AJ's Pizza Butler
12 Main St, Butler
(973) 283-0454
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Francese Garlic Bread w Cheese 2l Soda
Macaroni & Cheese Pizza
Cheese Burger Deluxe
Philly Cheese Steak
Side Caesar Salad
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Fingers
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Knots 6
Grandma Slice
Soups
Pasta Fagioli Soup
Ditalini Pasta, Red Kidney Beans, Garlic, Chicken Broth, Grated Cheese, Touch of Marinara
Cheese Tortellini Soup
Cheese Tortellini Pasta, Chicken Broth, Parsley, Grated Cheese
Chicken Wild Rice Soup
Cream Based Soup, Rice, Carrots, Celery, Chicken
Chicken Noodle Soup
Noodles, Carrots, Celery, Chicken
Appetizers
Mac & Cheese
Mac & Cheese w/Bacon
Mac And Cheese Bites
Eggplant Rollatini (2)
Shrimp Cocktail (5 pcs)
Shrimp Cocktail
Mozzarella Sticks (8)
Mozzarella Sticks with Marinara Sauce
Black Shell Mussels (15)
Fried Calamari
Hot Or Sweet
Fried Shrimp (5 pcs)
Bruschetta
Wings
Wings - 6pcs or 12 pcs
Boneless Wings
Boneless Wings (7pcs or 14 pcs )
Zucchini Sticks (10)
Zucchini Sticks with Marinara Sauce
Cheese Steak Eggrolls (3)
Cheesesteak Egg Rolls comes with Chipotle Mayo
Chicken Nuggets (10 pcs.)
Chicken Nuggets with BBQ Sauce
Chicken Fingers (5 pcs.)
Chicken Fingers (5 pcs.) w/Fries
Chicken Fingers with Fries
French Fries w/ Toppings
French Fries W /Toppings
French Fries
Pizza Fries
Curly Fries
Steak Fries
Sweet Potato Fries
French Bread Pizza
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Garlic Knots (6)
Onion Rings
Fried Ravioli (8)
Jalapeño Poppers (8)
Zuppa Di Clams
White Scampi or Marinara
Sauteed Broccoli
Sautéed in chicken broth
Sauteed Broccoli Rabe
Sauteed Spinach
Panini
Prosciutto Panini
w/ fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomato & olive oil
Chicken Caesar Panini
Grilled chicken w/ romaine lettuce, croutons & caesar dressing
Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato, Basil & Balsamic Vinaigrette Panini
Chicken Panini w/choice of toppings
with your choice of toppings
Grilled Chicken Pesto Panini
w/ sun-dried tomato & goat cheese
Grilled Chicken Mixed Green Panini
w/ fresh mozzarella, mixed greens & balsamic vinaigrette
Turkey, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese & Sundried Tomato Panini
w/ honey mustard or deli mustard
Roast Beef Panini
w/ cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onions & thousand island dressing
Steak, Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers Panini
w/ mixed greens, tomato & balsamic vinaigrette
Cheesesteak Panini
w/ mushrooms, peppers, onions, potatoes & American cheese
Tuna Salad Panini
Our special recipe tuna topped w/ leaf lettuce, tomato, red onion, salt & pepper
Hot Veggie Panini
Fried eggplant w/ grilled broccoli, spinach, mushrooms & peppers
Prosciutto Pesto Panini
w/ goat cheese & sun-dried tomatoes
Salads
House Salad
Iceberg lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Pepperoncini, Carrots, Black olives, Green olives, Red onions, Provolone cheese cut into strips
House Salad w/Grilled Chicken
Antipasto Salad
Chef Salad
Caesar Salad
Caesar Salad w/ Grilled Chicken
Fresh Mozz, Tomato, & Basil Salad
Greek Salad
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Calamari Salad
Shrimp Salad
Seafood Salad
Grilled Chicken & Artichoke Salad
Grilled chicken over romaine lettuce w/ red onions, roasted peppers, artichokes & fresh mozzarella
BBQ Grilled Chicken Salad
BBQ grilled chicken over romaine lettuce w/ cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, cheddar cheese & ranch dressing
Grilled Chicken Fresh Apple Craisin Salad
