Mayer's Tavern
894 3rd Ave, Cape May
(609) 435-5078
Customers' Favorites
Black Kale Salad w Yogurt Tahini & Seed Granola
Burger w Pickled Onion and Dijon Mayo
Fried Scallops w Fries & Citrus Slaw
Scallops with Cole Slaw & Fries
Housemade Fries & Citrus Slaw
Brioche Bread Pudding
Mac and Cheese
Crab Fritter
Cheeseburger
Menu
Photos
+27 photos
+26 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
One of my favorite things about this place is the small simple menu! I have to favorite hear and an honorable mention. Number 1, the delicious fried scallops! They're a must try. Number 2, the Burger is absolutely perfected, easily in my top 3 burgers. Third is the smoked fish dip for an appetizer(ask for some crackers on the side).
Pretty good. The lack of garnishes with the oysters and seafood tower was disappointing. No hot sauce, no horseradish, and stingy with crackers. There was also no bread served with the saucy steamed clams.All the little thoughtful touches were absent making the experience less than hospitable. It was cheapish for Cape May, I’d rather pay a couple extra bucks for a better effort.
You May Also Like
Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - 1216 NJ-109
![]()
Pizza, Pet Friendly
Lucky Bones Backwater Grille - 1200 NJ-109
![]()
American, Seafood, Bar, Gluten-Free, Vegan
Cinco De Mayo Mexican Restaurant - 1246 NJ-109
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian
This was one of the best dinners we have ever had.
FIVE STAR everything at a very good price.
The oysters, the bluefish, the squid, the tile fish....Everything was fresh and prepared and presented perfectly.
And the wait staff even better.
Will be going back again for certain.
Thank you for a great experience...