Mayer's Tavern

894 3rd Ave, Cape May
(609) 435-5078

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Harry Erney

Had dinner with the wife and daughter here Thursday night, 9/18/2025...
This was one of the best dinners we have ever had.
FIVE STAR everything at a very good price.
The oysters, the bluefish, the squid, the tile fish....Everything was fresh and prepared and presented perfectly.
And the wait staff even better.
Will be going back again for certain.
Thank you for a great experience...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

missey viatgliano

We had a birthday party last weekend, the food was amazing ! Service excellent. Everything was perfect ! Thank

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alex Kundrotas

They won’t give the customers what they want, i wouldn’t even crap here if i had to and if i did it would be a upper decker

Service: 1

Gail Wilsey Morrison

Delicious food, great service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mac and Cheese, Scallops with Cole Slaw & Fries

The Saint

What a disaster experience. We asked for crab cake and oysters to go. And was waiting for a long time. Mention to that lady manger on 8/30 pm. Shift she said ..oh ok.. is that how u answer to a guest who is waiting for food. Then best part is she got the crab cake and threw it. Here you go. What a disaster .. she does not belong in food and beverage...full blown disaster.. what a horrible person and a manager ! And guess what for the oyster we ordered never got that .. owner ..learn how to treat nice...learn how to hire manager who are not a racist garbage!
Learn! Disaster place ! I work for st regis where ppl spend over 3k in one setting.. what a low class and poor manager getting hired in this place and have no clue of customer service! ...what a shame ! Full blown Disaster garbage service! Grow up.. learn customer service !

John S

Scallops and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Scallops, Cheeseburger, Housemade Fries & Citrus Slaw, Salad, Crab Fritter, Burger, Brioche Bread Pudding

Tommy

What a great meal. Limited menu but everything very good. Incredible flavors with lots of attention to detail. The fried scallops were absolutely delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

oliver fegel

Everything is so good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Richard Scott

Great little place. Cant believe it took me this long to try it. Crab fritters were fantastic and the cilantro jalapeno dipping sauce was phenomenal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah York

Amazing meal. The small menu just means that everything they make is amazing. It was the best meal we have had in Cape May in years.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ryan Gallagher

One of my favorite things about this place is the small simple menu! I have to favorite hear and an honorable mention. Number 1, the delicious fried scallops! They're a must try. Number 2, the Burger is absolutely perfected, easily in my top 3 burgers. Third is the smoked fish dip for an appetizer(ask for some crackers on the side).

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Scallops, Burger

Lou Williams

The best mac and cheese ever

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mac “The Knife”

Pretty good. The lack of garnishes with the oysters and seafood tower was disappointing. No hot sauce, no horseradish, and stingy with crackers. There was also no bread served with the saucy steamed clams.All the little thoughtful touches were absent making the experience less than hospitable. It was cheapish for Cape May, I’d rather pay a couple extra bucks for a better effort.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

robin bodiroga

I love this place! Fresh food, delicious cocktails and fun wine.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Scallops, Fries

Gary Landis

Third visit and I think have eaten the whole menu. All the food is excellent. My favorite is chicken with yogurt and polenta and collards. Very limited menu but all the food is done right. Full bar, attentive staff, small dining room with outside seating in the summer.FUN, and near the water. Good vines,good wines. Had lovely Spanish white meritage.Today had a (new) appetizer--a great deconstructed salad with arugala fresh gold & red beets and wedge of GOOD blue cheese. Yummy

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...