was great!!!
Service: 5
Lindsay Sobon
The workers were slow. Unprofessional and my ice cream tasted like mint. It seemed dirty. And prices were not that great compared to a Barrys.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Three Scoops
Valerie McKiernan
Hands down, best ice cream on the island and homemade! Always unique flavors.
The best ice cream you’ll find just about anywhere. The staff is super friendly. They constantly update the flavors and everything is made in house.
We also had a party for our daughter here. They got to learn how ice cream is made and then got make their very own flavors to take home. Such a great experience!!
Miss them in the off season.
Locals know it as The Ice Cream Sammich Shack.
Delicious homemade cream with interesting unique flavors. We were there on a weekend afternoon, short line, very nice server. Generous servings of tasty, creamy ice cream. Small parking lot, inside and outside tables.
A friend and I ordered chocolate milkshakes. They were decent I suppose but not even halfway through the shake I had extreme stomach pain as did my friend. Ruined my whole night.
WooHoo has an electronic ice cream flavor menu that you would think is easy to update.
After I ordered and waited a minute or two, I was told “we are out of that flavor”,
I ordered a second flavor choice, also listed on the electronic menu.
After again waiting, I was told “we are out of that flavor” .
My third selection was available, and I watched as the server had quite a difficult time adding the second scoop to my two scoop cone order. The second scoop kept falling off. After a few more attempts, the server was able to balance the second scoop, but as she lifted up the cone from the ice cream tub area, the second scoop fell off and I was served, with a shrug, that I interpreted as “that was the best I could do”.
I was charged for two scoops and served a cone with ultimately less ice cream than what was on my wife’s single scoop cone.
It’s not about the price, it is all about service.
After tasting the ice cream, my assumption is that due to a very “icy” texture on what should have been a creamy ice cream texture, it was quite challenging to get the two scoops to stick together.
So who was at fault….the person who made the batch of ice cream? The server? Both.
As a member of a family who has lived on LBI for 5 generations, I understand the difficulty getting Summer help, and never set the bar high in anticipation of great Summer LBI service, but I think WooHoo should try a little harder.
Lots of flavors. Very creamy. No line like the other places nearby!
Lines are so slow, service isn’t good!! Took 30 min to get ice cream
Great ice cream, love the old school vibe! One suggestion would be an outside menu for while you are waiting in the line. Other than that, woo hoo!!!
My spouse is severely allergic to eggs and we double checked with the manager to make sure she could have the vegan ice cream and allergy safe brownie. She ended up getting a severe allergic reaction.Not an allergy friendly location!
Incredible creamy ice cream, lots of fun flavors. Tried the strawberry pretzel and cinnamon crunch - loved both. One scoop actually is more like three!
Restaurantji Recommends
If anyone gives this place less than 5 stars they have no idea what delicious homemade ice cream tastes like. Hands down the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Quality ingredients made to perfection!
Great prices and quality ice cream, owners are super friendly and you can tell they put a lot of time and effort into making great flavors!
Frankie was great!!!
Service: 5
The workers were slow. Unprofessional and my ice cream tasted like mint. It seemed dirty. And prices were not that great compared to a Barrys.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Three Scoops
Hands down, best ice cream on the island and homemade! Always unique flavors.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone, Ice Cream Sandwich
Loading...