Grilled chicken over mixed greens w/ tomatoes, red onions, frosted pecans, craisins, goat cheese & fresh apple slices
Grilled Chicken Mandarin Orange Salad
Grilled chicken over mixed greens w/ tomatoes, red onions, goat cheese, craisins & mandarin oranges
Wraps
Tuna Salad Wrap
Homemade Tuna w/ Choice of Veggies/Cheese
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Romaine Lettuce, Chicken, Croutons
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Chicken Cutlet, Buffalo Sauce, Choice of Veggies/Cheese
Cheesesteak Wrap
Mushrooms,Peppers,Onions,American Cheese
Chicken Teriyaki Wrap
Red onions, pineapples, American cheese & teriyaki sauce
Chicken Parm Vodka Wrap
Chicken Cutlet, Mozzarella, Vodka Sauce
Turkey And Cheese Wrap
Turkey, Choice of Veggies/Cheese
Grilled Chicken Fm Rrp Wrap
Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & balsamic vinaigrette
Breaded or Grilled Chicken Wrap
Italian Wrap
Ham, Salami, Provolone, Choice of Veggies
Eggplant Fresh Mozz Rrp Wrap
Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & balsamic vinaigrette
Hot Veggie Wrap
Grilled broccoli, spinach, mushrooms & peppers
Roast Beef & Cheese Wrap
Roast Beef, Choice of Veggies/Cheese
Salad Wrap
Chicken Bruschetta Wrap
Fresh-homemade bruschetta w/ your choice of dressing
Cold Subs
Italian Sub
Provolone Cheese , Ham & Salami
Ham & Cheese Sub
Salami & Cheese Sub
Grill Chicken W/ Lettuce& Tomato Sub
w/ lettuce & tomato
Grilled Chicken with Cheese Sub
Grilled Chicken Fm Rrp
w/ fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers
Grilled Chicken Fm Rrp Broc Rabe Sub
w/ broccoli rabe, fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers
Buffalo Chicken Cutlet Sub
Breaded Chicken Cutlet Sub
w/ choice of cheese, lettuce & tomato
BLT
Veal Cutlet Sub
w/ lettuce & tomato
Eggplant Sub Fresh Mozzarella Roasted Red Peppers Sub
w/ fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers
Tuna Sub
Tuna Melt Sub
Turkey Sub
Turkey & Chesse Sub
Three Cheese Sub
American, Provolone & Swiss Cheese
Prosciutto Fresh Mozz Rrp Sub
w/ fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers
Prosciutto & Provolone Sub
Chicken BLT Sub
Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers Sub
w/ fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers
Roast Beef Sub
Roast Beef & Turkey Sub
Hot Subs
Shrimp Parmigiana Hot Sub
Chicken Parmigiana Hot Sub
Chicken Parm with Alfredo Sauce Hot Sub
Chicken Parm with Vodka Sauce Hot Sub
Grilled Chicken Parm Hot Sub
Boom Boom Chicken Parm Hot Sub
Buffalo Chicken Parm Hot Sub
Veal Parmigiana Hot Sub
Eggplant Parmigiana Hot Sub
Meatball Parmigiana Hot Sub
Sausage Parmigiana Hot Sub
Sausage & Peppers Hot Sub
Sausage, Peppers, & Onions Hot Sub
Sausage, Peppers, & Onions Hot Sub
Pepper & Egg Hot Sub
Pepper, Egg, & Cheese Hot Sub
Sausage, Peppers, Egg, & Cheese Hot Sub
Ham, Egg, & Cheese Hot Sub
Egg & Cheese Hot Sub
Bacon, Egg, & Cheese Hot Sub
Specialty Subs
Chicken Francese Specialty Sub
w/ fresh mozzarella
Chicken Marsala Specialty Sub
w/ fresh mozzarella
Grilled Chicken Teriyaki Specialty Sub
w/ your choice of cheese
Hot Roast Beef Specialty Sub
w/ mozzarella & gravy
Hot Turkey Specialty Sub
w/ mozzarella & gravy
Grilled Chicken Balsamico Specialty Sub
Grilled chicken marinated in balsamic dressing with melted mozzarella & roasted peppers on a toasted Italian bread
Sweet BBQ Cheesesteak w/Cheddar Sub
Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak Specialty Sub
w/ provolone, lettuce & bleu cheese
Fat AJ's #1 Specialty Sub
Chicken cutlet w/ french fries, mozzarella sticks, American cheese, onion rings & mayo
Fat AJ's #2 Specialty Sub
