Angeloni's Restaurant and Pizzeria

6 Brookside Ave, Caldwell
(973) 226-1234

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Michael Brick

Great all around. We are so lucky to have all these incredible restaurants near us.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Doering

This place is great. Amazing atmosphere and incredible food. The thinny thin is the BOMB! Don’t walk run here. Our waitress was sooo nice, ask for Veronica.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rafael Hernandez Jr

Great pizza! Looking forward to coming back and trying some of the other dishes.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Colleen Rose

New to the area and we had to try Angeloni's! The Thinny Thin pizza 100% lives up to the hype. We also got sandwiches and their prosciutto and mozz sandwich may be the best I have had in NJ! The prosciutto is thinly sliced, stacked thick, and is melt in your mouth! (None of that chewiness that some other places give)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

divid craig

the thincrust pizza was the BEST i ever had ...
thanks
77+ year old pizza lover...
its now my favorite pie place . & i have been around the block;::
the attitude of the peoples are great-

Ashleigh Fairfax

If I were on my deathbed, my only request would be a pepperoni pie from this place. I’ve put so many people onto it. (RIP Brook Tap House, but happy Angeloni’s will remain!)

I live in San Diego now, but every time I’m home, I get a pie (or two) and consider bringing some back in my suitcase…

Raimondo Isanali

Great place to eat

Premier Services

If you haven’t tried highly recommend

Nick Smiljanic

they need to be open when they say they are gonna be!

Cardinali Electric

Was sad to see them leave Wood Ridge , we enjoyed everything the service the place the food the pizza I thought was a 10 and now it’s a trip but we take it when we can .
If you like very thin pizza this is the best in my opinion and my family agrees.

Vincent Ranieri

Excellent food was delicious pizza was perfect. Canzone was to die for.

Peter Toriello

The amount of positive and impressive reviews on this food is overwhelming. It took me a very long time to finally go

This is a very busy location, I was prepared to wait..... I don't believe they were very well staffed inside. Not only did it take a very long time to order a couple of pasta dishes and one pizza, the group of seven waited for more than 45 minutes before our waitress came over and asked us how everything was.... She didn't even realize we had not even gotten our food

From what I was told, the pasta was better than good. I wanted the pizza. I got one large thinny thin... Better than good but nowhere near what other reviews have said. Somewhat disappointing but I would be willing to give it another try

Amit Hirani

Pizza is 10/10. Service is as well!!!

Diana Jishkariani

This was our first visit at Angeloni's restaurant. We walked in, it was Friday evening, and was packed, so we had to wait for about 30 minutes, but we're so eager to try their dishes, the wait definitely worth it. The reservation is highly recommended. Once you try, you will leave the place with confidence to go back again. 👍

Frankie Ferrante

Thinny thin with pepperoni - so good

Loading...

Angeloni's Restaurant and Pizzeria

6 Brookside Ave, Caldwell, NJ 07006
(973) 226-1234