First time and look forward to our next. My wife and I went for New Year’s Eve dinner. Very nice! Atmosphere warm and cozy, service spot on and food was excellent. They hit all the marks. Thank you for giving us a great experience and we wish you a wonderful and successful 2026! Mike & Ariane Schmidt
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donna
The food, and the service was great. The tables that were any place by the door were uncomfortable because every time someone came in or out the cold air would come in with them. Also no place for people to wait for their tables. It felt like they were right on top of some of the dinners
Renee
Went for lunch. It's NYE. Servious was slow but we wanted a leisurely lunch so it wasn't a problem. I think the staff was gearing up for tonight. All in all a great lunch. Had the crab cake tacos and the blackened chicken sandwich.
Erin Livesey
My family and I go to Tisha’s every time we’re in Cape May and it never disappoints - excellent service, food and atmosphere. We had Cat last night and in true Tisha’s fashion she was attentive, kind & personable. We’re already looking forward to our next visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joan
Best food for the money. First thing I do after I book our lodging I book my reservation at Tisha.
Paulette
Outstanding service Cat went out of her way to make us feel welcome She treated us and everyone around her like family She made excellent recommendations and came back to make sure we liked the food The ice water never ran out Nice atmosphere Just wanted to make sure that Cat is recognized for the outstanding person that she is Truly exceptional!!!!
Cynthia
Came highly recommended and were anticipating a nice meal. We were not disappointed. Everything was delicious and the service was excellent. Nicely paced. Looking forward to going again soon.
Katie G
Everyone, and I mean absolutely everyone, on the staff was friendly/professional. Filet Mignon was melt in your mouth perfection. Porkchop was insane (stole multiple bites of my partner’s). Our server Kat was knowledgeable, friendly, and made us feel like we were her only table. This is the kind of place you HAVE to come back to and work your way through the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rick W
Our group of 4 has a fantastic dinner here. Space is a little on the tight side but the service and food were top notch. Everyone's meal was excellent. The filet, pork chop and short ribs were served hot and tasted amazing. All 4 meals were perfect. Then to top it off, everyone had a different dessert and everyone loved their dessert which I often find can often be disappointing, but not here. All 4 of us talked about how good the dinner was on the ride home. We dined on a slow mid week early December night and the place filled up. I'd recommend making a reservation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa Wedemeyer
Food was amazing. Not an extensive menu but still a good selection. Pork chop dish was phenomenal! And desserts, which often disappoint, did not here! It was a super enjoyable meal, start to finish! Highly recommend!
There are several excellent foodie restaurants in Cape May but Tisha's has a happy welcoming vibe that makes it special. They have a back room for special occasions and outdoor seating when the weather is mild.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barbara Hagelgans
Our party of 4 had dinner at Tisha's before our Xmas trolley ride. Our friends had a much earlier ride than we did, but Denny, our wonderful server, got us served/checked out in plenty of time for our friends to meet the trolley. We love the food & ambience here, but Denny made sure that we were not late for our Xmas adventures. Thank you, Denny. Will ask for you next time!!💕🎄
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rit Ebert
Stopped in for lunch while visiting Cape May for the weekend and was placed in the back room and we wondered why everyone was eating with their winter coats on and then after a few mins realized it was about 55 degrees in that room. Too cold to enjoy your meal. Ended up ordering a Caesar salad with grilled chicken, chicken was ice cold. Blacken chicken sandwich was very bland. Won’t be back, too many other places to eat in Cape May that turn their heat on for customers.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 4
Matt Moccia
The staff was very friendly and the food was delicious. Highly recommend the chicken pasquale.
First time and look forward to our next. My wife and I went for New Year’s Eve dinner. Very nice! Atmosphere warm and cozy, service spot on and food was excellent. They hit all the marks.
Thank you for giving us a great experience and we wish you a wonderful and successful 2026!
Mike & Ariane Schmidt
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food, and the service was great. The tables that were any place by the door were uncomfortable because every time someone came in or out the cold air would come in with them. Also no place for people to wait for their tables. It felt like they were right on top of some of the dinners
Went for lunch. It's NYE. Servious was slow but we wanted a leisurely lunch so it wasn't a problem. I think the staff was gearing up for tonight. All in all a great lunch. Had the crab cake tacos and the blackened chicken sandwich.
My family and I go to Tisha’s every time we’re in Cape May and it never disappoints - excellent service, food and atmosphere. We had Cat last night and in true Tisha’s fashion she was attentive, kind & personable. We’re already looking forward to our next visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best food for the money. First thing I do after I book our lodging I book my reservation at Tisha.
Outstanding service Cat went out of her way to make us feel welcome She treated us and everyone around her like family She made excellent recommendations and came back to make sure we liked the food The ice water never ran out Nice atmosphere Just wanted to make sure that Cat is recognized for the outstanding person that she is Truly exceptional!!!!
Came highly recommended and were anticipating a nice meal. We were not disappointed. Everything was delicious and the service was excellent. Nicely paced. Looking forward to going again soon.
Everyone, and I mean absolutely everyone, on the staff was friendly/professional. Filet Mignon was melt in your mouth perfection. Porkchop was insane (stole multiple bites of my partner’s). Our server Kat was knowledgeable, friendly, and made us feel like we were her only table. This is the kind of place you HAVE to come back to and work your way through the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our group of 4 has a fantastic dinner here. Space is a little on the tight side but the service and food were top notch. Everyone's meal was excellent. The filet, pork chop and short ribs were served hot and tasted amazing. All 4 meals were perfect. Then to top it off, everyone had a different dessert and everyone loved their dessert which I often find can often be disappointing, but not here. All 4 of us talked about how good the dinner was on the ride home. We dined on a slow mid week early December night and the place filled up. I'd recommend making a reservation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was amazing. Not an extensive menu but still a good selection. Pork chop dish was phenomenal! And desserts, which often disappoint, did not here! It was a super enjoyable meal, start to finish! Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
There are several excellent foodie restaurants in Cape May but Tisha's has a happy welcoming vibe that makes it special. They have a back room for special occasions and outdoor seating when the weather is mild.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our party of 4 had dinner at Tisha's before our Xmas trolley ride. Our friends had a much earlier ride than we did, but Denny, our wonderful server, got us served/checked out in plenty of time for our friends to meet the trolley. We love the food & ambience here, but Denny made sure that we were not late for our Xmas adventures. Thank you, Denny. Will ask for you next time!!💕🎄
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in for lunch while visiting Cape May for the weekend and was placed in the back room and we wondered why everyone was eating with their winter coats on and then after a few mins realized it was about 55 degrees in that room. Too cold to enjoy your meal. Ended up ordering a Caesar salad with grilled chicken, chicken was ice cold. Blacken chicken sandwich was very bland. Won’t be back, too many other places to eat in Cape May that turn their heat on for customers.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 4
The staff was very friendly and the food was delicious. Highly recommend the chicken pasquale.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Pasquale, Fried Calamari
Lunch was delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Scallops Risotto
Loading...