Bagelsmith Food Store Deli & Pizzeria

It's so awesome to FINALLY have good pizza in the area! Outstanding!
Update as of March 2025... pizza is absolute trash now. I'm not sure where they went wrong but I'd honestly rather eat a frozen Ellio's. So disappointing.

Food: 1

Ordered a cheese steak with sauce and onions. Got home to find out it's just steak and cheese. Called back and they said they couldn't make me a new one because they have no rolls. She said come back and we will give you a refund. Went back to only be told they can't give me a refund. Call back tomorrow. This place has changed so much in the past year that I will no longer be a customer.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

OK so against my better judgement I returned to Baglesmith. Now my last review the owner said that it wasn’t his store I was mistaken. So let’s start by saying this is the combination pizza/ice cream/sandwich/bagel shop off 46 on 519 catty corner to Quick Check, and across from a school. That being said, I got the Italian Hogie and the lovely Mz D got a BLT. First of all who has seen invisible tomatoes, ok I’m exaggerating they weren’t invisible but they sure were see thru. I’d had writing paper thicker, this on both sandwiches. First Mz D wasn’t aware you need to specify toasted bread, (on a BLT? Really?) And speaking of invisible the bacon came in a close second to the tomato. Mz D who used to frequent this shop was very, very, very disappointed. Did I mention she was very disappointed. My Hoagie which I said load it up but no hot peppers. (Also found out I was charged an addition .50 for provolone (on an Italian hoagie really?) Any way huge roll which was probably the best part of this sandwich, and a ton of shredded lettuce, three paper thin tomatoes, and to paraphrase the old Wendy commercial “Where’s the CHEESE”? Mz D did buy a pint of coleslaw which was good (probably not house made) and thank God she did cause I used it to add some flavor to my Hoagie. Look, the kids behind the counter were nice enough but I think a little adult supervision might have been called for. Then again they were probably only following the owners directions, dotting the i’s and crossing their T’s. So while I was expecting a Hoagie that would be better than the Quick Check (who incidentally make a great spicy Italian Sub, maybe that’s the difference QC makes subs and zone Bagel makes “Hoagies”). Now since it’s a small business and (foolish me) believing they are trying to keep customers happy, I was also, like the lovely Mz D, very very disappointed. Maybe not very very very disappointed but disappointed none the less. Sorry Mr (or Mrs) Baglesmith you get a double thumbs down ( no make that 5 thumbs down) with my advice; if you’re not stopping in for just coffee or bagels pass this place by.
?????
BTW for making crappy sandwiches how come the pizza looks so good? Oh yeah the Spanish guys run that part and they want to make good food.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Food is good if they can get the order right !!!! Order a bacon & egg and get a bacon, egg & cheese !

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

Delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Bagel

Excellent bagels!!

Food: 5

I always like coming here. Decent prices. Okay staff

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Great subs

Ordered a large Pepporni pie picked it up and had to check the box to make sure there was a pizza inside. The box felt so light compared to other places. It was almost like thin crust the pizza was like see through it's like they are using halt the normal dough size. Not good I don't know what changed.
I asked them about it they looked at me like I had three heads.
Not going back there.

Food: 2

Service: 2

This is a great deli. The selection and service is great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

So excited to return to NJ and order porkroll, egg, and cheese on a hard roll.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Bagel, Egg and Cheese

Very clean place and great customer service ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Service is quick. Food is well cooked. Staff is friendly. Great food choices and good coffee.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Been here dozens of times. Never had a bad meal. Bagels and breakfast sandwiches, pizza, burgers, meatball parm. I'd highly recommend if your passing through.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Bagel, Egg and Cheese

Great personal

Vegetarian options: Great morning staff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast Bagel