Mayer's Tavern

894 3rd Ave, Cape May
(609) 435-5078

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Black Kale Salad w Yogurt Tahini & Seed Granola

Burger w Pickled Onion and Dijon Mayo

Fried Scallops w Fries & Citrus Slaw

Scallops with Cole Slaw & Fries

Housemade Fries & Citrus Slaw

Brioche Bread Pudding

Mac and Cheese

Crab Fritter

Cheeseburger

Photos

+29 photos

+28 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Toasttab

Recent Reviews

Hostess was very pleasant and accommodating. In fact, she saw it taking the waiter a while to attend to me and she took and got my drink order. Waiter was basically ‘what’s your order, here’s your food’. $33 for a burger, shoestring fries and a 12 oz beer. Food was good. Nice, upscale pub. But a bit pricey for the overall experience.

November 2025

Great bar/restaurant usually! Except my last meal was so much money. Also they served a calamari dish that was like three overcooked rings and they cut up like 10 raw whole jalapeños and served it?! What the heck is that dish?! One of the craziest things I’ve ever been served in my life. Totally inedible.

September 2025

Had dinner with the wife and daughter here Thursday night, 9/18/2025...
This was one of the best dinners we have ever had.
FIVE STAR everything at a very good price.
The oysters, the bluefish, the squid, the tile fish....Everything was fresh and prepared and presented perfectly.
And the wait staff even better.
Will be going back again for certain.
Thank you for a great experience...

September 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Cape May, NJ

Mayer's Tavern

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Mayer's Tavern