$24 for a large plain pizza is ridiculous. I did not think it was worth it. And it wasn't even that good.
Joe Cummiskey
Always good!! Home for the holidays ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ENRICO MANCINI
Best pizza in cape may/wildwood area hands down and exactly what you want from a pizza place in terms of
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza
The Sm0ke Ninja
Best pizza in cape may/wildwood area hands down and exactly what you want from a pizza place in terms of
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Donna D.
Love this place! Pizza is very good! My go to spot when I am down the shore in Cape May.
Sarah G.
The customer service at this establishment is horrible. The interaction I had with the young man who answered the phone tonight is the reason I am writing a review! They get one star for the previous service I have received while ordering pizza from them. However, I don't know what has happened since! The young man on the phone wouldn't update me on my order nor provide his name so I can discuss it further with his manager. The manager on shift on 7/7/23 was no help and they were unable to tell me how to cancel my order nor would they refund the order. I will not be eating at this pizza shop anymore. Customer service is an important thing to possess while in the food service business. I hope the staff gets better and works towards understanding the customers concern instead of arguing with them!If you want to get good pizza in Cape May, do not waste your money at this establishment.
Doctor DeMento
This is our preferred Local "Pizza Parlor" as we say in South Jersey. Quality Pizzas with a wide variety of Toppings, tasty Appetizers and some of the best Salads you can get in a Pizzaria... but they keep where they buy their Lettuce a secret! The friendly Staff know like Family since we get Take-out there so regularly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Wings, Italian Wrap
Maryann Penza
The best cheesesteak in Cape May.
Food: 5
Dave Renner
Got a cheesesteak. Edible to say the least, roll to meat ratio and meat dry. Weird.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Matt Kittridge
Great service!! Driver went all the way back to the restaurant to get my wife ranch dressing that we forgot to ask for. Pizza was really good too. Very pleased. Thanks Cappy's.
Recently under new management and very lovely customer service! Had an amazing slice of margarita pizza 10/10 would go back again for lunch :)
Frank Y
I had contractors working in my house and I decided to buy them lunch. I ordered two large cheese pizzas for pick up. The pizza was fine. It’s hard to screw up cheese pizza. What I couldn’t believe was the price of $22 per pizza! Gouge much Capps? So with plus a 3% surcharge for my credit card and tax it cost me $48.50 for two cheese pizzas.
Tom Brown
In my opinion best pizza in Cape May. I stop to get the Buffalo chicken pizza always hot and saucy. I like the place so much that I have their limited-edition tie-dye shirts.
What a nice little pizza joint. I was craving some fast and simple pizza. This place delivers literally. I was pleased with the specialty Brooklyn style square pizza slices that I ordered and it felt like I stepped into a Time Machine. The last time I was in Cape May was for USCG basic training and what did they have on their smart TV? Usher's 2004 hit "Yeah!" featuring Lil Jon and Ludacris and then Mario & Scott Storch's "Let Me Love You". It felt like divine intervention as soon as I entered. This is the pizza place I'll be going to whenever I come back to Cape May.
Brian Craig
I stopped around lunch time for the slice special (still a very high price for pizza btw) and the pizza was beyond awful and borderline disgusting. I ordered my slices well done and was given sloppy tasteless soft mush on a plate. I wish I could find something good to say about it but there's nothing. I would not advise eating here!
$24 for a large plain pizza is ridiculous. I did not think it was worth it. And it wasn't even that good.
Always good!! Home for the holidays ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in cape may/wildwood area hands down and exactly what you want from a pizza place in terms of
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Best pizza in cape may/wildwood area hands down and exactly what you want from a pizza place in terms of
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Love this place! Pizza is very good! My go to spot when I am down the shore in Cape May.
The customer service at this establishment is horrible. The interaction I had with the young man who answered the phone tonight is the reason I am writing a review! They get one star for the previous service I have received while ordering pizza from them. However, I don't know what has happened since! The young man on the phone wouldn't update me on my order nor provide his name so I can discuss it further with his manager. The manager on shift on 7/7/23 was no help and they were unable to tell me how to cancel my order nor would they refund the order. I will not be eating at this pizza shop anymore. Customer service is an important thing to possess while in the food service business. I hope the staff gets better and works towards understanding the customers concern instead of arguing with them!If you want to get good pizza in Cape May, do not waste your money at this establishment.
This is our preferred Local "Pizza Parlor" as we say in South Jersey. Quality Pizzas with a wide variety of Toppings, tasty Appetizers and some of the best Salads you can get in a Pizzaria... but they keep where they buy their Lettuce a secret! The friendly Staff know like Family since we get Take-out there so regularly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Wings, Italian Wrap
The best cheesesteak in Cape May.
Food: 5
Got a cheesesteak. Edible to say the least, roll to meat ratio and meat dry. Weird.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Great service!! Driver went all the way back to the restaurant to get my wife ranch dressing that we forgot to ask for. Pizza was really good too. Very pleased. Thanks Cappy's.
Restaurantji Recommends
Recently under new management and very lovely customer service! Had an amazing slice of margarita pizza 10/10 would go back again for lunch :)
I had contractors working in my house and I decided to buy them lunch. I ordered two large cheese pizzas for pick up. The pizza was fine. It’s hard to screw up cheese pizza. What I couldn’t believe was the price of $22 per pizza! Gouge much Capps? So with plus a 3% surcharge for my credit card and tax it cost me $48.50 for two cheese pizzas.
In my opinion best pizza in Cape May. I stop to get the Buffalo chicken pizza always hot and saucy. I like the place so much that I have their limited-edition tie-dye shirts.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Chicken Cheesesteak, Wings, Cappy
What a nice little pizza joint. I was craving some fast and simple pizza. This place delivers literally. I was pleased with the specialty Brooklyn style square pizza slices that I ordered and it felt like I stepped into a Time Machine. The last time I was in Cape May was for USCG basic training and what did they have on their smart TV? Usher's 2004 hit "Yeah!" featuring Lil Jon and Ludacris and then Mario & Scott Storch's "Let Me Love You". It felt like divine intervention as soon as I entered. This is the pizza place I'll be going to whenever I come back to Cape May.
I stopped around lunch time for the slice special (still a very high price for pizza btw) and the pizza was beyond awful and borderline disgusting. I ordered my slices well done and was given sloppy tasteless soft mush on a plate. I wish I could find something good to say about it but there's nothing. I would not advise eating here!