Bagelsmith Food Store Deli & Pizzeria
540 County Road 519, Belvidere
(908) 475-8787
Customers' Favorites
Breakfast Bagel
Egg and Cheese
Roast Beef
Menu
Photos
+20 photos
+19 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Hands down best bagels in the area. We have tried them all and nothing touches Bagelsmith. But it doesn't end there, ALL of their ingredients are just, better, than others we have tried. Their eggs, meats, cheeses, everything. On top of that the ladies (and you guys!) that run the place are super nice and always on top of the utter chaos that sometimes happens in their small establishment (it's that good!).
This place is amazing! My husband and I got the French toast bagel with cream cheese (incredible) and two breakfast sandwiches. I’m pregnant and forgot to ask for my eggs well done, and they put the eggs on longer for me even after they were finished! This place is great, highly recommend
It's so awesome to FINALLY have good pizza in the area! Outstanding!
Update as of March 2025... pizza is absolute trash now. I'm not sure where they went wrong but I'd honestly rather eat a frozen Ellio's. So disappointing.
Update as of March 2025... pizza is absolute trash now. I'm not sure where they went wrong but I'd honestly rather eat a frozen Ellio's. So disappointing.
You May Also Like
Riverside Diner - 475 US-46
![]()
Diner, Bar
Hot Dog Johnny's - 333 US-46
![]()
Hot Dogs, Pet Friendly
Waters Edge - 487 US-46
![]()
Pizza, Burgers, Bar, Vegetarian