We ordered 12 peace pies for Christmas Eve. Jessica was a pleasure to work with. The pies came packed well with dry ice. We love peace pies. Will definitely order more.
mark g-s
Banana Fosters was soooo good.
Carter Denny
I tried the chocolate peanut butter cookie dough and it was delicious. I would definitely return and recommend stopping!
Update: it’s December and 38 degrees and I stopped here for a second time today. It’s delicious. I tried the Elvis the second time.
Mark Bierman
amazing concept. could be a bit fresher
Sophie
Delicious ice cre sandwiches — must visit spot for any trip to Cape May
Marty
Part of me wishes this place were closer, but the other half of me is glad that it's not. I could eat this three times a day. Great little shop, I love the little window setup. Great staff and amazing ice cream flavors.
Amanda Martinez-Kirby
Love the choices and the super cute building!
Joe Fylypowycz
Fun ice cream sandwiches, great flavor combos, quick and easy service.
Daniel
Peace Pie in Cape May is a delightful treasure for anyone with a sweet tooth. My wife and I tried their Peanut Butter Brownie ice cream sandwich, and it was absolutely delicious. While I prefer a softer cookie, the crunchy ones they use held up well and still tasted fantastic.
I was impressed by the huge range of flavor options they offer. It’s clear they’ve put thought into creativity and quality. The shop is charming, the service was friendly and efficient, and the overall vibe fits perfectly within the Cape May dessert scene.
If you’re in Cape May and looking for a memorable treat, Peace Pie deserves a stop. We’ll certainly be back to try even more of their flavors.
Marcia Hershey
Best ice cream sandwiches ever!! A must stop, every visit to Cape May! Chocolate with raspberry ice cream is our favorite!
What can I say, the trip from Toms River was worth it, kids enjoyed every morsel and we’ve went back again without them 🫢😂 love this place!
A. V.
This was listed as one of the places to visit during our trip to Cape May, and also recommended by a work colleague. Glad we went. I personally got the Carmel Apple flavor and would have it again. It is vanilla ice cream with a hint of apple in every bite. Perfect.
Jose Quintanilla
Great ice cream sandwich located in a beautiful place. Parking is limited in high season but it worth to walk for this ice cream. The store has two windows for dispatch and they are very quick reducing people’s line.
Bern McC
Ice cream sandwich was good but not outstanding. Very hard to eat because its frozen solid. Staff wasn't very friendly. No seating. No trash cans nearby. I'd probably try somewhere else before going back to Peace Pie
John LaPalme
Best ice cream sandwich I have ever had, and that’s 63 years! Good service at window too.
We ordered 12 peace pies for Christmas Eve. Jessica was a pleasure to work with. The pies came packed well with dry ice. We love peace pies. Will definitely order more.
Banana Fosters was soooo good.
I tried the chocolate peanut butter cookie dough and it was delicious. I would definitely return and recommend stopping!
Update: it’s December and 38 degrees and I stopped here for a second time today. It’s delicious. I tried the Elvis the second time.
amazing concept. could be a bit fresher
Delicious ice cre sandwiches — must visit spot for any trip to Cape May
Part of me wishes this place were closer, but the other half of me is glad that it's not. I could eat this three times a day. Great little shop, I love the little window setup. Great staff and amazing ice cream flavors.
Love the choices and the super cute building!
Fun ice cream sandwiches, great flavor combos, quick and easy service.
Peace Pie in Cape May is a delightful treasure for anyone with a sweet tooth. My wife and I tried their Peanut Butter Brownie ice cream sandwich, and it was absolutely delicious. While I prefer a softer cookie, the crunchy ones they use held up well and still tasted fantastic.
I was impressed by the huge range of flavor options they offer. It’s clear they’ve put thought into creativity and quality. The shop is charming, the service was friendly and efficient, and the overall vibe fits perfectly within the Cape May dessert scene.
If you’re in Cape May and looking for a memorable treat, Peace Pie deserves a stop. We’ll certainly be back to try even more of their flavors.
Best ice cream sandwiches ever!!
A must stop, every visit to Cape May!
Chocolate with raspberry ice cream is our favorite!
Restaurantji Recommends
What can I say, the trip from Toms River was worth it, kids enjoyed every morsel and we’ve went back again without them 🫢😂 love this place!
This was listed as one of the places to visit during our trip to Cape May, and also recommended by a work colleague. Glad we went. I personally got the Carmel Apple flavor and would have it again. It is vanilla ice cream with a hint of apple in every bite. Perfect.
Great ice cream sandwich located in a beautiful place. Parking is limited in high season but it worth to walk for this ice cream. The store has two windows for dispatch and they are very quick reducing people’s line.
Ice cream sandwich was good but not outstanding. Very hard to eat because its frozen solid. Staff wasn't very friendly. No seating. No trash cans nearby. I'd probably try somewhere else before going back to Peace Pie
Best ice cream sandwich I have ever had, and that’s 63 years! Good service at window too.
Loading...