Gencarelli's Bakery
446 Broad St, Bloomfield
(973) 743-1480
Customers' Favorites
Mousse Cake with Wipe Cream Icing
Black and White Cookie
Strawberry Cheesecake
Strawberry Shortcake
Hazelnut Cheesecake
Seven Layer Cake
Apple Turnover
Chocolate Cake
Birthday Cake
Carrot Cake
Menu
Photos
+51 photos
+50 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I ordered a custom cake and it was just subpar. For some unknown reason, you can get red velvet in 7inch but NOT 8inch??? Then I asked for an edible image on the cake and it actually looked so dumb 😆 yes, the pick is a square with text but at least call to see how I’d like for it to be placed on the cake omg it looks so silly I could cry. Anyway, I paid for it beforehand so I just left with the silly cake (not even the flavor I wanted!!!!!) but would not recommend.
Good service and the bakery items are usually good. However, on several occasions I’ve purchased cupcakes that were stale and dry. I’ve learned to ask for cupcakes from the front of the display case. I recently bought a cake and was told it was made that day, but it definitely didn’t taste fresh. Unfortunately, no one finished their slice. It really should have been returned.
This place is amazing! I came here to get some cannoli’s for a godfather movie weekend. And Josie helped me out. She was great and enthusiastic. Recommended some other pastries. And wrapped everything up nicely! Thanks Josie! I will be back.
You May Also Like
Casa Turano Parkside Pizza - 455 Broad St
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian
Happy Ming - 456 Broad St
![]()
Chinese
Obal's Inn - 439 Broad St
![]()
Gastropubs, Barbeque, Pubs, American, Sports Bar