Steak w/ chicken cutlet, french fries, mozzarella sticks, American cheese, onion rings & mayo
Fat AJ's #3 Specialty Sub
Chicken fingers w/ mozzarella sticks, french fries, marinara or honey mustard
Fat AJ's #4 Specialty Sub
Steak w/ mozzarella sticks, french fries & marinara sauce
Fat AJ's #5 Specialty Sub
Steak w/ chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, french fries, lettuce & ketchup
Fat AJ's Create Your Own Specialty Sub
Pasta
Pasta w Marinara Sauce
Pasta w Marinara Sauce
Pasta w Butter Sauce
Pasta w Butter Sauce
Pasta w Meat Sauce
Pasta w Meat Sauce
Pasta Primavera Sauce
Pasta Primavera Sauce
Pasta Garlic & Oil
Pasta w/ Garlic & Oil
Pasta Broccoli, Garlic, & Oil
Pasta w Vodka Sauce
Pasta w Vodka Souce & Chicken
Pasta w Vodka Souce & Shrimps
Pasta w Alfredo Sauce
Pasta w Alfredo Sauce & Chicken
Pasta w Alfredo Sauce & Shrimps
Pasta w Alfredo Sauce & Shrimps
Pasta w Meatballs (3)
Pasta w Sausage (3)
Pasta w Pesto Sauce
Baked Lasagna w Meat
Baked Lasagna w Meat
Baked Lasagna w Cheese
Baked Ziti
Baked Ziti w / Ricotta
Baked Ziti w / 3 Meatballs
Baked Ziti w / 3 Sausages
Baked Stuffed Shells
Ravioli w/ Marinara Sauce
Baked Cheese Ravioli Marinara
Baked Ravioli
Baked Ravioli
Ravioli w Alfredo
Ravioli W/Vodka Sauce
Tortellini Marinara
Cavatelli Marinara
Cavatelli Marinara
Cavatelli & Broccoli
Cavatelli & Broccoli
Cavatelli w Broccoli Rabe With Chicken
Cavatelli and Broccoli Rabe With Chicken
Cavatelli w Broccoli Rabe With Shrimp
Gnocchi Marinara
Gnocchi Marinara with Potato pasta
Eggplant Rollatini w/Pasta
Eggplant Parmigiana w/Pasta
Eggplant Parmigiana w/Pasta
Side Pasta
Side Marinara Pasta
Side Marinara Pasta
Side Baked Marinara Pasta
Side Baked Marinara Pasta
Side Meat Sauce Pasta
Side Garlic & Oil Pasta
Side Vodka Sauce Pasta
Side Vodka Sauce Pasta
Side Meatballs (3)
Side Meatballs (3)
Side Sausage (3)
Side Alfredo Sauce Pasta
Side Alfredo Sauce Pasta
Side Pesto Sauce
Side Pesto Sauce
Side Butter Sauce Pasta
Chicken Dinners
Chicken Parmigiana
Breaded cutlets topped w/ marinara & mozzarella cheese
Chicken Marsala
Sautéed w/ mushrooms in a Marsala wine sauce
Chicken Francese
Dipped in egg batter & sautéed in a white wine lemon sauce
Chicken Scampi
Fresh chicken cutlets lightly breaded & sautéed in a garlic lemon sauce
Chicken Cacciatore
Chunks of fresh chicken sautéed w/ mushrooms, potatoes, peppers & onions in a fresh marinara sauce
Chicken Florentine
Topped with spinach, roasted red peppers, and mozzarella cheese sautéed in an oil and garlic sauce with a touch of marinara
Chicken Piccata
Sautéed w/ capers in a lemon sauce
Chicken Saltimbocca
Sautéed cutlets topped w/ spinach, prosciutto, & mozzarella cheese in an oil & garlic sauce w/ a touch of marinara
Chicken Tomesto
Sautéed cutlets topped w/ sliced tomato & mozzarella cheese in an oil & garlic sauce w/ a touch of marinara
Chicken Alla AJ's
Sautéed w/ mushrooms, roasted peppers & artichoke hearts in an oil & garlic sauce w/ a touch of marinara
Chicken Rollatini
Fresh chicken cutlets stuffed w/ spinach, roasted peppers, mozzarella cheese & sautéed in a mushroom garlic sauce
Chicken Three Seasons
One piece breaded chicken cutlet, one piece breaded veal cutlet, two pieces breaded shrimp topped w/ marinara & mozzarella cheese
Chicken Parm Vodka Dinner
Chicken Parm Vodka Dinner
Grilled Chicken Parm Dinner
Veal Dinners
Veal Parmigiana
Breaded cutlets topped w/ marinara & mozzarella cheese
Veal Marsala
Sautéed w/ mushrooms in a Marsala wine sauce
Veal Francese
Dipped in egg batter & sautéed in a white wine lemon sauce
Veal Florentine
Sautéed w/ capers in a lemon sauce
Veal Piccata
Sautéed w/ capers in a lemon sauce
