Lenny's Pizzeria & Trattoria

Phenomenal pizza 👏🏼 I swear the bolognese square slice is the single best piece of pizza I’ve ever had. The dough is so light and fluffy here. My only small complaint is that when you dine in and pay for a fountain soda it’s “no refills” which is a little funny since you get a reusable cup

Lenny’s is one of the best Pizzeria in entire New Jersey. I have been coming here for over 17 years and it is super consistent in terms of the quality and service they offer. Overall it’s a nice cozy place to dine in or take out. The owner is always a joy to meet and is very friendly. Highly recommend their famous Margherita Pizza

Best pizza in the Bernardsville area.

Came in for a quick slice, not disappointed, good stuff!

My son and I had my Mother's Day dinner at Lenny's and we really enjoyed the food and service! My son always loves their pepperoni pizza and I enjoyed an Italian sub sandwich with what I believe are homemade chips--very satisfying! Their service people were very attentive and kind and we definitely enjoyed our Mother's Day evening dining at Lenny's.

Lenny's is a great place for pizza and other items you'd expect in a pizza place like wings or chicken parm.

Absolutely one of the best tasting pies around! Been going there for years. They also have a new garlic spread that is a MUST HAVE! Great to dip your slice in or have on a white slice. If you haven’t tried it yet, ask for it when you order a pizza! 🍕🇮🇹👌🏼

The restaurant has a very high-end look and feel, which initially gave me different expectations. However, the experience was a bit surprising. They ring a loud bell multiple times when your food is ready, and if you don’t come right away, they’ll call you out about it—which felt a bit awkward, especially since I didn’t know that’s how they operated.

One thing that really stood out to me in a negative way was the “no free refills” sign. It just gives off a cheap vibe, especially since they only offer one cup size. It felt like nickel-and-diming.

As for the food, the pizza was okay—nothing terrible, but nothing that really wowed me either. Overall, a decent spot, but I expected a bit more based on the upscale appearance.

Terrible. Ordered pizza to go. The pizza was wet and cold.

My all time favorite pizza place growing up. Been going here for 20+ years. Their margherita slices are what I base all other margherita slices on! Always super fresh and always consistently delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lenny’s pizza went above & beyond for me. I messed up on my online order. I thought I did an order for delivery & it was for pick up. My kid were home alone. The owner hand delivered the pizza to my children when he heard this!! I’ve been going to Lenny’s since I was in high school. I will forever be a HUGE supporter!! Great food and great people.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I’m done with this place, been getting orders of food here for months. 3 strikes im done. Lady behind the counter doesn’t do customer service well. Not worth the high prices to come here And have rest of your day ruined

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Brooklyn Vodka Grandma Pizza

Came late on Sunday night , ordered takeout and eat in, added to our order a second time and they couldn’t have been nicer. Food was great, servers were super nice and they went out of their way to accommodate every request!

Just had the cheese pizza. It was tasty. I liked it much more than the basking ridge pizza.

The dishes are superb, each one a feast for the eyes and the palate. The presentation is top-notch, and the flavors are incredible.
The pizzas are a standout. They have the perfect balance of a crispy crust and rich toppings. Every slice is a joy to eat, with fresh ingredients and a delicious blend of flavors.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Slice, Mushroom Pizza