We were seated promptly, a group of 9. Drinks came out , 2 were wrong, it was taken care of. Food was good, but service was a bit off. Asked several times for things, and never came. Found out that it was asked for a dessert with a candle for a birthday, which we never received. All in all, we had a good dining experience. I chalked it up to the waitress having such a large group. Update!! I am so pleased to have heard from Tuckers today. Totally wasn't necessary, but it has meant alot that they chose to respond to my review. That tells me more than anything else, that they read these reviews and learn from them. Like I said, we had a great time, the food was delicious (ahi tuna tacos are my favorite), and a few little service hiccups would never stop me from coming back. Thanks again for reaching out and we will definitely see you soon!
JayF
Best meal I've had on LBI. Chowder was excellent. Burger was one of the best I've had. Bolognese was 10/10. The server was exceptional. Can't wait to go back.
Marc and Noelle
We had an amazing waiter, Michael, who made sure our drinks & food were on par. Dedicated server and fun attitude added joy to our night. Enjoyed restaurant had a band playing but do suggest booking an early start time to play longer set on holiday evening. Music was good though and we really enjoyed!
Lelette
Wonderful time for our early New Year's Eve dinner! Everyone ( patrons, staff) was happy! Our food choices were excellent. So were the speciality cocktails! Our server, Aimee was great! Extra bubbly like my prosecco!
Carin
So nice and toasty being sat up by the fire. Waiter was great - very helpful. The food was delicious and beautifully presented. We enjoy a wonderful time with friends we haven't seen for a long while. A wonderful time of fellowship during the Christmas holidays. We'll be back again.
Maureen
Just a great restaurant with the feel of a local tavern. We sat by the fireplace. Nice mixture of couples and families at 7pm. Food very good.
WILLIAM
only complaint-sat us(5) at a table next to an outside door in winter,cold draft at your feet,blast of cold air when door was opened.Should no t be a table there unless door problem is somehow remedied ! ( Our server was great !)
Jeanise
Everything was wonderful! Server was amazing! Food great! Only negative was the host and hostess. Not friendly at all.
Kathy
Our Waitress was a delight. So cheerful and she was there for whatever we needed. Food and drinks were very good. We were seated right by the roaring fireplace and we loved it. Thanks for a great night out.
Rich
Everything was great! The food, the service and the drinks. That Campfire Old Fashioned did not disappoint. The ambiance was all decked out for Christmas and felt festive. Our server Mike was professional and fun to interact with. Will definitely be going back there and asking for him. I definitely recommend this restaurant.
Ok so this is our go to spot especially in the fall and winter. Love the variety of drinks and food. Great staff.
Stephen M
Food was great wings, calamari catch of the day Sarah was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lake Girl
Our favorite restaurant on the island has lost its sparkle. My daughter treated me to a dinner for my birthday. A Wednesday night on October 1, it was quiet, and the server was sweet. The food however was awful, frozen shrimp, dressing from a jar, cold French fries, 2 tiny fish and chips, wine that is measured. The good ole Tuckers is dead. And what we paid for this nightmare is beyond sad.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Jersey paddle boards
Absolutely loved this place. Fantastic food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dorothy Elizabeth
Went for Saturday night dinner with our Pupster! We sat on the upper deck, arrived close to sundown! The sunset was breathtaking as was the Seafood! 😊 The seafood salad was scrumptious and large enough for two! Salmon, shrimp and lump crab meat on top of cob salad …cocktails were delicious… He had the Watermelon Mint Martini light and refreshing I had Tuckers Tikitini light flavors mixed well!
We were seated promptly, a group of 9. Drinks came out , 2 were wrong, it was taken care of. Food was good, but service was a bit off. Asked several times for things, and never came. Found out that it was asked for a dessert with a candle for a birthday, which we never received. All in all, we had a good dining experience. I chalked it up to the waitress having such a large group. Update!! I am so pleased to have heard from Tuckers today. Totally wasn't necessary, but it has meant alot that they chose to respond to my review. That tells me more than anything else, that they read these reviews and learn from them. Like I said, we had a great time, the food was delicious (ahi tuna tacos are my favorite), and a few little service hiccups would never stop me from coming back. Thanks again for reaching out and we will definitely see you soon!
Best meal I've had on LBI. Chowder was excellent. Burger was one of the best I've had. Bolognese was 10/10. The server was exceptional. Can't wait to go back.
We had an amazing waiter, Michael, who made sure our drinks & food were on par. Dedicated server and fun attitude added joy to our night. Enjoyed restaurant had a band playing but do suggest booking an early start time to play longer set on holiday evening. Music was good though and we really enjoyed!
Wonderful time for our early New Year's Eve dinner! Everyone ( patrons, staff) was happy! Our food choices were excellent. So were the speciality cocktails! Our server, Aimee was great! Extra bubbly like my prosecco!
So nice and toasty being sat up by the fire. Waiter was great - very helpful. The food was delicious and beautifully presented. We enjoy a wonderful time with friends we haven't seen for a long while. A wonderful time of fellowship during the Christmas holidays. We'll be back again.
Just a great restaurant with the feel of a local tavern. We sat by the fireplace. Nice mixture of couples and families at 7pm. Food very good.
only complaint-sat us(5) at a table next to an outside door in winter,cold draft at your feet,blast of cold air when door was opened.Should no t be a table there unless door problem is somehow remedied ! ( Our server was great !)
Everything was wonderful! Server was amazing! Food great! Only negative was the host and hostess. Not friendly at all.
Our Waitress was a delight. So cheerful and she was there for whatever we needed. Food and drinks were very good. We were seated right by the roaring fireplace and we loved it. Thanks for a great night out.
Everything was great! The food, the service and the drinks. That Campfire Old Fashioned did not disappoint. The ambiance was all decked out for Christmas and felt festive. Our server Mike was professional and fun to interact with. Will definitely be going back there and asking for him. I definitely recommend this restaurant.
Restaurantji Recommends
Ok so this is our go to spot especially in the fall and winter. Love the variety of drinks and food. Great staff.
Food was great wings, calamari catch of the day Sarah was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our favorite restaurant on the island has lost its sparkle. My daughter treated me to a dinner for my birthday. A Wednesday night on October 1, it was quiet, and the server was sweet. The food however was awful, frozen shrimp, dressing from a jar, cold French fries, 2 tiny fish and chips, wine that is measured. The good ole Tuckers is dead. And what we paid for this nightmare is beyond sad.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Absolutely loved this place. Fantastic food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went for Saturday night dinner with our Pupster! We sat on the upper deck, arrived close to sundown! The sunset was breathtaking as was the Seafood! 😊 The seafood salad was scrumptious and large enough for two! Salmon, shrimp and lump crab meat on top of cob salad …cocktails were delicious…
He had the Watermelon Mint Martini light and refreshing
I had Tuckers Tikitini light flavors mixed well!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Loading...