Take out pizza cost $80 for 3 pies and it was by far the worst pizza I’ve ever had. Wet and soggy for two of the pies and completely overdone and chewy for the third. Do not recommend for pizza.
Food: 1
Logan Cuff
floppy, wet, undercooked pizza. I ordered the burrata pizza (vodka sauce, burrata, basil), and it was borderline inedible. I felt as though a massive quantity of vodka sauce was dumped over raw dough and served. The pomodoro and sausage pizzas were extremely floppy and wet as well. Do not consider ordering from this place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Vito Maffei
We went for Valentines night 4ppl ordered 3 apps salad was bad octopus was ok but our rice balls were frozen inside that was disgusting they must buy them frozen.. Meals were terrible my chicken parm and Gnocchi was the worse I ever had I had 1 bite and couldn't eat any more the Sunday dinner was also disgusting was thrown all out as an Italian this place doesn't care about quality especially on Valentines day . We would rate it a zero on food....our 2nd time there and will never return
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Robert Bozewski
Very good food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Victoria
I've driven past Panico 's Bistro so many times I decided it was time to give it a try. The food was delicious and the service was wonderful. Unfortunately, the noise level was deafening. I will probably get takeout from them in the future since the food was very good. However, I will never dine in the restaurant again.
Terry
My husband and I went to Panico's for salad and pizza! It is such a great spot and we absolutely loved the pizza!
chris
The only thing positive about our experience was our server, Savana. She was great; everything else was a very poor experience on NYE.
Kathy
Food as always was amazing! Waitress wasn't very good! Disappointed in service as we usual get a great waiter/waitress.
Carol Curry
I’ve been going to Panicos for years but last week was not good at all. The penne pasta tasted like it was reheated a million times so it was like eating paste. The sauce was so acidic I felt sick after the meal. The chicken parm burnt to death and my parents had veal that tasted like pork, also burned! We had a late reservation and the servers couldn’t wait for us to leave. I’ve been bragging to people about this place for years….thumbs down Panicos! I sent them an email and have not received a reply. Needless to say it was my husband’s birthday and not a cheap dinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 2
Renee
We had another great evening at Panico's!! Thanks to Savanna for being attentive and to Chef for a delicious meal!
Friendly and helpful staff food presented and served very professionally and on time would strongly recommend this Restaurant
Dorothea
My husband and I had dinner there last night. Dinner was delicious. I had the shrimp and crab with penne pasta in a garlic sauce. My husband had the spicy salmon over rice. We shared the pumpkin cheesecake for dessert. We enjoyed everything. We have been there many times and we will continue to patronize this establishment.
Carey
We love this Restaurant and actually came down from North Jersey for the weekend just to have dinner there. We love the ambience, but unfortunately for whatever reason we were escorted down to the basement of the church for dinner. Not sure if they were full upstairs or what, but we should've been told when he made the reservation as it was a totally different experience. The waiter was great. Food was great as expected, But the ambience was what you would've expected from a church basement. Italian food in New Jersey is a dime a dozen so if it wasn't for the nice ambience, we were expecting we would not have come. If you're making a reservation, make sure to ask where you will be sitting.  Food was great as expected,
Corinne
Have been coming here for many many years and finally ordered the brick oven pizza! Well it was the best Crust that I ever had, never mind the toppings!!! the Calamari was crispy and perfectly prepared! just perfect !
John DeQuattro
Had dinner tonight, dinner was excellent. Our server was excellent, I believe her name was Samantha. Gnocchi appetizer was spot on. My wife had the Snapper which she enjoyed. I had their pizza which was very good. Desert we took home, have not had yet.
Take out pizza cost $80 for 3 pies and it was by far the worst pizza I’ve ever had. Wet and soggy for two of the pies and completely overdone and chewy for the third. Do not recommend for pizza.
Food: 1
floppy, wet, undercooked pizza. I ordered the burrata pizza (vodka sauce, burrata, basil), and it was borderline inedible. I felt as though a massive quantity of vodka sauce was dumped over raw dough and served. The pomodoro and sausage pizzas were extremely floppy and wet as well. Do not consider ordering from this place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
We went for Valentines night 4ppl ordered 3 apps salad was bad octopus was ok but our rice balls were frozen inside that was disgusting they must buy them frozen..
Meals were terrible my chicken parm and Gnocchi was the worse I ever had I had 1 bite and couldn't eat any more the Sunday dinner was also disgusting was thrown all out as an Italian this place doesn't care about quality especially on Valentines day . We would rate it a zero on food....our 2nd time there and will never return
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Very good food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've driven past Panico 's Bistro so many times I decided it was time to give it a try. The food was delicious and the service was wonderful. Unfortunately, the noise level was deafening. I will probably get takeout from them in the future since the food was very good. However, I will never dine in the restaurant again.
My husband and I went to Panico's for salad and pizza! It is such a great spot and we absolutely loved the pizza!
The only thing positive about our experience was our server, Savana. She was great; everything else was a very poor experience on NYE.
Food as always was amazing! Waitress wasn't very good! Disappointed in service as we usual get a great waiter/waitress.
I’ve been going to Panicos for years but last week was not good at all. The penne pasta tasted like it was reheated a million times so it was like eating paste. The sauce was so acidic I felt sick after the meal. The chicken parm burnt to death and my parents had veal that tasted like pork, also burned! We had a late reservation and the servers couldn’t wait for us to leave. I’ve been bragging to people about this place for years….thumbs down Panicos! I sent them an email and have not received a reply. Needless to say it was my husband’s birthday and not a cheap dinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 2
We had another great evening at Panico's!! Thanks to Savanna for being attentive and to Chef for a delicious meal!
Restaurantji Recommends
Friendly and helpful staff food presented and served very professionally and on time would strongly recommend this Restaurant
My husband and I had dinner there last night. Dinner was delicious. I had the shrimp and crab with penne pasta in a garlic sauce. My husband had the spicy salmon over rice. We shared the pumpkin cheesecake for dessert. We enjoyed everything. We have been there many times and we will continue to patronize this establishment.
We love this Restaurant and actually came down from North Jersey for the weekend just to have dinner there. We love the ambience, but unfortunately for whatever reason we were escorted down to the basement of the church for dinner. Not sure if they were full upstairs or what, but we should've been told when he made the reservation as it was a totally different experience. The waiter was great. Food was great as expected, But the ambience was what you would've expected from a church basement. Italian food in New Jersey is a dime a dozen so if it wasn't for the nice ambience, we were expecting we would not have come. If you're making a reservation, make sure to ask where you will be sitting.  Food was great as expected,
Have been coming here for many many years and finally ordered the brick oven pizza! Well it was the best Crust that I ever had, never mind the toppings!!! the Calamari was crispy and perfectly prepared! just perfect !
Had dinner tonight, dinner was excellent. Our server was excellent, I believe her name was Samantha. Gnocchi appetizer was spot on. My wife had the Snapper which she enjoyed. I had their pizza which was very good. Desert we took home, have not had yet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...