Fine Fellows Creamery

313 Beach Ave, Cape May
(609) 854-7902

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Blueberry Pomegranate Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream

Pisatchio and Scoop of Peanut Butter Cup

Tacos & Kitchencabinetwarehouse Com

Coca Colafloat

Waffle Sundae

Banana Split

Mango Sorbet

Choc Chip

Photos

+47 photos

+46 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

My favorite Cape May ice cream shop! We've been stopping in every summer since they first opened. The ice cream is delicious (try the cherry vanilla) and it's even better in their homemade waffle cone. Besides having terrific ice cream, the service is always friendly and pleasant even when it's really busy.

July 2025

I have a nut allergy. I love this place because the staff is very allergy conscious and they take whatever steps are needed to accommodate me and my issues. Is my favorite ice cream place anywhere. My wife has no allergy issues, and she loves it here too!

Dietary restrictions: I am allergic to nuts, but I always feel very safe getting ice cream here because they are very allergy conscious. Most ice cream places do not make the effort that these guys do. I really...

September 2024

A bit of a long line, but we expected that bc of the holiday weekend. Very good ice cream! Highly recommend and will be our Cape May ice cream spot now.

Vegetarian options: They have about 6 or more vegan ice cream options.

September 2024

More Reviews

Restaurants in Cape May, NJ

Fine Fellows Creamery

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Fine Fellows Creamery