Veal Saltimbocca
Sautéed cutlets topped w/ spinach, prosciutto, & mozzarella cheese in an oil & garlic sauce w/ a touch of marinara
Veal Tomesto
Sautéed cutlets topped w/ sliced tomato & mozzarella cheese in an oil & garlic sauce w/ a touch of marinara
Veal Alla AJ's
Sautéed w/ mushrooms, roasted peppers & artichoke hearts in an oil & garlic sauce w/ a touch of marinara
Seafood Dinners
Shrimp Parmigana
Breaded shrimp topped w/ marinara & mozzarella
Shrimp Francese
Shrimp dipped in egg batter & sautéed in a white wine lemon sauce
Shrimp Scampi
Shrimp lightly breaded & sautéed in a garlic lemon sauce
Shrimp Marinara
Shrimp sautéed in a fresh marinara sauce
Shrimp Fra Diavlo
Shrimp sautéed w/ hot peppers in a fresh marinara sauce
Shrimp Vodka
Shrimp sautéed in a creamy pink vodka sauce
Shrimp & Broccoli Rabe
Shrimp sautéed in oil & garlic w/ a touch of marinara
Linguine with Clam Sauce
Served in a white or red sauce w/ fresh garlic over linguine
Mussels Over Linguine
Black shell mussels sautéed in fresh marinara (hot, medium or sweet)
Fried Calamari Over Linguine
Breaded calamari served in a fresh marinara sauce (hot, medium or sweet)
Zuppa Di Clams
Little neck clams served in a fresh marinara sauce or in a white scampi sauce
Zuppa Di Pesce
Mussels, clams, shrimp & calamari sautéed in a fresh marinara or white scampi sauce
Calamari Marinara
Calamari sautéed in a fresh marinara sauce
From The Grill
Grilled Cheese
Grilled Cheese
Gyro
All gyros come with lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki sauce
Grilled Chicken Gyro
All gyros come with lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki sauce
Grilled Chicken Gyro w/ Choice Of Cheese
All gyros come with lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki sauce
Steak Sandwich
Cheesesteak
Cheesesteak
Chicken Cheesesteak
Pizza Steak
Cheesesteak on Garlic Bread W Potato
w/ mozzarella cheese, potato & brown gravy
Steak, Egg, & Cheese
Steak, Egg, & Cheese
Burgers
Hamburger
Cheeseburger
Cheeseburger
Bacon Cheeseburger
Bacon Cheeseburger
Pizza Burger
Pizza Burger
Grilled Mushroom Swiss Burger
Grilled Mushroom Swiss Burger
Double Cheeseburger (16oz)
Double Cheeseburger (16oz)
Cowboy Burger
Burger topped w/ Swiss, jalapeños, BBQ sauce, onions & bacon
Mac & Cheese Burger
Burger topped w/ homemade mac & cheese & two beer-battered onion rings
Fat Burger #1
Burger w/ steak, steak fries, onions, American cheese & chipotle mayo
Fat Burger #2
Burger w/ french fries, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, American cheese & mayo
Create Your Own Fat Burger
Calzone
Cheese Calzone
Cheese Calzone
Ham & Cheese Calzone
Ham & Cheese Calzone
Chicken Calzone
Chicken Calzone
Buffalo Chicken Calzone
Steak Calzone
Veggie Calzone
Mushrooms, olives, peppers, onions, spinach & broccoli
Meat Lovers Calzone
Ham, bacon, pepperoni, meatballs & sausage
AJ's Special Calzone
Meatball, pepperoni, sausage, olives, extra cheese, bacon, fresh mushrooms, peppers and onions
Eggplant Calzone
Eggplant Calzone
Strombolis
Cheese Stromboli
Ham And Cheese Stromboli
Breaded Chicken Stromboli
Breaded Chicken Stromboli
Buffalo Chicken Stromboli
Buffalo Chicken Stromboli
Steak stromboli
Steak stromboli
Veggie Stromboli
Mushrooms, Olives, Peppers, Onions, Spinach, Broccoli
Meat Lovers Stromboli
Ham, Bacon, Pepperoni, Meatballs, Sausage
AJS Special Stromboli
Meatballs, Pepperoni, Sausage, Olives, Extra Cheese, Fresh Mushrooms, Peppers, Onions
Eggplant Stromboli
Grilled Chicken Stromboli
Rolls
Pepperoni Roll
Sausage Roll
Broccoli Roll
Broccoli Roll
Spinach Roll
Spinach Roll
Grilled Chicken Roll
Grilled Chicken Roll
