Fine Fellows Creamery

313 Beach Ave, Cape May
(609) 854-7902

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tracy Lakota

UPDATE YOUR HOURS INSTEAD OF WASTING MY TIME

Don Riviello

I have a nut allergy. I love this place because the staff is very allergy conscious and they take whatever steps are needed to accommodate me and my issues. Is my favorite ice cream place anywhere. My wife has no allergy issues, and she loves it here too!

Dietary restrictions: I am allergic to nuts, but I always feel very safe getting ice cream here because they are very allergy conscious. Most ice cream places do not make the effort that these guys do. I really appreciate them.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mango Sorbet

Joelle

Came two nights in a row because we loved it so much! Delicious ice cream and great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vanessa Morales

A bit of a long line, but we expected that bc of the holiday weekend. Very good ice cream! Highly recommend and will be our Cape May ice cream spot now.

Vegetarian options: They have about 6 or more vegan ice cream options.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Donald Riviello

I am allergic to nuts. The staff here always goes out of their way to accommodate me and my allergy issues. I really appreciate them for that. And, the ice cream is great! So if you have allergies like me, this is your go to place!

twolightsabovethesea

There were three vegan flavors when I stopped. The vegan mint chip was creamy and delicious!

Kathy Velez

Absolutely delish and great owners and staff!!

Peter Nilax

This place is a very nice ice cream place. The ice cream isn’t as good as other shops in cape may, but it’s still good. The server was nice and helpful. The menu was organized. The decor was amazing. (Pink walls with chocolate like drips) there were also paper things hanging. The decor was fun and colorful. For the ice cream you get, it is a little overpriced, but in the end, worth it. I recommend the 16 candles milkshake. It tastes like birthday cake, but better. I recommend this place just to try out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Waffle Sundae, Choc Chip, Pisatchio and Scoop of Peanut Butter Cup, Blueberry Pomegranate Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream, Coca Colafloat, Banana Split

Delly Dell

So good went back for seconds

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thistle Cain

vegan ice cream in a gluten free waffle cone was a dream come true ? thank you!!

Dietary restrictions: vegan

Sherilyn Glose

Obsessed with the decor, told my husband it was like a manic dream sequence set in the 80’s. Rainbow floating lanterns and bright pink walls. Also the menu items are named after 70’s and 80’s pop icons - pretty fun!

My husband had some sort of pb&jelly shake and I got the vegan mint chocolate chip. Husband downed his shake rather quickly, and I cannot remember the last time I had mint chocolate chip ice cream! I cannot have dairy anymore so last time I had dairy ice cream was probably more than a decade ago. I asked the owner (?) what base they use and he said coconut cream! Usually you can tell because coconut has a pretty distinct flavor (which I don’t mind but some do) and I’ve tried every dairy alternative ice cream under the sun and when I tell you this tasted like the mint chocolate chip I remember as a kid, I’m not kidding!! He was very sweet and seemed happy I asked.

Also kudos to him because I was obsessed with his sparkly nail polish and the fact that he looked like a young Pedro Pascal! Next time we are in Cape May I hope to go back!

Vegetarian options: Vegan options

Dietary restrictions: Dairy free (listed as vegan) options!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christopher Lutz

It sucked.
Just kidding!
Customer service was great, bright and bubbly, plus cool views of the beach. Only place I've found that has vegan ice cream!
11/10! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fire Warrior

Gay cream is the best cream, they also have very good tacos with kitchen cabinets which is listed on the secret menu of google reviews, to get the secret menu you must ask the man with a mustache if you can get the sashimi swirl.

Vegetarian options: Theyve got the vegan ice cream which you can eat if you are intolerant towards lactose

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free cones for the weak and feeble theyre are slightly more cost but ive heard theyre alright

Parking: Dont even try to park it the street is full of cars because its a street, i had to bike to the place as the parkinf was none

Kid-friendliness: Well most the workers are kids so i would hope they are kid friendly

Wheelchair accessibility: Yeah you can peobably fit a wheelchair thru the dore but i think that keeping the parapeligic outside is more humane

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Waffle Sundae, Choc Chip, Pisatchio and Scoop of Peanut Butter Cup, Blueberry Pomegranate Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream, Coca Colafloat, Tacos & Kitchencabinetwarehouse Com, Banana Split

Gary Landis

One scoop of vegan vanilla in a cup, Two scoops of pistachio in a cup. $18.50. Outrageous. Gouging. Don't

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jace White

17$ for an ice cream called the LeFreak. Never going back

Loading...