Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls

awesome definitely will be back!

The lobster was not fresh. And it has too many bones

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

The lobster mac n cheese was genuinely the best I’ve had in cape may. The lobster was salty and buttery and the mac was delicious! I can’t wait to come again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

just went to the sea isle city nj location. was very excited to try. 30.00 for extra lobster on 2 pieces of romaine lettuce. what’s joke not enough food for a 2 yr old. paid for extra lobster. i called the store after returning home and got some bs response. Will NEVER go back and will spread the word to avoid at all costs. This was an all time ripe off. Have to order a pizza. Terrible

A total rip off for the price and what little you get.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Classic Lobster Roll with blt

Great lobster rolls at a decent price!

Food: 5

I had the lobster without the roll. Very disappointed. No mayonnaise on the lobster. No flavor. I have had it in the past and it was excellent. I don’t know if I will go back The lobster MAC N cheese was not cheesy and it was watery. The spices on the lobster Mac n cheese killed it. Very disappointed. Also drove about 30 minutes just to eat there. What happened to the quality?

Very upset with Quincy’s. Order yesterday was TERRIBLE. It is just not the same. They charged $54 for 2 lobster mac and cheese and a lobster roll without the buns. The lobster Mac and cheese was spicy and soupy. It tasted like water not cheese. The lobster roll with out the bun only had pickles , no mayo , and seasoning. Long wait and customer service is terrible. They also are always sold out of lobster bisque and clam chowder. VERY UPSETTING ! ALL THAT MONEY WASTED. I DO NOT RECOMMEND !

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ordered a lobster roll, overall it was ok

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

The wife and I were out and about and decided to try the Waterside location in Lakewood Ranch Fl. I have to say im a bit of a critic because we have family in Maine and have tasted all ends of the spectrum of lobster rolls from amazing to terrible and this place makes a great Lobster rolls with a spot on price comparable to Maine and other restaurants in the area. The staff member we dealt with was super nice I wish I would have got his name, but I do know he was from Jersey and had great knowledge knew the product well. We had 2 Connecticut rolls and they were great. I would say this place is worth checking out. Theres only outdoor seating, but you can easily walk around waterside and find a spot to kick back and enjoy or walk out enjoy their outdoor seating and it will complement their lobster rolls very well. They also have nice little selection of beers/beverages and a whole N/A fridge too.

Fantastic lobster rolls & salads!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

According to chat gpt this is THE lobster roll place in Cape May… so 5 of us came for a late lunch… in the middle of shopping and dinning strip and a block away from the beach. Parking can be tricky… typical lobster roll place - no thrills hole in a wall. There are few options to pick from including lobster bisque, which my friends did try and liked.
3 rolls option - original , salad and Connecticut style. I decided to try Connecticut and Original. Nothing to complain about - fresh. Hit the spot but a star shy of 5 stars. Came with chips and a pickle. We are outside. Service was quick. Food was fresh.
WATCH OUT FOR SEAGULLS - they nearly stole our food - spiraled down and literally missed it by an inch…

Certainly would encourage you to try them - not too pricey… but dont expect Micheline style dining

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Small, but it’s only $20 for a lobster roll and they offer a deal on 4 rolls.

Outside seating only, with some sun protection but not a lot.

I had the Connecticut roll which was served warm, the bun was crispy, buttered and soft.

Food was prepared relatively quick.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Food is overpriced, overrated, and very small portions and looks nothing like pictures on their website. And pricing is higher than online prices. Never go again for any of it.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Super delicious!(: I got the original lobster roll.