Breaded Chicken Roll
Breaded Chicken Roll
Desserts
Cannoli
Carrot Cake
Cheesecake
Zeppoles (12)
Tiramisu Cup
Tartufo (Ice Cream)
Ice Cream
Chocolate Lovers Cake
Specialty Pizzas
*** Cheese Pizza ***
*** Margherita Pizza ***
*** Creamy Spinach Artichoke Pizza ***
Creamy alfredo sauce, artichoke hearts, spinach, and mozzarella cheese
*** Buffalo Chicken Pizza ***
***16" Sicilian Pizza***
*** Boom Boom Chicken Pizza ***
*** Penne Vodka Pizza ***
*** Vodka Sauce Pizza ***
*** Hawaiian Pizza ***
(Ham and pineapple)
*** Ground Beef Pizza ***
*** White Spinach or Broccoli Pizza ***
Mozzarella & Ricotta cheese
*** AJ's Special Pizza ***
Meatball, pepperoni, sausage, olives, extra cheese, bacon, fresh mushrooms, peppers & onions
*** 16" Grandma Pizza ***
Thin crust sicilian w/ fresh mozzarella, plum tomatoes, basil, olive oil & garlic
*** Chicken Vodka Pizza ***
*** Breaded Chicken Pizza ***
*** Tangy BBQ Chicken Pizza ***
*** Sweet BBQ Chicken Pizza ***
*** Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza ***
*** Chicken Francese Pizza ***
*** Sun-Dried Tomato Pizza ***
Mozzarella & Ricotta cheese
*** White Pizza ***
Mozzarella & Ricotta cheese
*** Eggplant Pizza ***
*** Eggplant Rollatini Pizza ***
*** Baked Ziti Pizza ***
*** Cheese Tortellini Alfredo Pizza ***
*** Shrimp Scampi Pizza ***
*** Plum Tomato & Basil Pizza ***
*** Bruschetta Pizza ***
*** Cheesesteak Pizza ***
Mushrooms, onions, peppers & potatoes
*** Cheesesteak Special Pizza ***
Steak, garlic butter, steak fries, mozzarella cheese, American cheese & brown gravy
*** Macaroni & Cheese Pizza ***
*** Fat AJ's Pizza ***
Our fresh dough topped w/ pizza sauce, steak, chicken fingers, french fries, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, mozzarella cheese, & American cheese
*** Pesto Pizza ***
*** Greek Pizza ***
Spinach, feta & mozzarella cheese
*** AJ's Veggie Pizza ***
Broccoli, olives, onions, mushrooms, peppers & spinach
*** AJ's Meat Lovers Pizza ***
(Meatballs, sausage, ham, bacon & pepperoni)
*** Grilled Chicken Pizza ***
Beverages
***Coke 2L.***
*** 20oz of Soda ***
*** Snapple ***
Mexican Coke********
Ajs Soda
Joe Tea
*** Boylans Soda ***
*** 20oz of Water ***
***Apple Juice***
*** Gatorade ***
*** Lemonade ***
*** Monster ***
*** Orange Juicev
*** Vitamin Waterv
***Can Of Sprite***
20 Oz Brisk Iced Tea
*** 18.5 oz Gold Peak Sweet Tea ***
Photos
+48 photos
+47 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Insanely good vodka sauce!!! Highly recommend the fries with vodka sauce and mozzarella!!! Anything here with vodka sauce is amazing!! I got disco fries, but next time def doing the vodka sauce fries. They have good pizza, amazing fat sandwiches which you don't find so often these days so I appreciate that!! And just overall I had a really good meal and experience here. I will be coming back for more vodka sauce haha!! MVP was good too!! Good vodka sauce good pesto which...
July 2026
Sonny the man. (Owner)
Thats my DUDE.
Humble, easy going guy.
He makes sure you have a pleasant experience.
So does his staff.
He’d be nothing w/o them 😉😎
Thats my DUDE.
Humble, easy going guy.
He makes sure you have a pleasant experience.
So does his staff.
He’d be nothing w/o them 😉😎
June 2026
Delivery was quick. The One-Bite app has this place at a 5.8. I have no idea why so low. I had delivery and there was still no flop. The crust was crunchy with a little chew. The only downside is the sauce was kind of bland. Tomatoey, but needed a little herbs/seasoning.
May 2026
You May Also Like
Panda World - 16 Main St
![]()
Chinese
Munchies - 139 Main St
![]()
Hamburger, Fast Food, American